Archival Photographic Plates Research Articles

Investigation of WZ Sge-type Dwarf Nova ASASSN-19oc: Optical Spectroscopy and Multicolor Light Curve Analysis

In this study, we present an investigation of the newly discovered dwarf nova ASASSN-19oc during its superoutburst on 2019 June 2. We carried out detailed UBVR c I c -photometric observations and also obtained a spectrum on day 7 of the outburst, which shows the presence of hydrogen absorption lines commonly found in dwarf nova outbursts. Analysis of photometric data reveals the occurrence of early superhumps in the initial days of observations, followed by ordinary and late superhumps. We have accurately calculated the period of the ordinary superhumps as P ord = 0.05681(10) days and determined the periods at different stages, as well as the rate of change of the superhump period (P dot = Ṗ /P = 8.1 × 10−5). Additionally, we have derived the mass ratio of the components (q = 0.09), and estimated the color temperature during the outburst as ∼11,000 K, the distance to the system (d = 560 pc) and absolute magnitude of the system in outburst (M V = 5.3). We have shown that outbursts of this star are very rare: based on brightness measurements on 600 archival photographic plates, we found only one outburst that occurred in 1984. This fact, as well as the properties listed above, convincingly shows that the variable ASASSN-19oc is a dwarf nova of WZ Sge type.

Blast from the past: constraining progenitor models of SN 1972E

ABSTRACT We present a novel technique to study Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) by constraining surviving companions of historical extragalactic SN by combining archival photographic plates and Hubble Space Telescope(HST) imaging. We demonstrate this technique for Supernova 1972E, the nearest known SN Ia in 125 yr. Some models of SNe Ia describe a white dwarf with a non-degenerate companion that donates enough mass to trigger thermonuclear detonation. Hydrodynamic simulations and stellar evolution models show that these donor stars will survive the explosion, and show increased luminosity for at least a 1000 yr. Thus, late-time observations of the exact location of a supernova can constrain the presence of a surviving donor star and progenitor models. We find the explosion site of SN 1972E by analysing 17 digitized photographic plates taken with the European Southern Observatory 1-m Schmidt and 1 plate taken with the Cerro Tololo Inter-American Observatory 1.5-m telescope. Using the Gaia eDR3 catalogue to determine Supernova 1972E’s location yields: α = 13h39m52${_{.}^{\rm s}}$708 ± 0${_{.}^{\rm s}}$004 and δ = −31°40’9${_{.}^{\prime\prime}}$00 ± 0${_{.}^{\prime\prime}}$04 (ICRS). In 2005, HST/ACS imaged the host galaxy of SN 1972E with the F435W, F555W, and F814W filters covering the explosion site. The nearest detected source is offset by 3.0 times our positional precision, and is inconsistent with the colours expected of a surviving donor star. Thus, the limiting magnitude of the HST observation (F555W > 28 mag) rules out all He star companion models and the most luminous main-sequence companion model currently in the literature. The remaining main-sequence companion models could be tested with a 10 orbit HST exposure in the F606W filter.

Precise Photometric Measurements from a 1903 Photographic Plate Using a Commercial Scanner

We demonstrate the feasibility of determining magnitudes of stars on archival photographic plates using a commercially available scanner. We describe one photometric approach that could serve as a useful example for other studies. In particular, we measure and calibrate stellar magnitudes from a 1903 photographic plate from the Yerkes Observatory collection, and demonstrate that the overall precision from our methods is better than 0.10 mag. Notably, these measurements are dominated by intrinsic plate noise, rather than noise introduced through the scanning/digitization process. The low expense of this approach expands the scientific potential to study variable stars in the archives of observatory plate collections. We use the serendipitous discovery of a candidate transient at photographic magnitude pg = 16.60 in the spiral galaxy NGC 7331 to illustrate our photometric methods. If this unknown source is a supernova, it would represent the fourth known supernova in NGC 7331.

Outbursts of the black hole X-ray transient KV UMa (XTE J1118+480) in the optical band

AbstractKV UMa (XTE J1118+480) is an X-ray binary that is known to undergo outbursts in 2000 and 2005. This paper presents the discovery of a large outburst starting in 1927 on the archival photographic plates and an analysis of the long-term optical activity of this system. We used the photographic data from DASCH (Digital Access to a Sky Century @ Harvard). We placed the 1927 outburst in the context of the observed outbursts of KV UMa. We show that it is a double event, with a precursor similar to the one of the outbursts in 2000. We find a big difference between the 1927 and 2000 outbursts as regards the length of the gap between the precursor and the main outburst. It is more than 250 d in 1927, whereas it is about 20 d in 2000, although the brightnesses of all peaks are mutually comparable. We also show that the individual optical outbursts of KV UMa differ from each other by the duration of the stage of a slow decline of brightness (sometimes roughly a plateau). This determines the length of the entire main outburst. Both the peak magnitude and the brightness of the outburst when the slow decline transitions to a steep final decaying branch plausibly reproduce in all three outbursts. In the interpretation, the short duration of the precursor is caused by the fact that only the thermal-viscous instability operated in the accretion disk while also the tidal instability of the disk contributed in the subsequent main outburst.

Precise measures of orbital period, before and after nova eruption for QZ Aurigae

For the ordinary classical nova QZ Aurigae (which erupted in 1964), we report 1317 magnitudes from 1912--2016, including four eclipses detected on archival photographic plates from long before the eruption. We have accurate and robust measures of the orbital period both pre-eruption and post-eruption, and we find that the orbital period decreased, with a fractional change of -290.71+-0.28 parts-per-million across the eruption, with the orbit necessarily getting smaller. Further, we find that the light curve outside of eclipses and eruption is flat at near B=17.14 from 1912--1981, whereupon the average light curve starts fading down to B=17.49 with large variability. QZ Aur is a robust counter-example against the Hibernation model for the evolution of cataclysmic variables, where the model requires that all novae have their period increase across eruptions. Large period decreases across eruptions can easily arise from mass imbalances in the ejecta, as are commonly seen in asymmetric nova shells.

Constraining the period of the ringed secondary companion to the young star J1407 with photographic plates

Context. The 16 Myr old star 1SWASP J140747.93-394542.6 (V1400 Cen) underwent a series of complex eclipses in May 2007, interpreted as the transit of a giant Hill sphere filling debris ring system around a secondary companion, J1407b. No other eclipses have since been detected, although other measurements have constrained but not uniquely determined the orbital period of J1407b. Finding another eclipse towards J1407 will help determine the orbital period of the system, the geometry of the proposed ring system and enable planning of further observations to characterize the material within these putative rings. Aims. We carry out a search for other eclipses in photometric data of J1407 with the aim of constraining the orbital period of J1407b. Methods. We present photometry from archival photographic plates from the Harvard DASCH survey, and Bamberg and Sonneberg Observatories, in order to place additional constraints on the orbital period of J1407b by searching for other dimming and eclipse events. Using a visual inspection of all 387 plates and a period-folding algorithm we performed a search for other eclipses in these data sets. Results. We find no other deep eclipses in the data spanning from 1890 to 1990, nor in recent time-series photometry from 2012–2018. Conclusions. We rule out a large fraction of putative orbital periods for J1407b from 5 to 20 yr. These limits are still marginally consistent with a large Hill sphere filling ring system surrounding a brown dwarf companion in a bound elliptical orbit about J1407. Issues with the stability of any rings combined with the lack of detection of another eclipse, suggests that J1407b may not be bound to J1407.

An UXor among FUors: Extinction-related Brightness Variations of the Young Eruptive Star V582 Aur

Abstract V582 Aur is an FU Ori-type young eruptive star in outburst since ∼1985. The eruption is currently in a relatively constant plateau phase, with photometric and spectroscopic variability superimposed. Here we will characterize the progenitor of the outbursting object, explore its environment, and analyze the temporal evolution of the eruption. We are particularly interested in the physical origin of the two deep photometric dips, one that occurred in 2012 and one that is ongoing since 2016. We collected archival photographic plates and carried out new optical, infrared, and millimeter-wave photometric and spectroscopic observations between 2010 and 2018, with a high sampling rate during the current minimum. Besides analyzing the color changes during fading, we compiled multiepoch spectral energy distributions and fitted them with a simple accretion disk model. Based on pre-outburst data and a millimeter continuum measurement, we suggest that the progenitor of the V582 Aur outburst is a low-mass T Tauri star with average properties. The mass of an unresolved circumstellar structure, probably a disk, is 0.04 M ⊙. The optical and near-infrared spectra demonstrate the presence of hydrogen and metallic lines, show the CO band head in absorption, and exhibit a variable Hα profile. The color variations strongly indicate that both the ∼1 yr long brightness dip in 2012 and the current minimum since 2016 are caused by increased extinction along the line of sight. According to our accretion disk models, the reddening changed from A V = 4.5 to 12.5 mag, while the accretion rate remained practically constant. Similarly to the models of the UXor phenomenon of intermediate- and low-mass young stars, orbiting disk structures could be responsible for the eclipses.

THE SOLAR NEIGHBORHOOD. XXXVIII. RESULTS FROM THE CTIO/SMARTS 0.9 m: TRIGONOMETRIC PARALLAXES FOR 151 NEARBY M DWARF SYSTEMS

ABSTRACT We present 160 new trigonometric parallaxes for 151 M dwarf systems from the REsearch Consortium On Nearby Stars (RECONS) group’s long-term astrometry/photometry program at the CTIO/SMARTS 0.9 m telescope. Most systems (124 or 82%) are found to lie within 25 pc. The stars have 119 mas yr μ 828 mas yr−1 and 3.85 8.47. Among these are 58 systems from the SuperCOSMOS-RECONS search, discovered via our proper motion trawls of the SuperCOSMOS digitized archival photographic plates, while the remaining stars were suspected via photometric distance estimates to lie nearby. Sixteen systems were newly discovered via astrometric perturbations to be binaries, many of which are ideal for accurate mass determinations due to their proximity and orbital periods on the order of a decade. A variability analysis of the stars presented, two-thirds of which are new results, shows six of the stars to vary by more than 20 mmag. This effort brings the total number of parallaxes for M dwarf systems measured by RECONS to nearly 500 and increases by 26% the number of southern M dwarf systems with accurate trigonometric parallaxes placing them within 25 pc.

KIC 8462852 FADED AT AN AVERAGE RATE OF 0.164 ± 0.013 MAGNITUDES PER CENTURY FROM 1890 TO 1989

ABSTRACT KIC 8462852 is a completely ordinary F3 main-sequence star, except that the light curve from Kepler shows episodes of unique and inexplicable day-long dips with up to 20% dimming. Here, I provide a light curve of 1338 Johnson B-band magnitudes from 1890 to 1989 taken from archival photographic plates at Harvard. KIC 8462852 displays a secular dimming at an average rate of 0.164 ± 0.013 mag per century. From the early-1890s to the late-1980s, KIC 8462852 faded by 0.193 ± 0.030 mag. The decline is not an artifact because nearby check stars have closely flat light curves. This century-long dimming is unprecedented for any F-type main-sequence star. Thus, the Harvard light curve provides the first confirmation (past the several dips seen in the Kepler light curve alone) that KIC 8462852 has anything unusual. The century-long dimming and the day-long dips are both just extreme ends of a spectrum of timescales for unique dimming events. By Ockham’s Razor, two such unique and similar effects are very likely produced by one physical mechanism. This one mechanism does not appear as any isolated catastrophic event in the last century, but rather must be some ongoing process with continuous effects. Within the context of dust-occultation models, the century-long dimming trend requires 104–107 times as much dust as for the deepest Kepler dip. Within the context of the comet-family idea, the century-long dimming trend requires an estimated 648,000 giant comets (each with 200 km diameter) all orchestrated to pass in front of the star within the last century.

DASCH DISCOVERY OF A POSSIBLE NOVA-LIKE OUTBURST IN A PECULIAR SYMBIOTIC BINARY

We present photometric and spectroscopic observations of a peculiar variable (designated DASCH J075731.1+201735 or J0757) discovered from our DASCH project using the digitized Harvard College Observatory archival photographic plates. It brightened by about 1.5 magnitudes in B within a year starting in 1942, and then slowly faded back to its pre-outburst brightness from 1943 to the 1950s. The mean brightness level was stable before and after the outburst, and ellipsoidal variations with a period of $P=119.18\pm0.07$ days are seen, suggesting that the star is tidally distorted. Radial-velocity measurements indicate that the orbit is nearly circular ($e=0.02\pm0.01$) with a spectroscopic period that is the same as the photometric period. The binary consists of a $1.1\pm0.3 M_\odot$ M0III star, and a $0.6\pm0.2 M_\odot$ companion, very likely a white dwarf (WD). Unlike other symbiotic binaries, there is no sign of emission lines or a stellar wind in the spectra. With an outburst timescale of ~10 years and estimated B band peak luminosity M_B~0.7, J0757 is different from any other known classic or symbiotic novae. The most probable explanation of the outburst is Hydrogen shell-burning on the WD, although an accretion-powered flare cannot be ruled out.

OBJECT X: THE BRIGHTEST MID-INFRARED POINT SOURCE IN M33

We discuss the nature of the brightest mid-IR point source (which we dub Object X) in the nearby galaxy M33. Although multi-wavelength data on this object have existed in the literature for some time, it has not previously been recognized as the most luminous mid-IR object in M33 because it is entirely unremarkable in both optical and near-IR light. In the Local Group Galaxies Survey, Object X is a faint red source visible in VRI and H-alpha but not U or B. It was easily seen at JHK_s in the 2MASS survey. It is the brightest point source in all four Spitzer IRAC bands and is also visible in the MIPS 24-micron band. Its bolometric luminosity is 5x10^5 L_sun. The source is optically variable on short time scales (tens of days) and is also slightly variable in the mid-IR, indicating that it is a star. Archival photographic plates (from 1949 and 1991) show no optical source, so the star has been obscured for at least half a century. Its properties are similar to those of the Galactic OH/IR star IRC+10420 which has a complex dusty circumstellar structure resulting from episodic low velocity mass ejections. We propose that Object X is a M>30 M_sun evolved star obscured in its own dust ejected during episodic mass loss events over at least half a century. It may emerge from its current ultra-short evolutionary phase as a hotter post-RSG star analogous to M33 Var A. The existence and rarity of such objects can be an important probe of a very brief yet eventful stellar evolutionary phase.

A long-term photometric study of the FU Orionis star V 733 Cephei

The FU Orionis candidate V733 Cep was discovered by Roger Persson in 2004. The star is located in the dark cloud L1216 close to the Cepheus OB3 association. Because only a small number of FU Orionis stars have been detected to date, photometric and spectral studies of V733 Cep are of great interest. The studies of the photometrical variability of PMS stars are very important to the understanding of stellar evolution. The main purpose of our study is to construct a long-time light curve of V733 Cep. On the basis of BVRI monitoring we also study the photometric behavior of the star. We gather data from CCD photometry and archival photographic plates. The photometric BVRI data (Johnson-Cousins system) that we present were collected from June 2008 to October 2009. To facilitate transformation from instrumental measurements to the standard system, fifteen comparison stars in the field of V733 Cep were calibrated in BVRI bands. To construct a historical light curve of V733 Cep, a search for archival photographic observations in the Wide-Field Plate Database was performed. As a result, 192 photographic plates containing the field of V733 Cep were found. Some plates were analyzed at our request to estimate the magnitude of V733 Cep.

THE BEHAVIOR OF NOVAE LIGHT CURVES BEFORE ERUPTION

In 1975, E. R. Robinson conducted the hallmark study of the behavior of classical nova light curves before eruption, and this work has now become part of the standard knowledge of novae. He made three points; that 5 out of 11 novae showed pre-eruption rises in the years before eruption, that one nova (V446 Her) showed drastic changes in the variability across eruptions, and that all but one of the novae (excepting BT Mon) have the same quiescent magnitudes before and after the outburst. This work has not been tested since it came out. We have now tested these results by going back to the original archival photographic plates and measuring large numbers of pre-eruption magnitudes for many novae using comparison stars on a modern magnitude scale. We find in particular that four out of five claimed pre-eruption rises are due to simple mistakes in the old literature, that V446 Her has the same amplitude of variations across its 1960 eruption, and that BT Mon has essentially unchanged brightness across its 1939 eruption. Out of 22 nova eruptions, we find two confirmed cases of significant pre-eruption rises (for V533 Her and V1500 Cyg), while T CrB has a deep pre-eruption dip. These events are a challenge to theorists. We find no significant cases of changes in variability across 27 nova eruptions beyond what is expected due to the usual fluctuations seen in novae away from eruptions. For 30 classical novae plus 19 eruptions from 6 recurrent novae, we find that the average change in magnitude from before the eruption to long after the eruption is 0.0 mag. However, we do find five novae (V723 Cas, V1500 Cyg, V1974 Cyg, V4633 Sgr, and RW UMi) that have significantly large changes, in that the post-eruption quiescent brightness level is over ten times brighter than the pre-eruption level.

A long-term photometric study of V 1184 Tauri

Aims. The main purpose of our investigation is to construct the long-time light curve of the PMS star V 1184 Tau. We consider the study of the photometrical variability of PMS stars as very important for understanding stellar evolution. The unusual photometric variability of V 1184 Tau was reported in previous studies as well, but the nature of the observed deep minima is still under discussion. Methods. We present recent data from CCD photometry and from archival photographic plates. The photometric BVRI data presented in this paper were collected from November 2005 to November 2007. To construct the historical light curve of V 1184 Tau, a search for archived photographic observations in the Wide-Field Plate Database (WFPDB) was made. As a result, 412 photographic plates were found containing the field of V 1184 Tau. A part of the plates were scanned at our request and a magnitude estimation was made of V 1184 Tau. Results. Our recent photometric data suggest that the star brightness is still near the minimum. Thus the period of strong light variations that started in 2003 continues up to the present, hence more than 4 years. Our data from the archival photographic plates suggest that an unknown minimum of brightness exists in the approximate period 1980-1985. Taking all available photometric and spectroscopic data into account we must reject the hypothesis that V 1184 Tau is an FU Orionis type object. V 1184 Tau is a G type low-mass star whose spectrum is similar to WTT stars, but its photometric behavior is typical of the UX Orionis variable stars. Assuming the obscuration from orbiting dust clouds as a reason for a deep minimum, we estimate the approximate period of obscurations and the interval between two deep minima. Our calculations give a 25-28 year period between the two minima and approximately 8-10 year duration of the minima.

Use of confocal microscopy in the search for optical counterparts to Gamma-Ray bursts

A number of star-like images have been found on archival photographic plates, however there is debate as to whether these are optical emissions relating to Gamma-Ray bursts, or simply plate defects. Results from photographic science are summarized so that the characteristic shape of different types of images on photographic plates can be theoretically predicted. Explanation for the formation of the relief image and reasons for its continued study are described. New methods in the use of laser scanning confocal microscopy are presented to study the relief image and the depthwise disposition of silver so that a test procedure can be established to end the speculation surrounding the astrophysical truth of stellar-like images on photographic plates.

Very low luminosity stars with very large amplitude flares

CCD frames of CZ Cnc, KY Cep, the gamma-ray burster optical transient, and NSV 12006 are analyzed. Also studied are 549 archival photographic plates of the CZ Cnc field. These observations are compared with the data of Lovas (1976). Flare events on CZ Cnc are examined. Based on the data it is noted that CZ Cnc is a main-sequence star, has a magnitude of 16.1, a distance of 100 pc, occasional large-amplitude flares, and frequent flares with amplitudes greater than 4 mag.

Search for optical counterparts of gamma-ray burst sources

The examination of nearly 9600 archival photographic plates covering six gamma-ray burst error boxes has unveiled several star-like images. Unfortunately, the reality of none of these images can be proved by duplicate plates.

Search for optical flashes from gamma-ray burst sources on plates of Sonneberg observatory archive

The results of inspecting five gamma-ray burst error boxes using more than 7,000 archival photographic plates are reported. We have found altogether two star-like images within and five such images in the immediate vicinity of three error boxes. A brief discussion of the connection of these possible optical flashes with the gamma-ray burst sources is given.

On the binary nature of cosmic γ-ray burst sources

The basic nature of cosmic γ-ray burst sources1 has remained a mystery. Schaefer2 and Schaefer et al.3 recently discovered three images on archival photographic plates probably due to optical flashes from the error boxes of three γ-ray burst sources. This discovery opens up the possibility of ground-based optical studies of these objects (see, for example, ref. 4) and provides an important new set of data that can constrain models significantly (see, for example, ref. 5 and references therein) for these intriguing sources. London and Cominsky6 have considered a model for the optical flashes, wherein γ-ray bursts are emitted by a collapsed object in a close-binary stellar system and a small fraction of the γ radiation is reprocessed into optical radiation in the surface layers of the companion star (see refs 7 and 8 for possible alternative explanations). Based on their own estimates of the time, τ, required to reprocess the γ radiation into optical light, London and Cominsky concluded that a binary model would not account for the observed optical flashes. They considered, however, only main-sequence stars and hydrogen-depleted degenerate dwarfs as possible companion stars. We reconsider here the binary model and conclude that it is viable. In particular, under the assumption that the optical flashes were produced by γ-ray bursts of about the same intensity as those observed, we find that nearby (≲100 pc) binary systems with secondaries whose masses are less than ∼0.06 M⊙ can fit all the observational constraints for the three optical/γ-ray pair events (hereafter 1928/1978, 1944/1979 and 1901/1979; see Table 1).

Two probable optical flashes from gamma-ray bursters

Two images on archival photographic plates which are most likely records of optical flashes from gamma-ray bursters (GRBs) were examined. One of these images appears on a 1901 plate in the field of the Nov. 5, 1979 GRB, while the other is in the field of the Jan. 13, 1979 GRB on a plate exposed in 1944. The 1901 optical transient image is circular in shape, while all normal star images are trailed by 8 in. No optical transients are found in a control region which is 34.3 times larger than the GRB error regions examined. Independent limits on the optical flash rate from the sky yield a probability of less than 0.0001 that any one of the optical transients is due to a background flash. A total exposure of 2.7 years was examined for GRB flashes at known GRB locations on the Harvard plates and a total of three GRB flashes were seen, that the average recurrence time scale for optical flashes is roughly one year. The optical fluence of these optical flashes was measured. For the three currently known GRB optical flashes, the ratio of gamma-ray fluence (from a modern burst) to the optical fluence (from a archival burst) were measured to be 800, 900, and 900.