Applications In Wearable Electronics Research Articles

High Seebeck Coefficient Thermally Chargeable Supercapacitor with Synergistic Effect of Multichannel Ionogel Electrolyte and Ti3C2Tx MXene‐Based Composite Electrode

Thermally chargeable supercapacitors can collect low‐grade heat generated by the human body and convert it into electricity as a power supply unit for wearable electronics. However, the low Seebeck coefficient and heat‐to‐electricity conversion efficiency hinder further application. In this paper, we designed a high‐performance thermally chargeable supercapacitor device composed of ZnMn2O4@Ti3C2Tx MXene composites (ZMO@Ti3C2Tx MXene) electrode and UIO‐66 metal–organic framework doped multichannel polyvinylidene fluoridehexafluoro‐propylene ionogel electrolyte, which realized the thermoelectric conversion and electrical energy storage at the same time. This thermally chargeable supercapacitor device exhibited a high Seebeck coefficient of 55.4 mV K−1, thermal voltage of 243 mV, and outstanding heat‐to‐electricity conversion efficiency of up to 6.48% at the temperature difference of 4.4 K. In addition, this device showed excellent charge–discharge cycling stability at high‐temperature differences (3 K) and low‐temperature differences (1 K), respectively. Connecting two thermally chargeable supercapacitor units in series, the generated output voltage of 500 mV further confirmed the stability of devices. When a single device was worn on the arm, a thermal voltage of 208.3 mV was obtained indicating the possibility of application in wearable electronics.

Design of Stretchable and Conductive Self-Adhesive Hydrogels as Flexible Sensors by Guar-Gum-Enabled Dynamic Interactions.

The limited elasticity and inadequate bonding of hydrogels made from guar gum (GG) significantly hinder their widespread implementation in personalized wearable flexible electronics. In this study, we devise GG-based self-adhesive hydrogels by creating an interpenetrating network of GG cross-linked with acrylic, 4-vinylphenylboronic acid, and Ca2+. With the leverage of the dynamic interactions (hydrogen bonds, borate ester bonds, and coordination bonds) between -OH in GG and monomers, the hydrogel exhibits a high stretchability of 700%, superior mechanical stress of 110 kPa, and robust adherence to several substrates. The adhesion strength of 54 kPa on porcine skin is obtained. Furthermore, the self-adhesive hydrogel possesses stable conductivity, an elevated gauge factor (GF), and commendable durability. It can be affixed to the human body as a strain sensor to obtain precise monitoring of human movement behavior. Our research offers possibilities for the development of GG-based hydrogels and applications in wearable electronics and medical monitoring.

Self‐powered sensor based on compressible ionic gel electrolyte for simultaneous determination of temperature and pressure

AbstractThe simultaneous detection of multiple stimuli, such as pressure and temperature, has long been a persistent challenge for developing electronic skin (e‐skin) to emulate the functionality of human skin. Meanwhile, the demand for integrated power supply units is an additional pressing concern to achieve its lightweightness and flexibility. Herein, we propose a self‐powered dual temperature–pressure (SPDM) sensor, which utilizes a compressible ionic gel electrolyte driven by the potential difference between MXene and Al electrodes. The SPDM sensor exhibits a rapid and timely response to changes in pressure‐induced deformation, while exhibiting a slow and hysteretic response to temperature variations. These distinct response characteristics enable the differentiation of current signals generated by different stimuli through machine learning, resulting in an impressive accuracy rate of 99.1%. Furthermore, the developed SPDM sensor exhibits a wide pressure detection range of 0–800 kPa and a broad temperature detection range of 5–75°C, encompassing the environmental conditions encountered in daily human life. The dual‐mode coupled strategy by machine learning provides an effective approach for temperature and pressure detection and discrimination, showcasing its potential applications in wearable electronics, intelligent robots, human–machine interactions, and so on.

Flexible piezoresistive pressure sensor based on a graphene-carbon nanotube-polydimethylsiloxane composite

Flexible sensors are used widely in wearable devices, specifically flexible piezoresistive sensors, which are common and easy to manipulate. However, fabricating such sensors is expensive and complex, so proposed here is a simple fabrication approach involving a sensor containing microstructures replicated from a sandpaper template onto which polydimethylsiloxane containing a mixture of graphene and carbon nanotubes is spin coated. The surface morphologies of three versions of the sensor made using different grades of sandpaper are observed, and the corresponding pressure sensitivities and linearity and hysteresis characteristics are assessed and analyzed. The results show that the sensor made using 80-mesh sandpaper has the best sensing performance. Its sensitivity is 0.341 kPa−1 in the loading range of 0–1.6 kPa, it responds to small external loading of 100 Pa with a resistance change of 10%, its loading and unloading response times are 0.126 and 0.2 s, respectively, and its hysteresis characteristic is ∼7%, indicating that the sensor has high sensitivity, fast response, and good stability. Thus, the presented piezoresistive sensor is promising for practical applications in flexible wearable electronics.

Laser-assisted synthesis of MnOx and 3D graphene composites for wide-voltage flexible planar microcapacitors

Herein, we propose a simple and eco-friendly strategy based on laser direct writing technology to regulate the valence state of Mn-based oxides nanoparticles anchored on three-dimensional(3D) framework of laser-induced graphene (LIG) for the application of high-performance flexible planar interdigital microsupercapacitors (MSCs). Under the laser radiation, a polyimide (PI) and MnO2 composite film was directly converted into 3D graphene and MnOx (MnO, MnO2 and Mn3O4 mixture). Furthermore, the results reveal that LIG/MnOx MSCs device exhibits a high specific capacitance of 23.3 mF cm−2, which is about 29 times higher than that of LIG MSCs (0.8 mF cm−2). Moreover, LIG/MnOx MSCs possess a high energy density of 7.28 μWh cm−2, outstanding cycle stability with the capacitance retention rate of 97.4 % after 10,000 cycles, and excellent mechanical flexibility. Therefore, this preparation strategy of LIG/MnOx provides a reference for the performance regulation of Mn-based oxides and the low-cost construction of MSCs devices with high energy density, which carries significant research implications for diverse flexible wearable electronic applications in the forthcoming days.

Superwetting Capillary Tubes: Surface Science under Confined Space.

Capillarity is a crucial and pervasive phenomenon in nature and has found important applications in wearable electronics, medical devices, and miniature energy systems. Capillary tubes are the transport vessels in which the surface wettability plays an essential role in efficient and accurate liquid delivery. However, it remains a challenging issue to tailor and measure the surface wettability inside the tubes in view of the confined space. Herein, recent progress on the surface science under confined space is discussed, with a particular focus on surface modification, wettability evaluation, and advanced applications of the superwetting capillary tubes. This Perspective aims to highlight the emerging opportunities in surface science with spatial confinement toward flexible and portable devices.

Silver nanoparticles reinforced on silk fibroin/carboxymethylcellulose composite films for electrical applications

This study proposes the fabrication of silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) on silk fibroin-carboxymethylcellulose (SF-CMC) composite films for advancement in electronic device applications. Bombyx mori silk fibroin is a biopolymer that is used as a bio-template in the fabrication of AgNPs. Various silver nitrate (AgNO3) combinations are added to the prepared SF solution to synthesize AgNPs. To develop stand-alone biopolymer-nanocomposite (SF-CMC/AgNPs) films, SF-AgNPs colloidal solution is blended with CMC solution. Ultra Violet – Visible (UV–Vis), Photoluminescence (PL), Fourier Transform Infra-red Spectroscopy (FT-IR), X-ray diffraction (XRD), Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) have been employed to the prepared SF-CMC/AgNPs composites toevaluate the physical, chemical, structural, morphological, and topographical information of the composite films. Furthermore, the composites are subjected to LCR Hi-tester and electrochemical workstation CH instrument to analyze the AC, DC conductivity, dielectric characteristics, and electrochemical impedance analysis of SF-CMC/AgNPs composites. The UV–visible spectra reveals the formed nanoparticles in spherical shape with average particle size 35–40 nm. XRD reveals the formed AgNPs in face centred cubic (FCC) structure; TEM reveals the average particle size of 35 nm. AC conductivity of the SF-CMC/AgNPs composite found to be 4.0 × 10−4 to 8.04 × 10−4 S/cm. In spite of the presence of AgNPs, measurements of the dielectric behaviourof pure CMC and SF-CMC materials exhibit good dielectric performance. The obtained results demonstrated that the SF-CMCfilms exhibit significant conductivity following AgNPs incorporation and may therefore be used in biosensor and wearable electronic device applications.

Polymerized-Small-Molecule Acceptors Featuring Siloxane-Terminated Side Chains for Mechanically Robust All-Polymer Solar Cells.

Flexible and stretchable organic solar cells (OSCs) show great promise in wearable and stretchable electronic applications. However, current high-performance OSCs consisting of polymer donors (PDs) and small-molecule acceptors (SMAs) face significant challenges in achieving both high power conversion efficiency (PCE) and excellent stretch-ability. In this study, we synthesized a new polymerized-small-molecule acceptor (P-SMA) PY-SiO featuring siloxane-terminated side chains and compared its photovoltaic and mechanical performance to that of the reference PY-EH with ethylhexyl-terminated side chains. We found that the incorporation of siloxane-terminated side chains in PY-SiO enhanced the molecular aggregation and charge transport, leading to an optimized film morphology. The resultant of all-polymer solar cells (all-PSCs) based on PBDB-T/PY-SiO showed a higher PCE of 12.04% than the PY-EH-based one (10.85%). Furthermore, the siloxane-terminated side chains also increased the interchain distance and provided a larger free volume for chain rotation and reconfiguration, resulting in a higher film crack-onset strain (COS: 18.32% for PBDB-T/PY-SiO vs 11.15% for PBDB-T/PY-EH). Additionally, the PY-SiO-based stretchable all-PSCs exhibited an impressive PCE of 9.8% and retained >70% of its original PCE even under a substantial 20% strain, exceeding the performance of the PY-EH-based stretchable all-PSCs. Our result suggests the great potential of the siloxane-terminated side chain for achieving high-performance and stretchable OSCs.

Biomechanical energy harvesting technologies for wearable electronics: Theories and devices

AbstractWearable biomechanical energy harvesting devices have received a lot of attention recently, benefiting from the rapid advancement of theories and devices in the field of the micro electromechanical system (MEMS). They not only fulfil the requirements for powering wearable electronic devices but also provide an attractive prospect for powering self-powered flexible electronic devices when wearing. In this article, we provide a review of the theories and devices of biomechanical energy harvesting technology for wearable applications. Three different forms of biomechanical energy harvesting mechanisms, including the piezoelectric effect, electromagnetic effect, and electrostatic effect, are investigated in detail. The fundamental principle of converting other types of energy from the biomechanical environment into electrical energy, as well as the most commonly-used analytical theoretical models, are outlined for each process. Therefore, the features, properties, and applications of energy harvesting devices are summarized. In addition, the coupled multi-effect hybrid energy harvesting devices are listed, showing the various possibilities of biomechanical energy harvesting devices for serving as sources, sensors, and actuators. Finally, we present perspectives on the future trends of biomechanical energy harvesting devices for wearable electronics applications.

Multi-Functional Nano-Doped Hollow Fiber from Microfluidics for Sensors and Micromotors.

Nano-doped hollow fiber is currently receiving extensive attention due to its multifunctionality and booming development. However, the microfluidic fabrication of nano-doped hollow fiber in a simple, smooth, stable, continuous, well-controlled manner without system blockage remains challenging. In this study, we employ a microfluidic method to fabricate nano-doped hollow fiber, which not only makes the preparation process continuous, controllable, and efficient, but also improves the dispersion uniformity of nanoparticles. Hydrogel hollow fiber doped with carbon nanotubes is fabricated and exhibits superior electrical conductivity (15.8 S m-1), strong flexibility (342.9%), and versatility as wearable sensors for monitoring human motions and collecting physiological electrical signals. Furthermore, we incorporate iron tetroxide nanoparticles into fibers to create magnetic-driven micromotors, which provide trajectory-controlled motion and the ability to move through narrow channels due to their small size. In addition, manganese dioxide nanoparticles are embedded into the fiber walls to create self-propelled micromotors. When placed in a hydrogen peroxide environment, the micromotors can reach a top speed of 615 μm s-1 and navigate hard-to-reach areas. Our nano-doped hollow fiber offers a broad range of applications in wearable electronics and self-propelled machines and creates promising opportunities for sensors and actuators.

Flexible films with three-dimensional ion transport channels: Carbon nanotubes@MnO2 as interlayer spacers in porous graphene electrodes for high-performance supercapacitors

Flexible supercapacitors have a high potential for application in wearable electronics and microdevices, but their commercial appeal is limited because of low energy density. To overcoming this challenge, this paper proposes a strategy to fabricate dense films with high specific capacitance. A composite film with rapid ion diffusion channels and a high density of 0.86 g cm–3 was synthesized by combining porous graphene nanosheets (PGNs), carbon nanotubes (CNTs), and MnO2 nanosheets. The incorporation of CNTs@MnO2 between graphene layers effectively mitigated aggregation and enhanced electrolyte ion diffusion within the dense graphene structure. PGNs and CNTs synergistically established a three-dimensional pathway for efficient ion transport while optimizing electron dynamics. In 1 mol L–1 Na2SO4 electrolyte, the material exhibited a gravimetric capacitance of up to 320 F g–1 at 1 A g–1 and a volumetric capacitance reached 275 F cm–3. Furthermore, the assembled asymmetric supercapacitors, PGNs-CNTs@MnO2//PGNs-CNTs, exhibited a gravimetric energy density of up to 26.4 Wh kg–1 and a volumetric energy density of up to 22.7 Wh L–1. These findings offer insights into advancing flexible supercapacitor technology for diverse applications.

Bacterial cellulose-based composite films with liquid metal/graphene synergistic conductive pathways for superior electromagnetic interference shielding and Joule heating performance

Modern integrated electronics are in great demand for high-performance electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding materials with exceptional mechanical properties. Liquid metal (LM) has demonstrated great potential in EMI shielding by its superior electrical conductivity. However, its real-world EMI application is limited by the poor compatibility, insulating oxide shells, and unpredictable leakage. Here, graphene oxide (GO) is used to encapsulate LM to form LM@GO microdroplets dispersion, and bacterial cellulose (BC) is applied to construct a biocompatible fabric network. Moreover, GO is in-situ reduced by hydrazine vapor, which generates synergistic LM/reduced graphene oxide (rGO) conductive pathways with the aid of roll-in process, obtaining flexible LM/rGO/BC (LGB) composite film with outstanding electrical conductivity of 4.5 × 104 S/m and exceptional shielding effectiveness of 64.0 dB. The rGO sheets and BC network demonstrate layered structure after roll-in process, effectively impeding the leakage and oxidation of LM and achieving a tensile strength up to 62.9 MPa of LGB films. Meanwhile, the LGB films exhibit exceptional Joule heating performance, and the stable surface temperature reaches 110 °C with high stability and reliability when the applied voltage is 4 V. This work provides a feasible engineering approach to prepare LM-based films for applications in EMI shielding and wearable electronics.

Hybrid Hydrogen Bonding Strategy to Construct Instantaneous Self-Healing Highly Elastic Ionohydrogel for Multi-Functional Electronics.

Gels show great promise for applications in wearable electronics, biomedical devices, and energy storage systems due to their exceptional stretchability and adjustable electrical conductivity. However, the challenge lies in integrating multiple functions like elasticity, instantaneous self-healing, and a wide operating temperature range into a single gel. To address this issue, a hybrid hydrogen bonding strategy to construct gel with these desirable properties is proposed. The intricate network of hybrid strong weak hydrogen bonds within the polymer matrix enables these ionohydrogel to exhibit remarkable instantaneous self-healing, stretching up to five times their original length within seconds. Leveraging these properties, the incorporation of ionic liquids, water, and zinc salts into hybrid hydrogen bond crosslinked network enables conductivity and redox reaction, making it a versatile ionic skin for real-time monitoring of human movements and respiratory. Moreover, the ionohydrogel can be used as electrolyte in the assembly of a zinc-ion battery, ensuring a reliable power supply for wearable electronics, even in extreme conditions (-20°C and extreme deformations). This ionohydrogel electrolyte simplifies the diverse structural requirements of gels to meet the needs of various electronic applications, offering a new approach for multi-functional electronics.

Enhanced sensing performance of superelastic thermally drawn liquid metal fibers through helical architecture while eliminating directional signal errors

Due to their potential use in creating advanced electronic textiles for wearable technology, functional fibers have garnered enormous interests. The presence of stretchable smart fibers has significantly expanded the application scenarios of intelligent fibers. However, preparing fibers that possess both excellent electrical performance and high stretchability remains a formidable challenge. The fabrication of stretchable multifunctional fiber-based sensors employing a scalable method is reported here. Using a thermal drawing process, the collaborative interplay between the hollow confined channels of superelastic poly(styrene-b-(ethylene-co-butylene)-b-styrene) (SEBS) thermally drawn fibers and the high fluidity of liquid metal (LM) ensures the exceptional electrical performance of the fibers. Simultaneously, the presence of a helical structure further enhances both the sensing and mechanical properties. The helical two LM channel fiber-based sensors are capable of displaying more than 1000 % strain, high stability over 1000 cycles, a quick pressure response and release time of 30.45 and 45.35 ms, and outstanding electrical conductivity of 8.075 × 105 S/m. In addition, the electrical conductivity of this fiber increases with strain level, reaching 3 × 106 S/m when the strain is 500 %. Furthermore, due to their superior tension and compression sensing capabilities, flexible helical sensors offer considerable potential for use in wearable electronics applications such as human motion detection, Morse code compilation, multichannel sensing, and more.

Deep-Learning-Guided Evaluation Method for the High-Volume Preparation of Flexible Sensors Based on Inkjet Printing.

Flexible sensors for application in various industries, including biomedicine and wearable electronics, are frequently made using silver nanoparticle (AgNP) inks and inkjet printing (IJP) technology. Inkjet-printed flexible electronic devices are made up of many printed lines that run parallel to each other, and the surface morphology of the printed lines and the interline state directly impact the electrical conductivity of the electronic devices. This paper describes the experimental setup for IJP, the definition of print line characteristics, and common unavoidable defects. Conductivity and physical defects are considered in defining the print line quality assessment. In addition, two prediction models of flexible sensors before batch printing and a model for detecting defects after printing are provided. The predictive models can guide actions, leading to a print success rate of over 80%. We build the defect detection model using a neural architecture search because manually fine-tuning neural networks for reference is challenging. Finally, a target detection model with a mAP@0.5 of 81.2% is built in just 0.77 graphics processing unit (GPU) days. The model takes only 4.6 ms to detect an image, satisfying the real-time monitoring needs. At the same time, an accuracy of 95.5% can be achieved in the test data set. This work provides a new idea for the high-volume preparation of flexible sensors.

Highly reliable and stretchable OLEDs based on facile patterning method: toward stretchable organic optoelectronic devices

Stretchable displays attract significant attention because of their potential applications in wearable electronics, smart textiles, and human-conformable devices. This paper introduces an electrically stable, mechanically ultra-robust, and water-resistant stretchable OLED display (SOLED) mounted on a stress-relief pillar platform. The SOLED is fabricated on a thin, transparent polyethylene terephthalate (PET) film using conventional vacuum evaporation, organic-inorganic hybrid thin film encapsulation (TFE), and a nonselective laser patterning process. This simple and efficient process yields an OLED display with exceptional stretchability, reaching up to 95% strain and outstanding durability, enduring 100,000 stretch-release cycles at 50% strain. Operational lifetime and water-resistant storage lifetime measurements confirm that the TFE provides effective protection even after the nonselective laser patterning process. A 3 × 3 array SOLED display module mounted on a stress-relief pillar platform is successfully implemented, marking the first case of water-resistant display array operation in the field of SOLEDs. This work aims to develop practical stretchable displays by offering a reliable fabrication method and device design for creating mechanically robust and adaptable displays, potentially paving the way for future advances in human-conformable electronics and other innovative applications.

MXene bridging graphite nanoplatelets for electrically and thermally conductive nanofiber composites with high breathability

Electrically and thermally conductive polymer composites (CPCs) have promising applications in flexible and wearable electronics, and it remains difficult for the trade-off between the electrical and thermal properties and the breathability. We propose a “MXene bridging graphite nanoplatelets (GNPs)” strategy to prepare conductive membranes with high conductivity and excellent breathability. Rigid GNPs are randomly distributed inside polyurethane nanofibers and expand the network. MXene nanosheets are decorated onto the nanofibers and bridge GNPs to reduce the thermal and electrical contact resistance. The synergy of MXene and GNPs improves electrical and thermal conductivity without sacrificing their breathability. The electrical and thermal conductivity of the composites can reach 64.4 S/m and 4.9 W (m K)−1, respectively. In addition, the nanofiber composites with strong interfacial interactions and thus superior durability show outstanding photothermal conversion and heat dissipation capability. This study can provide inspiration for designing multi-functional, breathable CPCs with potential applications in wearable electronics.

High‐Performance Nd: AIZO/Al2O3 Dual Active Layer Design Without Thermal Annealing: High‐Speed Electron Transport and Defect Modification in Thin Film Transistors

Flexible wearable electronics have been developing rapidly in recent years, and one of its core devices, thin‐film transistor (TFT), is also attracting attention. Current TFT preparation processes usually require high annealing temperatures (>350 °C), which is not conducive to their application on most flexible substrates (PET, PEN, nanopaper, etc.). In this article, a strategy for the room temperature preparation of Nd:AIZO/Al2O3 dual‐layer TFT devices is proposed, which has appreciable electrical properties without additional annealing treatment. Taguchi orthogonal experimental methods are used to investigate the effects of three essential process parameters on the performance of the films and devices. As Nd:AIZO deposition time decreases and Al2O3 oxygen percentage and time during deposition increase, the μsat and SS of TFT devices are improved. With the preferred combination of parameters applied to the device preparation, the device exhibits a saturation mobility μsat of 24.3 cm2 V−1 s−1, a threshold voltage Vth of −1.4 V, a subthreshold swing SS of 0.21 V decade−1 and an Ion/Ioff ratio of 4.26 × 108. The ultra‐thin Al2O3 layer act as defect modification and form high‐speed electron transport in channel layer. The room temperature preparation of the dual‐layer TFT process proposed in this article is compatible with large‐size low‐cost flexible substrates. It has great potential for application in green flexible wearable electronics.

Investigations of Morphology and Carrier Transport Characteristics in High‐Performance PEDOT:PSS/Tellurium Binary Composite Fibers Produced via Continuous Wet‐Spinning

AbstractFiber‐based flexible thermoelectric (TE) generators are highly desirable due to their capability to convert thermal energy into electricity and their potential applications in wearable electronics. High‐performance poly(3,4‐ethylene dioxythiophene):poly(styrene sulfonate) (PEDOT:PSS)/Tellurium (Te) composite TE fibers have been successfully developed via a continuous wet‐spinning approach followed by sulphuric acid treatment. With a simple pre‐modification to Te nanowires, the inorganic Te fillers form uniform distribution in PEDOT:PSS. At the optimal condition, the composite fibers exhibit a power factor of 233.5 µW m−1 K−2 and mechanical strength of 205 MPa, which are among the highest values reported so far for the PEDOT:PSS‐based TE fibers. From the viewpoint of TE property enhancement mechanism, understanding the morphology and carrier transport behavior in the 1D organic/inorganic composite fibers remains still challenging. On basis of a series of PEDOT:PSS/Te composite fibers with varying Te fractions, orientations of both the inorganic and organic constituents are quantitatively evaluated. Their electrical conductivities and Seebeck coefficients are also analyzed with modified series‐parallel models and energy filtering theory. This work may not only provide a universal approach to produce high‐performance organic/inorganic composite TE fibers for various wearable applications, but also help to understand the morphology and charge transport between heterogeneous phases in a 1D composite.

Dual Interface Modification Using Potassium Aspartic Acid to Realize Low Dark Current, High-Speed Nonfullerene Photodetectors.

Organic photodetectors (OPDs) have attracted tremendous interest due to their potential applications in wearable electronics. However, due to the nonideal contacts between the electrodes and organic semiconductors, OPDs still suffer from high dark current and slow frequency response. Herein, by inserting potassium aspartic acid (PAA) interlayers between ITO/metal oxides and the metal oxides/active layer, the shunts and hole injections are blocked and the energy levels of the electrodes are aligned. As a result, our dual-interface modified OPDs (ITO/PAA/ZnO/PAA/PTB7-Th:ITIC/MoO3/Ag) exhibit suppressed dark current 550 times lower than the reference device, corresponding to specific detectivity of 2.1 × 1012 Jones, broad linear dynamic range of 113 dB, and quick response time to the nanosecond level. PAA interlayers have also been demonstrated to improve the storage stability of OPDs, leading to 10 times slower degradation for the on/off ratio when compared with the reference and conventional polyethylenimine-modified OPDs.