Fuchsia sect. Skinnera, the only Old World group in the genus, comprises three species in New Zealand and one in Tahiti. These species include a tree, a large shrub, a climbing-scandent shrub, and a creeping, barely woody plant. The section is extremely distinct from the New World species of Fuchsia, and several sharply contrasting models depicting the evolutionary history of these species and the character state changes associated with habit, breeding systems, and chemistry have been proposed. A chloroplast DNA restriction site analysis of sect Skinnera and two outgroup sections was performed, generating a single tree depicting maternal relationships. This tree is congruent with one previously proposed model and demonstrates that the rare F. procumbens of New Zealand is the sister group to all other species in the section, while F. cyrtandroides of Tahiti is the sister taxon of the two remaining New Zealand species. Based on the chloroplast DNA analysis, a critical reevaluation was made of character state changes in the section relating to morphology, breeding systems, and flavonoid compounds. Phylogenetic analysis of plants using chloroplast DNA (cpDNA) is increasingly providing detailed and often unexpected evidence of evolutionary relationships at many taxonomic levels (Jansen and Palmer 1987a, 1988; Palmer 1986; Palmer and Zamir 1982; Palmer et al. 1983, 1985, 1988; Rieseberg et al. 1988; Smith and Sytsma 1990; Soltis et al. 1988; Sytsma 1990; Sytsma and Gottlieb 1986a, 1986b; Sytsma and Schaal 1985; Sytsma and Smith 1988; Sytsma et al. 1990). A major strength of cpDNA restriction fragment analysis is that it provides numerous, independent molecular characters that can often rigorously define monophyletic lineages. The utility of cpDNA, as well as other molecular markers, in phylogenetic studies can involve two separate steps. The first consists of defining monophyletic lineages, refining estimates of historical genealogies, and changing taxonomic groupings as needed; that is, addressing questions about phylogenetic relationships. The second step involves the application of the resulting cladogram or phylogeny to questions such as the evolution of morphology, breeding systems, and biogeography; that is, addressing questions about character evolution (where, when, and how the character states arose). Through this secondary application, molecular phylogenetics is having a considerable impact on many aspects of systematics, evolution, genetics, and ecology. This two-step process is especially crucial and informative when dealing with groups of species that show tremendous divergence and radiation in morphology, chemicals, and ecology (Sytsma 1990). Analysis of non-molecular characters in such groups can often be phylogenetically uninformative or even misleading because of the operation of strong selection and resulting homoplasy, difficulty in ordering or even polarizing character states, the high number of autapomorphies, and the lack of well defined synapomorphies. An exemplary model of a lineage that has undergone extraordinary radiation but is difficult to interpret in an evolutionary sense is Fuchsia sect. Skinnera. This section has been the focus of several competing hypotheses concerning the evolution and relationships of component taxa and the nature of changes in habit, morphology, floral biology, flavonoids, and distribution. The genus Fuchsia, distinctive in the Onagraceae by its fleshy fruits, corolloid calyx, and unspecialized features in floral and vegetative
Read full abstract