In forensic investigations, the presumptive identification of illicit substances, such as Lysergic Acid Diethylamide (LSD), is crucial. While the Ehrlich's colorimetric reagent (EHR) is commonly employed for LSD detection, producing a characteristic colour change, its lack of selectivity often leads to false-positive or misinterpreted results. Addressing this, we propose a novel method combining electrochemical detection with EHR, enhancing selectivity for LSD’s preliminary identification in forensic samples. This method utilizes a screen-printed carbon electrode (carbon-SPE) in a pH 12 phosphate buffer. We observed two irreversible oxidation processes for LSD at Epa= + 0.35 V (Ox1) and + 0.65 V (Ox2), and for EHR at + 0.62 V and + 0.83 V (vs Ag/AgCl). The LSD + EHR combination displayed three distinct irreversible oxidation processes at + 0.35 V, + 0.66 V, and + 0.86 V. This approach provides three analytical responses for LSD identification: (1) colour change post-EHR test; (2) voltammetric detection of LSD’s two oxidation processes on carbon-SPE; (3) decreased peak current of LSD at Ox1 post-reaction after EHR. Additionally, our method facilitates LSD quantification, exhibiting a low limit of detection (LOD) of 0.69 μmol/L, and consistent electrochemical responses (RSD < 3.0 %) using the same or different carbon-SPEs. Interference studies with other illicit drugs underscored the method’s reliability and selectivity in LSD detection. Moreover, addition-recovery studies on real seized samples approached 100 %, and LSD identification was corroborated by QTOF-LC/MS analyses. Therefore, combining voltammetry with carbon-SPE and EHR offers significant potential for a rapid, simple, and selective LSD screening test in forensic analysis.