Abstract Density functional quantum chemical methods are used to predict the thermodynamics of disproportionation of electrochemically generated polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon radical anions ( 2 ) into the corresponding neutral species ( 1 ) and dianions ( 3 ). The computations reveal the overwhelming influence of solvation effects upon the disproportionation equilibrium. By comparison, the effect of ion pairing between 3 and the cation of the supporting electrolyte (R 4 N + ) is modest but real. The computational results can be combined with a variety of entropy effects to calculate the spacing Δ E between the first and second reduction potentials of 1 within 100–150 mV. The highly asymmetric structures of the ion pairs between 3 and R 4 N + show little evidence for steric hindrance to ion pairing, yet the computations do show that the strength of the ion pairs does appear to diminish with increasing size of the R group. The strength of the ion pairs with small cations appears to arise out of the large charge-to-size ratio in such cations.