Anaerobic Digestion Of Pig Manure Research Articles

Hydrothermal carbonisation of manure-derived digestates: Chemical properties and heavy metals distribution in end-products

Hydrothermal carbonisation (HTC) presents a promising method for converting high-moisture biomass into hydrochars, which can serve as valuable sources of carbon and nutrients for soil applications. However, there is a lack of comprehensive understanding regarding the characterisation and potential environmental risks of hydrochars with respect to different feedstock types and operating conditions especially when compared to those obtained from dry pyrolysis. This research aims to investigate the chemical properties and re-partitioning of Ni, Cd, Cr and Pb in the HTC-treated mono-and co-digestates derived from the anaerobic digestion of pig manure and ensiled maize. The hypothesis states that HTC will further reduce the potential availability of these metals, enhancing the quality of the digestates as bio-based fertilisers or soil improvers. Hydrochars were produced from homogeneous digestate slurries, derived from a unique source facility, VeDoWs system, and maize from contaminated land, containing potentially higher concentrations of heavy metals (HMs) compared to pig slurry. The derived hydrochars were further analysed for their composition and HMs extractability. Higher yields were observed for both digestates at lower temperatures and shorter residence times, whereas the total nitrogen and carbon content showed an opposite trend. The composition of the digestates and the HTC operating parameters influenced the enrichment of nutrients and release of the HMs from the hydrochars, enabling their classification as potential solid organic fertilisers according to the Fertilising Products Regulation (EU) 2019/1009. Notably, the HTC treatment at 200–220 °C for 4 h resulted in the highest immobilization of Ni, Cd, Cr, and Pb in both digestates. This treatment strategy effectively reduced the ecological risk index of these products, thereby mitigating potential environmental impacts associated with the HMs contamination.

Unveiling the synergy of volatile fatty acids and ammonia nitrogen in optimizing methane production during dry anaerobic digestion of pig manure and corn straw

Dry anaerobic digestion (AD) is vulnerable to volatile fatty acids (VFA) and ammonia nitrogen. Understanding their synergy is crucial for optimizing strategies. In this study, the digestive performance, microbial dynamics, metabolic pathways, and synergistic relationships were investigated in the dry AD process by adding different concentrations of acetic acid (2, 5, and 8 mg/g) and urea (1, 5 mg/g N). Results showed that acid inhibition was caused by excessive pH reduction due to VFA accumulation. Propionic acid was the primary form of VFA accumulation. The inhibition of VFA accumulation could be alleviated using a low concentration of ammonia nitrogen (1 mg/g N urea) or be strengthened using a high concentration of ammonia nitrogen (5 mg/g N urea). Compared with the control group (82.2 mL/g VS), VFA and 1 mg/g N urea had a synergistic facilitation effect on the methane production (increasing by 1.7 %-18.1 %). This synergistic effect shortened the lag phases, enhanced the activity of Caldicoprobacter and Methanosarcina, increased the expression of genes encoding functional enzymes involved in the acetoclastic-methanogenic pathway. By contrast, VFA and 5 mg/g N urea had a synergistic inhibition effect on methane production (decreasing by 65.7 %–69.8 %). This synergistic effect prolonged lag phases, increased the relative abundance of ammonia-tolerant and acid-tolerant microbial (such as Methanoculleus) and reduced the expression of genes encoding functional enzymes involved in the hydrogenotrophic-methanogenic pathway. These results improve the understanding of methane regulation during dry AD.

Effects of Hydrothermal Pretreatment and Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure on the Antibiotic Removal and Methane Production.

Whether advanced biological waste treatment technologies, such as hydrothermal pretreatment (HTP) integrated anaerobic digestion (AD), could enhance the removal of different antibiotics remains unclear. This study investigated the outcome of antibiotics and methane productivity during pig manure treatment via HTP, AD, and HTP + AD. Results showed improved removal efficiency of sulfadiazine (SDZ), oxytetracycline (OTC), and enrofloxacin (ENR) with increased HTP temperatures (70, 90, 120, 150, and 170°C). OTC achieved the highest removal efficiency of 86.8% at 170°C because of its high sensitivity to heat treatment. For AD, SDZ exhibited resistance with a removal efficiency of 52.8%. However, OTC and ENR could be removed completely within 30days. When HTP was used prior to AD, OTC and ENR could achieve complete removal. However, residual SDZ levels reduced to 20% and 16% at 150 and 170°C, respectively. The methanogenic potential showed an overall upward trend as the HTP temperature increased. Microbial analysis revealed the antibiotics-induced enrichment of specific microorganisms during AD. Firmicutes were the dominant bacterial phylum, with their abundance positively correlated with the addition of antibiotics. Methanobacterium and Methanosarcina emerged as the dominant archaea that drove methane production during AD. Thus, HTP can be a potential pretreatment before AD to reduce antibiotic-related risks in manure waste handling.

Techno-Economic and Life Cycle Assessment of a Small-Scale Integrated Biorefinery for Butyric-Acid Production in Chile

This study evaluates the techno-economic and environmental feasibility of a small-scale biorefinery in Chile’s La Araucanía Region, which utilizes wheat straw as feedstock to produce butyric acid using Clostridium tyrobutyricum. Two scenarios were considered; the standalone wheat straw biorefinery and its integration with the anaerobic digestion of pig manure for biogas production, coupled with a cogeneration system, using the xylo-oligosaccharides and lignin obtained in the pretreatment. The simulations were carried out using Aspen Plus, while the Aspen Process Economic Analyzer was used to perform the economic evaluation. The simulation results were validated with experimental data from the literature. An economic assessment was performed considering the different processes involved. A cradle-to-gate life-cycle analysis (LCA) was also applied to evaluate the different environmental impacts. Both studied scenarios were economically feasible, with the highest butyric acid production cost being USD 2.97/kgbutyricacid; however, this value is still higher compared to corn-based biorefineries. Annexed biogas production increased the costs and was less economically attractive. Nonetheless, the integrations with biogas production had lower environmental impacts, except in the photochemical oxidant formation category, which was higher because of the combustion gases obtained by the cogeneration system. A lower carbon footprint (23.5 kg CO2-eq. per ton of wheat straw) was obtained for the scenario including biogas production.

Degradation Performance of Estrogen During Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure

Degradation Performance of Estrogen During Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure

Layer Inoculation as a New Technology to Resist Volatile Fatty Acid Inhibition during Solid-State Anaerobic Digestion: Methane Yield Performance and Microbial Responses

Solid-state anaerobic digestion is easily inhibited by high volatile fatty acid induced by high total solids, although it is a promising technology. Previous studies on volatile fatty acid inhibition mainly focused on total solid content, co-digestion substrates, and external additives. The present study proposed a new inoculation method named layer inoculation and compared it to premixing inoculation in the solid-state anaerobic digestion of pig manure and maize straw. The results showed that the cumulative CH4 yields from layer inoculation (211.5 mL/g-VS) were 5.64 times more than premixing inoculation (37.5 mL/g-VS) under a low inoculation ratio (25%), with the values of total volatile fatty acid being greater than 30.0 mg/g. The concentrations of total VFAs and acetic acid from layer inoculation decreased dramatically during days 18–43. Layer inoculation also showed wider specific methane yield peaks and shorter startup times than premixing inoculation. Methanosphaerula and Methanothrix were the most dominant genera, while the genus Methanosphaerula did not correlate with volatile fatty acids, pH, or total ammonia nitrogen. The hydrogenotrophic methanogen pathway was predominant during solid-state anaerobic digestion; the shift from hydrogenotrophic to acetoclastic occurred in premixing inoculation, and it was stable in layer inoculation (61.20–68.88%). Overall, layer inoculation can effectively enhance methane production under high volatile fatty acid concentrations compared with premixing inoculation.

Potential Greenhouse Gas Mitigation from Utilising Pig Manure and Grass for Hydrothermal Carbonisation and Anaerobic Digestion in the UK, EU, and China

Pig manure currently results in sizeable greenhouse gas emissions, during storage and spreading to land. Anaerobic digestion and hydrothermal carbonisation could provide significant greenhouse gas mitigation, as well as generate renewable heat and power (with anaerobic digestion), or a peat-like soil amendment product (with hydrothermal carbonisation). The greenhouse gas mitigation potential associated with avoidance of pig manure storage and spreading in the UK, EU, and China, as well as the potential to provide heat and power by anaerobic digestion and soil amendment products by hydrothermal carbonisation was herein determined. In each case, the mono-conversion of pig manure is compared to co-conversion with a 50:50 mixture of pig manure with grass. Anaerobic digestion displayed a greater greenhouse gas mitigation potential than hydrothermal carbonisation in all cases, and co-processing with grass greatly enhances greenhouse gas mitigation potential. China has the largest greenhouse gas mitigation potential (129 MT CO2 eq), and greatest mitigation per kg of pig manure (1.8 kgCO2/kg pig manure volatile solids). The energy grid carbon intensity has a significant impact on the greenhouse gas mitigation potential of the different approaches in the different regions. Pig manure is generated in large amounts in China, and the energy generated from biogas offsets a higher carbon intensity grid. Greenhouse gas savings from the anaerobic digestion of pig manure and grass have been calculated to provide a significant potential for reducing total greenhouse gas emissions representation in China (1.05%), the EU (0.92%), and the UK (0.19%). Overall, the utilisation of pig manure could bring about substantial greenhouse savings, especially through co-digestion of pig manure with grass in countries with large pig farming industries and carbon intense energy mixes.

Hydrothermal treatment enhances energy recovery from pig manure digestate and improves the properties of residues

Energy recovery from biowaste is of high significance for a sustainable society. Herein, hydrothermal treatment (HT) was applied to valorize pig manure digestate. The effects of hydrothermal operational parameters, including temperature (130-250 °C), residence time (15-90 min), and total solid (TS) concentration (10%-20%), on reducing sugar yield were investigated in this study. Among them, hydrothermal temperature was identified as the most important factor influencing reducing sugar yield, followed by the TS concentration and time. The optimal hydrothermal conditions for the pig manure digestate were 175.6 °C, 35.4 min and a TS concentration of 10% with a reduced sugar yield of 9.81 mg gTS−1. The addition of hydrolysate could enhance methane production by 21.6-50.4% from the anaerobic digestion of pig manure than that without the hydrolysate addition. After HT, the hygienic quality, including fecal coliform number and ascaris egg mortality, was improved in the residual digestate. Antibiotics such as sulfamonomethoxine, oxytetracycline, doxycycline and sulfaclodazine in the pig manure digestate were decomposed during HT and decreased environmental risk. These findings indicated that the hydrothermal process might be an effective technique to recover energy from the digestate of livestock and poultry manure and to improve the residual digestate for subsequent utilization.

Effects of environmental factors on low temperature anaerobic digestion of pig manure

In this study, we investigated the inhibitory effect of low temperature on biogas fermentation system. Biogas fermentation inoculum was domesticated at 4 °C, and subsequently inoculated into pig manure feedstock in a batch biogas fermentation process. A low-temperature biogas fermentation system was maintained at 9 °C, and its abiotic factors, bacterial community, and archaeal community were determined. The results showed that (1) the biogas fermentation lasted for 160 days, with a total gas production of 19,150 ml, including N2 production of 11,370 ml, CO2 production of 3,534 ml, and CH4 production of 3,031 ml. (2) The average relative abundance of the primary dominant bacterium operational taxonomic unit (OTU) was 30%, with 100% similarity to Pseudomonas caeni , atypical denitrifying bacterium. The average relative abundance of the secondary dominant bacterium OTU was 20.36%, with 99% similarity to Clostridium cellulovorans, a typical cellulose- and hemicellulose-degrading bacterium. The average relative abundance of the primary dominant methanogenic archaeon OTU was 7.22%, with 99% similarity to Methanosphaera cuniculi, a typical methylotrophic methanogen, and the secondary dominant methanogenic archaeon OTU had an average relative abundance of 4.15%, with 98% similarity to Methanocorpusculum sinense, a typical hydrogenotrophic methanogen. (3) The primary dominant bacterial genus Pseudomonas exhibited highly significant negative correlations with the dominant biogas-producing microorganisms such as Clostridium, Terrisporobacter, Turicibacter, Methanosphaera, and Methanocorpusculum. We concluded that (1) high concentrations of abiotic factors such as ammonia nitrogen, acetic acid, and propionic acid were important indicators of relatively poor operation of low-temperature biogas fermentation systems, while (2) high numbers of MCG archaea and Pseudomonas were important biotic factors showing comparatively poor operation of the system.

The Material Flow and Stability Performance of the Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure after (Hyper)-Thermophilic Hydrolysis Is Introduced: A Comparison with a Single-Stage Process

Slow hydrolysis persistently affects the anaerobic digestion of animal manure. Thermophilic and hyper-thermophilic treatments introduced into a two-stage anaerobic process treating pig manure were investigated, with a single-stage mesophilic process as a control. The results from the 100-day experiment showed the thermophilic-mesophilic system had the highest removal efficiency of volatile solids at 60.8%, 18% higher than the single-stage process. The thermophilic and hyper-thermophilic hydrolysis reactors contributed 23.5% and 21.7% solubilization of chemical oxygen demand (COD), respectively. The hydrolysis efficiency achieved in the single process was 49.7%, which was lower than the hydrolysis in the two-stage processes. Approximately 60% of COD was distributed in the solid fraction in the first stage, and more than half of the particle COD continued to hydrolyze in the subsequent second stage. The mass balance of COD and volatile solids removal performance illustrated the advantages of the temperature-phased process. Comparatively, the three mesophilic reactors all had strong stability.

Passivation mechanism of Cu and Zn with the introduction of composite passivators during anaerobic digestion of pig manure

Heavy metals in livestock manure pose a threat to the environment after biogas fertilizer being utilized, while its bioavailability is reduced substantially by passivator during the anaerobic digestion. In this study, an optimal composite passivator of humic acid, fly ash and biochar with proportion of 7.5%:7.5%:7.5% and 5.0%:7.5%:7.5% is obtained and the passivation mechanism on Cu and Zn during anaerobic digestion of pig manure is explored. The content of humic acid (HA) in biogas residue increased by 15.66–27.82%, which promoted the transformation from FA-Cu/Zn to HA-Cu/Zn and was beneficial to the passivation of Cu and Zn. The bioavailability of Cu and Zn was reduced by the adsorption and complexation at the early and middle stages of anaerobic digestion. Humic substances play a major role in the passivation of heavy metals at the late stage. The composite passivator can improve the humification degree of biogas residue and reduce heavy metal biotoxicity.

Effect of water regime on the dynamics of free ammonia during high solid anaerobic digestion of pig manure

Free ammonia (FAN) inhibition is commonly encountered during high solid anaerobic digestion (HSAD) of pig manure. The performance of HSAD is highly related to its operational water regime; however, little information is available regarding the dynamics of free ammonia with varied water regimes. In this work, four treatments were set with equal amount of water supply but varied addition frequencies, i.e. add once but at different times in treatments T1 and T2, add twice in T3 while it was three times in treatment T4. Results showed that the whole methanogenic process ran smoothly with the average methane gas production rate maintaining at 191.1 LCH4/kgVSadded. Although a higher methane gas production rate of 217.4 LCH4/kgVSadded was achieved in T1, one time water addition triggered a higher ammonia inhibition potential. Cumulative FAN release was 6.03 mgFAN/kgVSadded in T1 while the balance between FAN and ammonia tended to the fraction of FAN. In T4, cumulative FAN of 5.07 mgFAN/kgVSadded was evolved, which was lower than that in T1 but similar to the situation in T2. The lowest FAN was observed in T3, indicating that a moderate frequency of dilution might be conducive to alleviate free ammonia inhibition.

The effect of heat pre-treatment on the anaerobic digestion of high-solid pig manure under high organic loading level.

Since more and more large-scale farms appear in China and changes in fecal sewage source disposal, the production of high-concentration solid manure waste is also increasing, and its conversion and utilization are gaining attention. This study investigated the effect of heat pre-treatment (HPT) on the thermophilic anaerobic digestion (AD) of high-solid manure (HSM). Pig manure (PM) feed with a total solids of 13% was used for the HPT and subsequent anaerobic digestion (AD) test. The HPT was carried out at 60°C, 80°C, and 100°C, respectively, for 15min after the heating reached the set temperature. The results show that HPT led to PM feed COD solubilization, observing a maximum increase of 24.57% after pretreated at 100°C, and the treated PM feed under this condition received the maximum methane production potential of 264.64 mL·g-1 VS in batch AD test, which was 28.76% higher than that of the untreated group. Another semi-continuous AD test explored the maximum volume biogas production rate (VBPR). It involves two organic loading rates (OLR) of 13.4 and 17.8g VSadded·L-1·d-1. The continuous test exhibited that all the HPT groups could produce biogas normally when the OLR increased to the high level, while the digester fed with untreated PM showed failure. The maximum VBPR of 4.71LL-1·d-1 was observed from PM feed after pre-treated at 100°C and running at the high OLR. This reveals that thermal treatment can weaken the impact of a larger volume of feed on the AD system. Energy balance analysis demonstrates that it is necessary to use a heat exchanger to reuse energy in the HPT process to reduce the amount of energy input. In this case, the energy input to energy output (E i /E o ) ranged from 0.34 to 0.55, which was much less than one, suggesting that biogas increment due to heat treatment can reasonably cover the energy consumption of the pre-treatment itself. Thus combining HPT and high-load anaerobic digestion of PM was suitable.

Effects of Inorganic Passivators on Gas Production and Heavy Metal Passivation Performance during Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure and Corn Straw.

The treatment of livestock manure caused by the expansion of the breeding industry in China has attracted wide attention. Heavy metals in pig manure can pollute soil and water and even transfer to crops, posing harm to humans through the food chain. In this study, corn straw was selected as the additive and introduced into the anaerobic digestion. Sepiolite (SE), ferric oxide (Fe2O3), attapulgite (AT) and ferric sulfate (FeSO4) were used as passivators to compare the effects of these inorganic passivators on gas production and passivation of heavy metals during the process of the anaerobic digestion. When the dry mass ratio of pig manure to straw is 8:2, the gas production efficiency is optimal. SE, AT and ferric sulfate have a much stronger ability to improve gas production performance than Fe2O3. The total gas production increased by 10.34%, 6.62% and 4.56%, and the average methane production concentration increased by 0.7%, 0.3% and 0.4%, respectively. The influence of SE, AT and ferric sulfate on the passivation of heavy metals is much better than Fe2O3, and the fractions in biological effective forms of Cu and Zn reduced by 41.87 and 19.32%, respectively. The anaerobic digestion of mixed materials is conducive to the gas production and the passivation of heavy metals. Therefore, SE, AT and ferric sulfate are selected as composite passivators, and the optimal ratio of inorganic composite passivators i: AT 7.5 g/L, ferric sulfate 5 g/L and SE 7.5 g/L, according to the results of orthogonal experiments. This study can provide a theoretical basis for the safe application of biogas fertilizers.

Methane Production Characteristics of an Anaerobic Co-Digestion of Pig Manure and Fermented Liquid Feed.

Methane production characteristics of anaerobic co-digestion of pig manure (PM) and fermented liquid feed (FLF) were investigated in a continuous digester under mesophilic conditions. The experiment followed three phases. PM alone was digested in phase I. In phases II and III, PM and FLF were mixed in a ratio of 95:5 and 90:10 (% v/v), respectively. The specific methane yields (SMYs) during phases I, II, and III were 238, 278, and 326.8 mLCH4·gVS−1-added, respectively. It was due to the effect of balancing the feedstock carbon-to-nitrogen ratio by adding FLF. This improvement can also be attributed to the readily biodegradable compounds in the FLF. The higher SMY obtained in this study showed a positive synergistic effect in the anaerobic co-digestion of PM and FLF. The results also indicate that adding the FLF positively affected and maintained a constant pH level, avoiding volatile fatty acid accumulation and ammonia inhibition in the anaerobic digestion (AD). Thus, this study provides valuable information regarding the usage of unused or wasted FLF as a co-substrate for the practical AD of PM. The production of fermented liquid additives such as FLF to improve the methane production from the AD of PM is a potential novel alternative to food waste recycling in Japan, besides compost and animal feeding.

Fe2(SO4)3-assisted anaerobic digestion of pig manure: the performance of biogas yield and heavy metal passivation

Abstract The harmless disposal and recycling treatment technology of livestock manure has received increasing attention in recent years. In this study, Fe2(SO4)3 was added during anaerobic digestion (AD) of pig manure (PM) to investigate the effects of different doses of Fe2(SO4)3 on biogas yield and heavy metal passivation. The results showed that the highest biogas yield was observed after adding a moderate dose of Fe2(SO4)3 (3%, based on the total solids), while the elevated result was inhibited as the Fe2(SO4)3 dosage increased. The analysis of solid digestate (solid matter remaining after AD) revealed that AD effectively passivated Cu, Zn, and As, which can be further improved with the addition of Fe2(SO4)3. However, the passivated Cd performance during this process was negligible. Furthermore, seed germination index (GI) trial results indicated that Fe2(SO4)3-assisted AD reduced the toxicity of end products to plants. To summarize, AD assisted by the addition of an appropriate amount of Fe2(SO4)3 is feasible to treat PM, and the addition of Fe2(SO4)3 at 3% was the most economic and environmental-friendly. This work could provide useful methods for the control of heavy metal pollution in the soil. Article highlights Adding 3% dose of Fe2(SO4)3 could increase methane yield by 66.76%. Fe2(SO4)3-assisted AD passivated HMs and reduced their bioavailability. The 3% Fe2(SO4)3-assisted AD significantly reduced the toxicity of end products to plants.

Effects of different low temperature conditions on anaerobic digestion efficiency of pig manure and composition of archaea community.

To explore the effect of low temperature on the anaerobic digestion of pig manure, the anaerobic digestion experiment was carried out under the conditions of inoculum concentration of 30% and TS of 8%. Five low-temperature gradients of 4, 8, 12, 16 and 20 °C were set to study the activities of gas production, pH, solluted chemical oxygen demand (SCOD), volatile fatty acids (VFAs), coenzymes F420 and archaea community composition in the digestion process. The results were demonstrated: as the temperature decreased, the more unstable the gas production became, the less gas production produced, and the later the gas peak occurred. There were no significant peaks at either 4 °C or 8 °C, and the SCOD was unstable over time. From 12 °C, the SCOD increased over time, and the higher the temperature, the faster the growth trend. The pH was always greater than 7.6. 8, 12, 16, 20 °C had different degrees of VFAs accumulation at the late digestion stage. The higher the temperature, the greater the amount of volatile acid accumulation. When the VFAs of each reactor reached the maximum, the proportion of acetic acid also reached the highest. The digestion system of the five treatment groups was dominated by hydrogen-nutrient methanogenic pathway. The results could provide a further reference for the mechanism of anaerobic digestion of pig manure at low temperatures.

Pilot-Scale Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure with Thermal Pretreatment: Stability Monitoring to Improve the Potential for Obtaining Methane

Monitoring and controlling stability in anaerobic digestion (AD) systems are essential, since it allows to obtain information that helps to take corrective actions in case of deviations in the system and to guarantee a stable performance in the biogas production. In this work, a pilot-scale CSRT reactor (1 m3) was monitored during the anaerobic digestion of pig manure with thermal pretreatment (80 °C) operated at thermophilic temperature (45 °C). The ratio of the volatile organic acids (FOS) to the total inorganic carbonate (TAC) and the pH were the indicators used during the monitoring process to identify deviations in the AD system. Additionally, alkaline solution NaOH (98%) was applied to counteract pH deviations and maintain stability. Chemical oxygen demand (COD) and biogas composition were measured during the AD process. It was found that during the AD process, the FOS/TAC was between the range of 0.5 and 1. The results revealed that, in the anaerobic digestion of pig manure with thermal pretreatment, the pH was kept stable in the range of 6.7–7.4 since no medium acidification occurred. Additionally, the tendency of the chemical oxygen demand decreased from the 10th day of operation, product of the favorable enzymatic activity of the microorganisms, reflected in the stable production of biogas (69% CH4). Finally, it is concluded that thermophilic AD of pig manure with thermal pretreatment is a good option when it is carried out efficiently by employing an adequate energetic integration.

Passivation Mechanism of Cu and Zn with the Introduction of Composite Passivators During Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure

Passivation Mechanism of Cu and Zn with the Introduction of Composite Passivators During Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure

Coupling of Anaerobic Digestion and Struvite Precipitation in the Same Reactor: Effect of Zeolite and Bischofite as Mg2+ Source

The aim of this research was to assess the simultaneous effect of zeolite and bischofite on estruvite production in an anaerobic digester treating pig slurry as substrate. Three ratios (5:1, 6:1 and 7:1) of Mg-P were used for evaluating the effect of only bischofite on anaerobic digestion. For assessing the simultaneous effect of zeolite and bischofite on anaerobic digestion, three mass ratios of zeolite:bischofite (1, 5 and 10%) were used. As results, bischofite as Mg+2 source served to decrease the total phosphorous (TP) concentration in the anaerobic digestion of pig manure without affecting the maximum methane production rate or methane yield of the system. An average 82.5% TP removal was found in the reactors with bischofite during the first 5 days of digestion. Nevertheless, bischofite increased the lag-phase of the system. The simultaneous presence of zeolite and bischofite (1% ratio with respect to bischofite) caused a TP removal of 65.6% and increased the methane yield by up to 19.9% compared to a system without zeolite or bischofite. Thus, it is feasible to use bischofite and zeolite as enhancers for the simultaneous production of biogas and struvite inside an anaerobic digester treating piggery wastewater.