Aromatic Ring Of Phenylalanine Research Articles

NMR Studies of Aromatic Ring Flips to Probe Conformational Fluctuations in Proteins.

Aromatic residues form a significant part of the protein core, where they make tight interactions with multiple surrounding side chains. Despite the dense packing of internal side chains, the aromatic rings of phenylalanine and tyrosine residues undergo 180° rotations, or flips, which are mediated by transient and large-scale "breathing" motions that generate sufficient void volume around the aromatic ring. Forty years after the seminal work by Wagner and Wüthrich, NMR studies of aromatic ring flips are now undergoing a renaissance as a powerful means of probing fundamental dynamic properties of proteins. Recent developments of improved NMR methods and isotope labeling schemes have enabled a number of advances in addressing the mechanisms and energetics of aromatic ring flips. The nature of the transition states associated with ring flips can be described by thermodynamic activation parameters, including the activation enthalpy, activation entropy, activation volume, and also the isothermal volume compressibility of activation. Consequently, it is of great interest to study how ring flip rate constants and activation parameters might vary with protein structure and external conditions like temperature and pressure. The field is beginning to gather such data for aromatic residues in a variety of environments, ranging from surface exposed to buried. In the future, the combination of solution and solid-state NMR spectroscopy together with molecular dynamics simulations and other computational approaches is likely to provide detailed information about the coupled dynamics of aromatic rings and neighboring residues. In this Perspective, we highlight recent developments and provide an outlook toward the future.

Zein Nanoparticles Containing Arginine-Phenylalanine-Based Surfactants: Stability, Antimicrobial and Hemolytic Activity

Although cationic surfactants have a remarkable antimicrobial activity, they present an intrinsic toxicity that discourages their usage. In this work novel zein nanoparticles loaded with arginine-phenylalanine-based surfactants are presented. The nanoparticles were loaded with two single polar head (LAM and PNHC12) and two with double amino acid polar head surfactants, arginine-phenylalanine (C12PAM, PANHC12). The formulations were characterized and their stability checked up to 365 days. Furthermore, the antimicrobial and hemolytic activities were investigated. Finally, NMR and molecular docking studies were carried out to elucidate the possible interaction mechanisms of surfactant-zein. The nanoparticles were obtained with satisfactory size, zeta potential and dispersibility. The surfactants containing arginine-phenylalanine residues were found to be more stable. The nanoencapsulation maintained the antimicrobial activities unaltered in comparison to the surfactants' solutions. These results are in agreement with the NMR and docking findings, suggesting that zein interacts with the surfactants by the aromatic rings of phenylalanine. As a result, the cationic charges and part of the aliphatic chains are freely available to attack the bacteria and fungi, while not available to disrupt the cellular membranes. This approach opens new possibilities for using cationic surfactants and benefits from their extraordinary antimicrobial responses for several applications.

ESR1 F404 mutations and acquired resistance to fulvestrant in the plasmaMATCH study.

1009 Background: The selective estrogen receptor modulator (SERD) fulvestrant is commonly used to treat patients with hormone receptor positive advanced breast cancer, although potential mechanisms of acquired resistance are poorly understood. plasmaMATCH cohort A (NCT03182634) investigated the activity of fulvestrant in patients with activating ESR1 mutations in circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). Here we present analysis of baseline and end-of-treatment (EOT) ctDNA to identify potential resistance mutations to fulvestrant. Methods: Paired baseline and EOT plasma samples from patients enrolled into plasmaMATCH underwent ctDNA sequencing (Guardant360, Guardant Health) to identify acquired mutations. For F404 analysis, MCF-7 cells were transiently transfected with estrogen receptor expression constructs containing either wildtype ESR1 (WT), single ESR1 mutations (D538G, E380Q, F404L), or compound mutations (D538G_F404L, E380Q_F404L), alongside an estrogen response element (ERE)-luciferase reporter construct. Transfected cells were treated with or without fulvestrant and ERE-luciferase activity compared. Results: Of 84 patients enrolled in cohort A, 69 had paired baseline and EOT sequencing. Patients with baseline ESR1 Y537S had shorter progression free survival (PFS), and Y537C longer PFS, than those wild-type for each respective mutation (p = 0.03 and p = 0.04). Patients frequently acquired mutations at EOT (n = 35, 51%), including potentially targetable mutations in 25% (including 3 PTEN, 3 BRCA1/2, 2 PIK3CA, 2 HER2, 1 BRAF). Three (4%) patients acquired ESR1 p.F404 mutations (F404L, F404I, F404V), with 7 mutations in total. Of 26 patients with PFS of ≥16 weeks, 3 patients (12%) acquired ESR1 F404. In 800 patients screened for entry to plasmaMATCH, one harbored a F404 mutation (0.13%), with a prior history of fulvestrant. F404 mutations resided in cis with E380Q in 6/7 assessable mutations. In vitro structural modelling revealed that ESR1 p.F404 resides within the ESR1 ligand binding domain, and contributes to estrogen and fulvestrant binding through a pi-stacking bond between the aromatic ring of phenylalanine and estrogen/fulvestrant, with all F404 mutations disrupting this bond. Transient transfection demonstrated that single mutations D538G, E380Q, F404L and wild-type ESR1 were sensitive to fulvestrant (p < 0.0001, p = 0.0006, p = 0.04 and p = 0.0001), whereas compound mutations D538G_F404L and E380Q_F404L were resistant. Further investigation of relative sensitivity of the F404 mutant ESR1 to other anti-estrogens will be presented. Conclusions: We have identified a novel resistance mechanism to fulvestrant, with F404 mutations acquired in patients with pre-existing activating ESR1 mutations. F404 confers fulvestrant resistance through the loss of a pi-stacking bond and likely reduced fulvestrant binding affinity, identifying a new potential target to overcome endocrine therapy resistance.

Fluorinated diphenylalanine analogue based supergelators: a stencil that accentuates the sustained release of antineoplastic drugs

ABSTRACT Inspired by the prolonged metabolism displayed by para substituted fluorinated drugs, we intended to design two isomers Fmoc-(4F)-Phe-Phe-OH (hydrogelator I) & Fmoc-(3F)-Phe-Phe-OH (hydrogelator II) to explore the propensity of fluorine substitution in the aromatic ring of phenylalanine, in assisting or disrupting the gelation phenomena. However, our experimental observation reveals that hydrogelator I and II containing fluorines in the aromatic core illustrates excellent hydrogelation ability in comparison to the unsubstituted analogue, in accordance with the computational findings. Indeed, the hydrogelators displayed b-sheet with a fibrillar tape like morphology and were found to be biocompatible. We developed hydrogel nanoparticles (HNPs) that exhibited particle size less than 200 nm, and were found to release the antineoplastic drugs, 5Fluorouracil, curcumin and doxorubicin in a sustained manner depending on the architectural parameters of the drugs. Thus the prospective use of these compounds holds immense promise as a potential tool for future drug delivery applications.

Effects of Cold Jet Atmospheric Pressure Plasma on the Structural Characteristics and Immunoreactivity of Celiac-Toxic Peptides and Wheat Storage Proteins.

The present research reported the effects of structural properties and immunoreactivity of celiac-toxic peptides and wheat storage proteins modified by cold jet atmospheric pressure (CJAP) plasma. It could generate numerous high-energy excited atoms, photons, electrons, and reactive oxygen and nitrogen species, including O3, H2O2, •OH, NO2− and NO3− etc., to modify two model peptides and wheat storage proteins. The Orbitrap HR-LC-MS/MS was utilized to identify and quantify CJAP plasma-modified model peptide products. Backbone cleavage of QQPFP and PQPQLPY at specific proline and glutamine residues, accompanied by hydroxylation at the aromatic ring of phenylalanine and tyrosine residues, contributed to the reduction and modification of celiac-toxic peptides. Apart from fragmentation, oxidation, and agglomeration states were evaluated, including carbonyl formation and the decline of γ-gliadin. The immunoreactivity of gliadin extract declined over time, demonstrating a significant decrease by 51.95% after 60 min of CJAP plasma treatment in vitro. The CJAP plasma could initiate depolymerization of gluten polymer, thereby reducing the amounts of large-sized polymers. In conclusion, CJAP plasma could be employed as a potential technique in the modification and reduction of celiac-toxic peptides and wheat storage proteins.

Cyclopeptide Dmt-[D-Lys-p-CF3-Phe-Phe-Asp]NH2, a novel G protein-biased agonist of the mu opioid receptor

Opioid peptides and alkaloid drugs such as morphine, mediate their analgesic effects, but also undesired side effects, mostly through activation of the mu opioid receptor which belongs to the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) family. A new important pharmacological concept in the field of GPCRs is biased agonism. Two mu receptor ligands, Dmt-c[D-Lys-Phe-Phe-Asp]NH2 (C-36) and Dmt-c[D-Lys-Phe-p-CF3-Phe-Asp]NH2 (F-81), were evaluated in terms of their ability to promote or block mu receptor/G protein and mu receptor/β-arrestin interactions. Using the bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) assay it was shown that C-36 activated both, G protein and β-arrestin pathways. Incorporation of trifluoromethyl group into the aromatic ring of phenylalanine in the sequence of F-81 led to activation of G-protein pathway rather than β-arrestin recruitment. Opioid cyclopeptide F-81 turned out to be a biased G protein mu receptor agonist. Such biased ligands are able to separate the biological actions of an activated receptor and have the potential to become more effective drug candidates with fewer side effects.

Structural modification of P-glycoprotein induced by OH radicals: Insights from atomistic simulations.

This study reports on the possible effects of OH radical impact on the transmembrane domain 6 of P-glycoprotein, TM6, which plays a crucial role in drug binding in human cells. For the first time, we employ molecular dynamics (MD) simulations based on the self-consistent charge density functional tight binding (SCC-DFTB) method to elucidate the potential sites of fragmentation and mutation in this domain upon impact of OH radicals, and to obtain fundamental information about the underlying reaction mechanisms. Furthermore, we apply non-reactive MD simulations to investigate the long-term effect of this mutation, with possible implications for drug binding. Our simulations indicate that the interaction of OH radicals with TM6 might lead to the breaking of C-C and C-N peptide bonds, which eventually cause fragmentation of TM6. Moreover, according to our simulations, the OH radicals can yield mutation in the aromatic ring of phenylalanine in TM6, which in turn affects its structure. As TM6 plays an important role in the binding of a range of cytotoxic drugs with P-glycoprotein, any changes in its structure are likely to affect the response of the tumor cell in chemotherapy. This is crucial for cancer therapies based on reactive oxygen species, such as plasma treatment.

Development of a Vibrational Hydration Ruler

Amino acids covalently modified with spectroscopic reporters offer the potential to probe local protein hydration with high spatial and temporal resolution when coupled with the appropriate spectroscopic technique. Three azidophenylalanine residues have been synthesized and, in combination with the commercially available 4-azido-L-phenylalanine, form a series of unnatural amino acids (UAAs) containing the azide vibrational reporter at varying distances from the aromatic ring of phenylalanine. The azide vibrational reporter was selected due to the position, sensitivity and extinction coefficient of the azide asymmetric stretch vibration. The sensitivity of the azide reporters for these UAAs was investigated in solvents that mimic distinct local protein environments. Three of the four azido modified phenylalanine residues were successfully genetically incorporated into a surface site in superfolder green fluorescent protein (sfGFP) utilizing an engineered, orthogonal aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase in response to an amber codon with high efficiency and fidelity. The site-specific incorporation of these UAAs was verified by SDS-PAGE and ESI-Q-TOF mass analysis. IR spectroscopy was then utilized to probe the protein hydration state for the azide group in these sfGFP constructs.

Synthesis and biological evaluation of new active For‐Met‐Leu‐Phe‐OMe analogues containing para‐substituted Phe residues

In the present study, we report synthesis and biological evaluation of the N-Boc-protected tripeptides 4a-l and N-For protected tripeptides 5a-l as new For-Met-Leu-Phe-OMe (fMLF-OMe) analogues. All the new ligands are characterized by the C-terminal Phe residue variously substituted at position 4 of the aromatic ring. The agonism of 5a-l and the antagonism of 4a-l (chemotaxis, superoxide anion production, lysozyme release as well as receptor binding affinity) have been examined on human neutrophils. No synthesized compounds has higher activity than the standard fMLF-OMe tripeptide to stimulate chemotaxis, although compounds 5a and 5c with -CH(3) and -C(CH(3))(3), respectively, in position 4 on the aromatic ring, are better than the standard tripeptide to stimulate the production of superoxide anion, in higher concentration. Compounds 4f and 4i, containing -F and -I in position 4, respectively, on the aromatic ring of phenylalanine, exhibit significant chemotactic antagonism. The influence of the different substitution at the position 4 on the aromatic ring of phenylalanine is discussed.

Temperature dependent 2nd derivative absorbance spectroscopy of aromatic amino acids as a probe of protein dynamics

Proteins display a broad peak in 250-300 nm region of their UV spectrum containing multiple overlapping bands arising from the aromatic rings of phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan residues. Employing high resolution 2(nd) derivative absorbance spectroscopy, these overlapping absorption bands can be highly resolved and therefore provide a very sensitive measure of changes in the local microenvironment of the aromatic side chains. This has traditionally been used to detect both subtle and dramatic (i.e., unfolding) conformational alterations of proteins. Herein, we show that plots of the temperature dependent 2(nd) derivative peak positions of aromatic residues have measurable slopes before protein unfolding and that these slopes are sensitive to the dielectric properties of the surrounding microenvironment. We further demonstrate that these slopes correlate with hydration of the buried aromatic residues in protein cores and can therefore be used as qualitative probes of protein dynamics.

Metal ligand aromatic cation-pi interactions in metalloproteins: ligands coordinated to metal interact with aromatic residues.

Cation-pi interactions between aromatic residues and cationic amino groups in side chains and have been recognized as noncovalent bonding interactions relevant for molecular recognition and for stabilization and definition of the native structure of proteins. We propose a novel type of cation-pi interaction in metalloproteins; namely interaction between ligands coordinated to a metal cation--which gain positive charge from the metal--and aromatic groups in amino acid side chains. Investigation of crystal structures of metalloproteins in the Protein Data Bank (PDB) has revealed that there exist quite a number of metalloproteins in which aromatic rings of phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan are situated close to a metal center interacting with coordinated ligands. Among these ligands are amino acids such as asparagine, aspartate, glutamate, histidine, and threonine, but also water and substrates like ethanol. These interactions play a role in the stability and conformation of metalloproteins, and in some cases may also be directly involved in the mechanism of enzymatic reactions, which occur at the metal center. For the enzyme superoxide dismutase, we used quantum chemical computation to calculate that Trp163 has an interaction energy of 10.09 kcal mol(-1) with the ligands coordinated to iron.

A ternary complex of carbonic anhydrase: X-ray crystallographic structure of the adduct of human carbonic anhydrase II with the activator phenylalanine and the inhibitor azide

The first X-ray structure of a ternary adduct of human carbonic anhydrase II with the activator phenylalanine and the inhibitor azide is reported. Confirming what is suggested by spectroscopic data on the Co(II) derivative of HCA II, the phenylalanine molecule does not interact with zinc and it is positioned in the hydrophobic region of the active site cavity, similarly to what is observed for histamine, the first activator for which the X-ray crystallographic structure has been reported. The aromatic ring of phenylalanine is pointed towards the cavity opening while its amino group is involved in a strong hydrogen bond with a water molecule which, on the other hand, interacts with a zinc-bound azide anion. This result provides further support for the existence of an ‘activator binding site’ in the HCA II cavity which allows the binding of compounds able to provide alternative proton transfer pathways from the zinc-bound water molecule to the bulk solvent.

New aspects of weak CH⋯π bonds: intermolecular interactions between alicyclic and aromatic rings in crystals of small compounds, peptides and proteins

The geometry of intermolecular contacts between alicyclic and aromatic rings in a number of crystal structures suggests an attractive interaction between the rings. An analysis of molecular packing of 444 different crystal structures collected in the Cambridge Structural Database shows that phenyl…cyclohexanonyl, cyclohexyl, and/or cyclopentyl ring interactions occur in 59–82% of studied crystals. Similar interactions are observed between aromatic rings and heterocyclic pyrrolidine rings of proline in peptides and proteins. An analysis of data collected in the Brookhaven Protein Data Bank reveals that interactions between proline CH groups and aromatic rings of phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan as acceptors are frequently observed in proteins. Based on these results, several geometric models of these interactions are proposed. Two of these models are fully optimized using quantum chemical calculations at the density functional theory level. Calculated energies suggest that the most important interaction between the cyclohexanone and benzene rings is described by the face-to-face model, in which three axial hydrogen atoms are directed toward the aromatic partner.

Amino acid- and pterin-metal chemistry as an approach to biological functions

Abstract

A structural model of the tetrodotoxin and saxitoxin binding site of the Na+ channel

Biophysical evidence has placed the binding site for the naturally occurring marine toxins tetrodotoxin (TTX) and saxitoxin (STX) in the external mouth of the Na+ channel ion permeation pathway. We developed a molecular model of the binding pocket for TTX and STX, composed of antiparallel beta-hairpins formed from peptide segments of the four S5-S6 loops of the voltage-gated Na+ channel. For TTX the guanidinium moiety formed salt bridges with three carboxyls, while two toxin hydroxyls (C9-OH and C10-OH) interacted with a fourth carboxyl on repeats I and II. This alignment also resulted in a hydrophobic interaction with an aromatic ring of phenylalanine or tyrosine residues for the brainII and skeletal Na+ channel isoforms, but not with the cysteine found in the cardiac isoform. In comparison to TTX, there was an additional interaction site for STX through its second guanidinium group with a carboxyl on repeat IV. This model satisfactorily reproduced the effects of mutations in the S5-S6 regions and the differences in affinity by various toxin analogs. However, this model differed in important ways from previously published models for the outer vestibule and the selectivity region of the Na+ channel pore. Removal of the toxins from the pocket formed by the four beta-hairpins revealed a structure resembling a funnel that terminated in a narrowed region suitable as a candidate for the selectivity filter of the channel. This region contained two carboxyls (Asp384 and Glu942) that substituted for molecules of water from the hydrated Na+ ion. Simulation of mutations in this region that have produced Ca2+ permeation of the Na+ channel created a site with three carboxyls (Asp384, Glu942, and Glu1714) in proximity.

A topochemical approach to explain morphiceptin bioactivity.

A topochemical model to explain the bioactivity of morphiceptin (Tyr1-Pro2-Phe3-Pro4-NH2) was developed by taking account of accessible conformations around rotatable bonds which define relative spatial arrangements of opioid pharmacophores, the amine and phenolic groups of tyrosine and the aromatic ring of phenylalanine, necessary for receptor recognition. For this purpose, 1H-NMR measurements and computer simulations were extensively carried out on 10 stereoisomeric analogs related to morphiceptin: Tyr-Pro-(L and D)-Phe- (L and D)-Pro-NH2; Tyr-Pro-(L and D)-(NMe)Phe-(L and D)-Pro-NH2; Tyr-(NMe)Ala-Phe-D-Pro-NH2; and Tyr-Ala-Phe-D-Pro-NH2. These analogs are structurally close to one another but display various opiate potencies from highly active to inactive. The conformation of each rotatable bond has been specifically identified by measuring accessible space for the analogs, in which the difference in composition is observed in the specific site affecting only the conformation around the target bond. The most interesting characteristic of the model is a requirement of a cis amide bond linking residues 1 and 2. The model also requires the side chains in a trans conformation (chi 1 = 180 degrees) for the Tyr and Phe residues. The distances between the three pharmacophores, d1 (Tyr N to Tyr OH), d2 (Tyr N to the center of the aromatic ring of the third residue), and d3 (Tyr OH to the center of the aromatic ring of the third residue), were found to be approximately 8, approximately 7, and approximately 11-13 A, respectively. This model should aid in pharmaceutical design of peptide and nonpeptide ligands with opioid potencies.

Structural studies of metalloporphyrins. Part XI: Complexes of water-soluble zinc(II) porphyrins with amino acids: Influence of ligand-ligand interactions on the stability of the complexes

The stability constants of a series of complexes of the cationic water-soluble porphyrin ZnTMPyP with various amino acids have been determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy at pH 10.5. The following stability order has been observed: Tyr greater than Phe, Glu greater than Asp greater than Ile greater than Val greater than Gly. These results can be best rationalized by invoking complex stabilization due to ligand-ligand (e.g., stacking or electrostatic) interactions. Evidence for stacking interactions between the porphyrin ring and the aromatic ring of phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan was further provided by study of the complexation of these amino acids with the free-base porphyrin TMPyPH2. In this case, complexation constants increased in the order: Phe less than Tyr less than Trp. Attempts to form complexes of the amino acids with the anionic porphyrin ZnTCPP proved unsuccessful, indicating that electrostatic interactions play a major role in the stability of the zinc porphyrin-amino acids complexes.

Structure-activity relationship studies on cholecystokinin: analogues with partial agonist activity

In the present study, hepta- and octapeptide analogues of the C-terminal part of cholecystokinin, modified on the C-terminal phenylalanine residue, were synthesized. CCK analogues were prepared in which the peptide bond between aspartic acid and phenylalanine had or had not been modified and were lacking the C-terminal primary amide function. These CCK derivatives were able to cause full stimulation of amylase release from rat pancreatic acini but without a decrease in amylase release at supramaximal concentrations. There was a close relationship between the abilities of these derivatives to stimulate amylase release and their abilities to inhibit binding of 125I-BH-CCK-9 to CCK receptors on rat and guinea pig pancreatic acini. These CCK analogues were also able to recognize the guinea pig brain CCK receptors, some of them being particularly potent. The findings indicate that the aromatic ring of phenylalanine is important for the binding to brain and pancreatic CCK receptors, whereas the C-terminal primary amide function is not essential for the binding to pancreatic CCK receptors but is crucial for biological activity of rat pancreatic acini.

Synthesis and analysis of tritiated neuropeptides

AbstractThe synthesis, purification and analysis of three tritiated neuropeptides are described. Org 2766 (an ACTH (4‐9) analogue) and Org GK 78 (des‐Tyr‐γ‐endorphin) were labelled in the aromatic ring of phenylalanine by catalytic deiodination of the (p‐iodophenyl)alanine precursors using 3H2.Org 5878 (des‐enkephalin‐γ‐endorphin) was labelled in the lysine residue by reduction of the L‐2,6‐diamino‐4‐hexynoic acid‐containing analogue with 3H2. The peptides were purified by preparative HPLC using ammonium acetate buffer systems. The chemical purity was determined by 1H NMR, the radiochemical purity was measured by HPLC and the 3H distribution by 3H NMR. Specific activities (as determined by HPLC) were ca. 900 GBq mmol−1 for Org 2766 and Org GK 78 and 1400 GBq mmol−1 for Org 5878.

Biosynthesis of phenylalanine, tyrosine, 3-(3-carboxyphenyl)alanine and 3-(3-carboxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)alanine in higher plants: Examples of the transformation possibilities for chorismic acid

14C-labelled shikimic acid and double labelled shikimic acid tritiated stereospecifically at C-6 are incorporated into 3-(3-carboxyphenyl)alanine, 3-(3-carboxyl-4-hydroxyphenyl)alanine, phenylalanine, and tyrosine in Resda lutea L., Reseda odoratta L., Iris x Hollandica cv. Prof. Blauw, and Iris x hollandica cv. Wedgwood. The experiments with 14C-labelled shikimic acid confirm that the aromatic carboxyl groups and rings in 3-(3-carboxyphenyl)-alanine and 3-(3-carboxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)alanine derive from the carboxyl group and ring in shikimic acid whereas the experiments with double labelled shikimic acid demonstrate that the pro-6S-hydrogen atom is retained and the pro-6R-hydrogen atom lost in the biosynthesis of 3-(3-carboxyphenyl)alanine, phenylalanine, and tyrosine in the plants used. 3H was located in the ortho-position in the aromatic rings of phenylalanine and tyrosine but in a position para to the alanine side chain of 3-(3-cabroxyphenyl)alanine. No 3H was found in 3-(3-carboxy-4-hydroxyphenyl)alanine. This supports a derivation of the last two compounds from chorismic acidvia isochorismic acid, isoprephenic acid, and 3′-carboxyphenylpyruvic acid and 3′-carboxy-4′-hydroxyphenylpyruvic acid. The 3H/14 C ratio in 3-(3-carboxyphenyl)alanine was found higher than in the precursor used. This isotope effect must operate by competition between the pathways from isoprephenic acid to 3′-carboxyphenylpyruvic acid and to 3′-carboxy-4′-hydroxyphenylpyruvic acid. The proposed biosynthetic pathways for the two carboxy-substituted amino acids are in agreement with their distribution patterns in the plant kingdom and suggest that they may derive from minor changes of enzymes involved in the general pathways of aromatic biosynthesis.