Few data are reported in literature about visceral artery aneurysms (VAAs) management. The aim of the present study was to analyze VAAs management in a single institution, with a dedicated algorithm for endovascular approach as the first line treatment. A single-center retrospective cohort study was performed. Patients with a VAA submitted to either endovascular repair or open surgery from 2016 to 2023 were included. A dedicated algorithm was used to evaluate the endovascular approach feasibility assessing on the preoperative computed tomography angiography the following parameters: (a) the tortuosity of the involved artery (<150°), (b) the healthy arterial diameter (>4mm), (c) the VAA proximity to the hilum and/or the presence of a bifurcation of the aneurysmatic artery, and (d) the circumferential calcium presence. An endovascular approach was chosen if (a) and (b) criteria were satisfied without (c) and (d) ones. Otherwise, it was deemed a challenging anatomy, and an open surgical treatment was considered. In the absence of (a) and/or (b) criteria open surgery was the preferred option. Thirty-one asymptomatic aneurysms (28 patients) were treated electively. The most frequent VAA location was the splenic artery (18 cases; 58%), followed by the renal arteries (6 cases; 19%), the common hepatic artery (5 cases; 16%), the gastroepiploic artery (1 case, 3.2%) and the pancreatoduodenal artery (1 case; 3%). Twenty-two aneurysms (71%) were initially treated by an endovascular approach (stent-graft deployment and/or transcatheter embolization) with 3 (13%) of them needing a surgical conversion. Nine aneurysms (29%) were submitted directly to a surgical treatment (aneurysm resection with or without interposition bypass) with no peri-operative and long-term complications. Technical success was 90.3%. Endovascular management as a first line approach is safe and effective in most cases. A preoperative dedicated algorithm is useful to identify suitable cases. Open surgery can be considered an alternative option in specific challenging anatomical situations or in case of endovascular failure.