Abstract Evolution-informed therapies exploit the ecological and evolutionary consequences of drug resistance to inhibit the expansion of treatment resistant populations and prolong time to progression. One strategy, termed an evolutionary double-bind, uses an initial therapy to elicit a specific adaptive mechanism that is then selectively targeted by a follow-on therapy. Here we examine combining radiation therapy followed by immunotherapy as a double bind strategy. Radiotherapy (RT) induces lethal double-strand DNA breaks in tumor cells and radiosensitivity is governed by the cells’ DNA repair capabilities. Radioresistant cancer cells upregulate DNA damage response pathways. However, successful adaptations to RT and other DNA damaging agents can increase natural killer (NK) cell ligand expression on tumor cells increasing their vulnerability to the immune system. We conducted a multidisciplinary investigation of this potential evolutionary double bind using an isogenic cell line model of radiation resistance derived from an androgen-independent human prostate carcinoma cell line (22Rv1). We demonstrate that RT-resistant cells maintain higher expression of NK cell ligands and have a 2-fold increase in sensitivity to NK cell mediated killing. Furthermore, we show that preferential targeting of the RT-resistant population by NK cells is preserved in competition assays with varying initial population frequencies. Scope of treatment responses are dependent on population frequencies in our in vitro analysis. Mathematical modeling quantified three key elements of a double-bind: cost of resistance, inter-specific competition between RT-sensitive and RT-resistant lines, and preferential targeting of RT-resistant lines by NK cells. We conclude that RT followed by immunotherapy produces an evolutionary double bind that can be exploited in heterogenous tumors to limit RT resistance. Furthermore, model simulations predict that extinction of both populations is achievable by sequential RT and NK cell therapy. Citation Format: Kimberly Luddy, Jeffery West, Mark Robertson-Tessi, Bina Desai, Taylor M. Bursell, Sarah Barrett, Joel Brown, Jacintha O'Sullivan, Robert Gatenby, Laure Marignol, Alexander R. Anderson, Cliona O'Farrelly. Radiotherapy and NK cell-based immunotherapy: An evolutionary double-bind [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2023; Part 1 (Regular and Invited Abstracts); 2023 Apr 14-19; Orlando, FL. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2023;83(7_Suppl):Abstract nr 2858.