Keeving is the removal of nutrients from apple musts due to their binding to pectin, resulting in a slower fermentation and spontaneous arrest. The aim of this study was to determine the effect of keeving on the chemical composition of fermented apple must and on the volatile profile and sensory analysis of apple brandies. We compared the application of keeving during spontaneous fermentation with fermentation carried out by Saccharomyces cerevisiae (SafSpirit HG-1). We evaluated the impact of adding different doses of calcium chloride on various parameters of fermented musts and distillates. Calcium chloride had a greater effect on the ethanol concentration, total extract, and fermentation efficiency than on the type of fermentation used. However, a different phenomenon was observed with respect to the volatiles. The concentration of most of the higher alcohols, acetaldehyde, dodecanal, and geranylaceton, decreased after spontaneous fermentation and increased during the fermentation carried out with Saccharomyces cerevisiae SafSpirit HG-1. In general, the application of keeving contributed to a decrease in the concentration of ethyl and methyl esters, but caused an increase in the concentration of all acetate esters and terpenoids. When the amount of nutrients in the environment is limited and starvation occurs, microorganisms use the available nutrients for basic metabolic processes that allow them to survive and limit the formation of side metabolites such as volatiles. However, most of the samples fermented after the faecal depletion achieved high scores for the floral, fruity, and “overall note” parameters in the sensory analysis. This means that this method, carried out with a properly selected yeast strain, could be feasible for the distilling industry.