Alternating Access Model Research Articles

Structural basis for the transport and regulation mechanism of the Multidrug resistance-associated protein 2.

Multidrug resistance-associated protein 2 (MRP2) is an ATP-powered exporter important for maintaining liver homeostasis and a potential contributor to chemotherapeutic resistance. Deficiencies in MRP2 function are associated with Dubin-Johnson Syndrome and increased vulnerability to liver injury from cytotoxic drugs. Using cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM), we determined the structures of human MRP2 in three conformational states: an autoinhibited state, a substrate-bound pre-translocation state, and an ATP-bound post-translocation state. These structures show that MRP2 functions through the classic alternating access model, driven by ATP binding and hydrolysis. Its cytosolic regulatory (R) domain serves as a selectivity gauge, wherein only sufficiently high concentrations of substrates can effectively compete with and disengage the R domain to initiate transport. Comparative structural analyses of MRP2 in complex with different substrates reveal how the transporter recognizes a diverse array of compounds, highlighting the transporter's role in multidrug resistance.

Architecture and autoinhibitory mechanism of the plasma membrane Na+/H+ antiporter SOS1 in Arabidopsis

Salt-overly-sensitive 1 (SOS1) is a unique electroneutral Na+/H+ antiporter at the plasma membrane of higher plants and plays a central role in resisting salt stress. SOS1 is kept in a resting state with basal activity and activated upon phosphorylation. Here, we report the structures of SOS1. SOS1 forms a homodimer, with each monomer composed of transmembrane and intracellular domains. We find that SOS1 is locked in an occluded state by shifting of the lateral-gate TM5b toward the dimerization domain, thus shielding the Na+/H+ binding site. We speculate that the dimerization of the intracellular domain is crucial to stabilize the transporter in this specific conformation. Moreover, two discrete fragments and a residue W1013 are important to prevent the transition of SOS1 to an alternative conformational state, as validated by functional complementation assays. Our study enriches understanding of the alternate access model of eukaryotic Na+/H+ exchangers.

Collective Domain Motion Facilitates Water Transport in SGLT1.

The human sodium-glucose cotransporter protein (SGLT1) is an important representative of the sodium solute symporters belonging to the secondary active transporters that are critical to the homeostasis of sugar, sodium, and water in the cell. The underlying transport mechanism of SGLT1 is based on switching between inward- and outward-facing conformations, known as the alternating access model, which is crucial for substrate transport, and has also been postulated for water permeation. However, the nature of water transport remains unclear and is disputed along the passive and active transport, with the latter postulating the presence of the pumping effect. To better examine the water transport in SGLT1, we performed a series of equilibrium all-atom molecular dynamics simulations, totaling over 6 μs of sample representative conformational states of SGLT1 and its complexes, with the natural substrates, ions, and inhibitors. In addition to elucidating the basic physical factors influencing water permeation, such as channel openings and energetics, we focus on dynamic flexibility and its relationship with domain motion. Our results clearly demonstrate a dependence of instantaneous water flux on the channel opening and local water diffusion in the channel, strongly supporting the existence of a passive water transport in SGLT1. In addition, a strong correlation found between the local water diffusion and protein domain motion, resembling the "rocking-bundle" motion, reveals its facilitating role in the water transport.

The Switch and Reciprocating Models for the Function of ABC Multidrug Exporters: Perspectives on Recent Research.

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters comprise a large superfamily of primary active transporters, which are integral membrane proteins that couple energy to the uphill vectorial transport of substrates across cellular membranes, with concomitant hydrolysis of ATP. ABC transporters are found in all living organisms, coordinating mostly import in prokaryotes and export in eukaryotes. Unlike the highly conserved nucleotide binding domains (NBDs), sequence conservation in the transmembrane domains (TMDs) is low, with their divergent nature likely reflecting a need to accommodate a wide range of substrate types in terms of mass and polarity. An explosion in high resolution structural analysis over the past decade and a half has produced a wealth of structural information for ABCs. Based on the structures, a general mechanism for ABC transporters has been proposed, known as the Switch or Alternating Access Model, which holds that the NBDs are widely separated, with the TMDs and NBDs together forming an intracellular-facing inverted "V" shape. Binding of two ATPs and the substrate to the inward-facing conformation induces a transition to an outward conformation. Despite this apparent progress, certainty around the transport mechanism for any given ABC remains elusive. How substrate binding and transport is coupled to ATP binding and hydrolysis is not known, and there is a large body of biochemical and biophysical data that is at odds with the widely separated NBDs being a functional physiological state. An alternative Constant Contact model has been proposed in which the two NBSs operate 180 degrees out of phase with respect to ATP hydrolysis, with the NBDs remaining in close proximity throughout the transport cycle and operating in an asymmetric allosteric manner. The two models are discussed in the light of recent nuclear magnetic resonance and hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry analyses of three ABC exporters.

Protein dynamics of a light-driven Na+ pump rhodopsin probed using a tryptophan residue near the retinal chromophore.

Direct observation of protein structural changes during ion transport in ion pumps provides valuable insights into the mechanism of ion transport. In this study, we examined structural changes in the light-driven sodium ion (Na+) pump rhodopsin KR2 on the sub-millisecond time scale, corresponding with the uptake and release of Na+. We compared the ion-pumping activities and transient absorption spectra of WT and the W215F mutant, in which the Trp215 residue located near the retinal chromophore on the cytoplasmic side was replaced with a Phe residue. Our findings indicated that atomic contacts between the bulky side chain of Trp215 and the C20 methyl group of the retinal chromophore promote relaxation of the retinal chromophore from the 13-cis to the all-trans form. Since Trp215 is conserved in other ion-pumping rhodopsins, the present results suggest that this residue commonly acts as a mechanical transducer. In addition, we measured time-resolved ultraviolet resonance Raman (UVRR) spectra to show that the environment around Trp215 becomes less hydrophobic at 1 ms after photoirradiation and recovers to the unphotolyzed state with a time constant of around 10 ms. These time scales correspond to Na+ uptake and release, suggesting evolution of a transient ion channel at the cytoplasmic side for Na+ uptake, consistent with the alternating-access model of ion pumps. The time-resolved UVRR technique has potential for application to other ion-pumping rhodopsins and could provide further insights into the mechanism of ion transport.

ABCA1 is an extracellular phospholipid translocase

Production of high density lipoprotein (HDL) requires ATP-binding cassette transporter A1 (ABCA1) to drive phospholipid (PL) from the plasma membrane into extracellular apolipoprotein A-I. Here, we use simulations to show that domains of ABCA1 within the plasma membrane remove PL from the membrane’s outer leaflet. In our simulations, after the lipid diffuses into the interior of ABCA1’s outward-open cavity, PL extracted by the gateway passes through a ring-shaped domain, the annulus orifice, which forms the base of an elongated hydrophobic tunnel in the transporter’s extracellular domain. Engineered mutations in the gateway and annulus strongly inhibit lipid export by ABCA1 without affecting cell-surface expression levels. Our finding that ABCA1 extracts lipid from the outer face of the plasma membrane and forces it through its gateway and annulus into an elongated hydrophobic tunnel contrasts with the alternating access model, which proposes that ABCA1 flops PL substrate from the inner leaflet to the outer leaflet of the membrane. Consistent with our model, ABCA1 lacks the charged amino acid residues in the transmembrane domain found in the floppase members of the ABC transporter family.

Proton coupling and the multiscale kinetic mechanism of a peptide transporter

Proton-coupled peptide transporters (POTs) are crucial for the uptake of di- and tripeptides as well as drug and prodrug molecules in prokaryotes and eukaryotic cells. We illustrate from multiscale modeling how transmembrane proton flux couples within a POT protein to drive essential steps of the full functional cycle: 1) protonation of a glutamate on transmembrane helix 7 (TM7) opens the extracellular gate, allowing ligand entry; 2) inward proton flow induces the cytosolic release of ligand by varying the protonation state of a second conserved glutamate on TM10; 3) proton movement between TM7 and TM10 is thermodynamically driven and kinetically permissible via water proton shuttling without the participation of ligand. Our results, for the first time, give direct computational confirmation for the alternating access model of POTs, and point to a quantitative multiscale kinetic picture of the functioning protein mechanism.

General principles of secondary active transporter function.

Transport of ions and small molecules across the cell membrane against electrochemical gradients is catalyzed by integral membrane proteins that use a source of free energy to drive the energetically uphill flux of the transported substrate. Secondary active transporters couple the spontaneous influx of a "driving" ion such as Na+ or H+ to the flux of the substrate. The thermodynamics of such cyclical non-equilibrium systems are well understood, and recent work has focused on the molecular mechanism of secondary active transport. The fact that these transporters change their conformation between an inward-facing and outward-facing conformation in a cyclical fashion, called the alternating access model, is broadly recognized as the molecular framework in which to describe transporter function. However, only with the advent of high resolution crystal structures and detailed computer simulations, it has become possible to recognize common molecular-level principles between disparate transporter families. Inverted repeat symmetry in secondary active transporters has shed light onto how protein structures can encode a bi-stable two-state system. Based on structural data, three broad classes of alternating access transitions have been described as rocker-switch, rocking-bundle, and elevator mechanisms. More detailed analysis indicates that transporters can be understood as gated pores with at least two coupled gates. These gates are not just a convenient cartoon element to illustrate a putative mechanism but map to distinct parts of the transporter protein. Enumerating all distinct gate states naturally includes occluded states in the alternating access picture and also suggests what kind of protein conformations might be observable. By connecting the possible conformational states and ion/substrate bound states in a kinetic model, a unified picture emerges in which the symporter, antiporter, and uniporter functions are extremes in a continuum of functionality. As usual with biological systems, few principles and rules are absolute and exceptions are discussed as well as how biological complexity may be integrated in quantitative kinetic models that may provide a bridge from the structure to function.

Random-walk model of the sodium-glucose transporter SGLT2 with stochastic steps and inhibition

Random-walk models are frequently used to model distinct natural phenomena such as diffusion processes, stock-market fluctuations, and biological systems. Here, we present a random-walk model to describe the dynamics of glucose uptake by the sodium-glucose transporter of type 2, SGLT2. Our starting point is the canonical alternating-access model, which suggests the existence of six states for the transport cycle. We propose the inclusion of two new states to this canonical model. The first state is added to implement the recent discovery that the Na+ ion can exit before the sugar is released into the proximal tubule epithelial cells. The resulting model is a seven-state mechanism with stochastic steps. Then we determined the transition probabilities between these seven states and used them to write a set of master equations to describe the time evolution of the system. We showed that our model converges to the expected equilibrium configuration and that the binding of Na+ and glucose to SGLT2 in the inward-facing conformation must be necessarily unordered. After that, we added another state to implement inhibition in the model. Our results reproduce the experimental dependence of glucose uptake on the inhibitor concentration and they reveal that the inhibitors act by decreasing the number of available SGLT2s, which increases the chances of glucose escaping reabsorption.

High-pH structure of EmrE reveals the mechanism of proton-coupled substrate transport

The homo-dimeric bacterial membrane protein EmrE effluxes polyaromatic cationic substrates in a proton-coupled manner to cause multidrug resistance. We recently determined the structure of substrate-bound EmrE in phospholipid bilayers by measuring hundreds of protein-ligand HN–F distances for a fluorinated substrate, 4-fluoro-tetraphenylphosphonium (F4-TPP+), using solid-state NMR. This structure was solved at low pH where one of the two proton-binding Glu14 residues is protonated. Here, to understand how substrate transport depends on pH, we determine the structure of the EmrE-TPP complex at high pH, where both Glu14 residues are deprotonated. The high-pH complex exhibits an elongated and hydrated binding pocket in which the substrate is similarly exposed to the two sides of the membrane. In contrast, the low-pH complex asymmetrically exposes the substrate to one side of the membrane. These pH-dependent EmrE conformations provide detailed insights into the alternating-access model, and suggest that the high-pH conformation may facilitate proton binding in the presence of the substrate, thus accelerating the conformational change of EmrE to export the substrate.

Elucidating allosteric communication in the human serotonin transporter

The human serotonin transporter (hSERT) is a membrane protein that mediates the re-uptake of serotonin from the synaptic cleft into presynaptic neurons. Dysregulation in the SERT transport cycle has been associated with numerous neuropsychiatric disorders, highlighting the crucial role of the transporter in maintaining the brain neurotransmitter levels homeostasis. From a mechanistic point of view, the transport cycle can be described by the alternating-access model, in which structural rearrangements in the protein domains result in the alternated exposure of substrates to the extracellular or intracellular environment.

Crystal structure of CmABCB1 multi-drug exporter in lipidic mesophase revealed by LCP-SFX.

CmABCB1 is a Cyanidioschyzon merolae homolog of human ABCB1, a well known ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporter responsible for multi-drug resistance in various cancers. Three-dimensional structures of ABCB1 homologs have revealed the snapshots of inward- and outward-facing states of the transporters in action. However, sufficient information to establish the sequential movements of the open-close cycles of the alternating-access model is still lacking. Serial femtosecond crystallography (SFX) using X-ray free-electron lasers has proven its worth in determining novel structures and recording sequential conformational changes of proteins at room temperature, especially for medically important membrane proteins, but it has never been applied to ABC transporters. In this study, 7.7 mono-acyl-glycerol with cholesterol as the host lipid was used and obtained well diffracting microcrystals of the 130 kDa CmABCB1 dimer. Successful SFX experiments were performed by adjusting the viscosity of the crystal suspension of the sponge phase with hy-droxy-propyl methyl-cellulose and using the high-viscosity sample injector for data collection at the SACLA beamline. An outward-facing structure of CmABCB1 at a maximum resolution of 2.22 Å is reported, determined by SFX experiments with crystals formed in the lipidic cubic phase (LCP-SFX), which has never been applied to ABC transporters. In the type I crystal, CmABCB1 dimers interact with adjacent molecules via not only the nucleotide-binding domains but also the transmembrane domains (TMDs); such an interaction was not observed in the previous type II crystal. Although most parts of the structure are similar to those in the previous type II structure, the substrate-exit region of the TMD adopts a different configuration in the type I structure. This difference between the two types of structures reflects the flexibility of the substrate-exit region of CmABCB1, which might be essential for the smooth release of various substrates from the transporter.

Structures and General Transport Mechanisms by the Major Facilitator Superfamily (MFS).

The major facilitator superfamily (MFS) is the largest known superfamily of secondary active transporters. MFS transporters are responsible for transporting a broad spectrum of substrates, either down their concentration gradient or uphill using the energy stored in the electrochemical gradients. Over the last 10 years, more than a hundred different MFS transporter structures covering close to 40 members have provided an atomic framework for piecing together the molecular basis of their transport cycles. Here, we summarize the remarkable promiscuity of MFS members in terms of substrate recognition and proton coupling as well as the intricate gating mechanisms undergone in achieving substrate translocation. We outline studies that show how residues far from the substrate binding site can be just as important for fine-tuning substrate recognition and specificity as those residues directly coordinating the substrate, and how a number of MFS transporters have evolved to form unique complexes with chaperone and signaling functions. Through a deeper mechanistic description of glucose (GLUT) transporters and multidrug resistance (MDR) antiporters, we outline novel refinements to the rocker-switch alternating-access model, such as a latch mechanism for proton-coupled monosaccharide transport. We emphasize that a full understanding of transport requires an elucidation of MFS transporter dynamics, energy landscapes, and the determination of how rate transitions are modulated by lipids.

The Transport Cycle of a Sodium/Proton Antiporter

Sodium/proton antiporters, also known as sodium/proton exchangers, are essential secondary active transporters that are involved in pH homeostasis and regulation of sodium concentration and cell volume. They belong to the monovalent cation/proton antiporter families (CPA1 and CPA2) which all appear to share a common fold, spanning prokaryotic to mammalian family members. They obey general principles of secondary active transporters, namely they switch between at least two conformations in accordance with the alternating access model, the major states (outward facing (OF) and inward facing (OF)) are rooted in structurally breaking an inverted repeat symmetry, and they transduce energy from a driving ion gradient to vectorial substrate transport through conformational cycles. However, these broad principles constrain but do not immediately provide insights into the molecular mechanism of sodium/proton antiport. We have been using molecular dynamics simulations (long equilibrium MD, free energy calculations, enhanced sampling for rare events, constant pH simulations) in combination with experimental techniques such as X-ray crystallography and functional measurements to investigate key steps in the transport cycle of the prokaryotic CPA2 transporter TtNapA. A competitive binding mechanism between protons and sodium emerges from an analysis of the thermodynamics of the OF and IF states and naturally explains the experimentally observed activity peak in a narrow pH range. Direct computational sampling of the conformational transitions shows that NapA can undergo fast (sub-microsecond) conformational changes in either the proton or sodium-loaded states and reveals a distinct meta-stable intermediate state. Taken together, the information from all the major steps in the complete transport cycle can then form the basis for multi-scale kinetic models of the physiological function of the antiporter.

Substrate binding in the bile acid transporter ASBTYf from Yersinia frederiksenii.

Apical sodium-dependent bile acid transporter (ASBT) retrieves bile acids from the small intestine and plays a pivotal role in enterohepatic circulation. Currently, high-resolution structures are available for two bacterial ASBT homologs (ASBTNM from Neisseria meningitides and ASBTYf from Yersinia frederiksenii), from which an elevator-style alternating-access mechanism has been proposed for substrate transport. A key concept in this model is that the substrate binds to the central cavity of the transporter so that the elevator-like motion can expose the bound substrate alternatingly to either side of the membrane during a transport cycle. However, no structure of an ASBT has been solved with a substrate bound in its central cavity, so how a substrate binds toASBT remains to be defined. In this study, molecular docking, structure determination and functional analysis were combined to define and validate the details of substrate binding in ASBTYf. The findings provide coherent evidence to provide a clearer picture of how the substrate binds in the central cavity of ASBTYf that fits the alternating-access model.

An engineered disulfide bridge traps and validates an outward-facing conformation in a bile acid transporter.

Apical sodium-dependent bile acid transporter (ASBT) mediates the uptake of bile acids from the ileum lumen into enterocytes and presents a potential target for the treatment of several metabolic diseases, including type 2 diabetes. It has been proposed that the underlying mechanism for transport by ASBT is an elevator-style alternating-access model, which was deduced mainly by comparing high-resolution structures of two bacterial ASBT homologs (ASBTNM from Neisseria meningitides and ASBTYf from Yersinia frederiksenii) in different conformations. However, one important issue is that the only outward-facing structure (PDB entry 4n7x) was obtained with an Na+-binding site mutant of ASBTYf, which severely cripples its transport function, and therefore the physiological relevance of the conformation in PDB entry 4n7x requires further careful evaluation. Here, another crystal structure is reported of ASBTYf that was captured in a state closely resembling the conformation in PDB entry 4n7x using an engineered disulfide bridge. The introduced cysteine mutations avoided any proposed Na+- or substrate-binding residues, and the resulting mutant retained both structural and functional integrity and behaved similarly to wild-type ASBTYf. These data support the hypothesis that the PDB entry 4n7x-like structure represents a functional outward-facing conformation of ASBTYf in its transport cycle.

Visualizing the nonlinear changes of a drug-proton antiporter from inward-open to occluded state

Drug-proton antiporters (DHA) play an important role in multi-drug resistance, utilizing the proton-motive force to drive the expulsion of toxic molecules, including antibiotics and drugs. DHA transporters belong to the major facilitator superfamily (MFS), members of which deliver substrates by utilizing the alternating access model of transport. However, the transport process is still elusive. Here, we report the structures of SotB, a member of DHA1 family (TCDB: 2.A.1.2) from Escherichia coli. Four crystal structures of SotB were captured in different conformations, including substrate-bound occluded, inward-facing, and inward-open states. Comparisons between the four structures reveal nonlinear rigid-body movements of alternating access during the state transition from inward-open to occluded conformation. This work not only reveals the conformational dynamics of SotB but also deepens our understanding of the alternating access mechanism of MFS transporters.

Transmembrane helix 6b links proton and metal release pathways and drives conformational change in an Nramp-family transition metal transporter

Transmembrane helix 6b links proton and metal release pathways and drives conformational change in an Nramp-family transition metal transporter

Locking Two Rigid-body Bundles in an Outward-Facing Conformation: The Ion-coupling Mechanism in a LeuT-fold Transporter

Secondary active transporters use electrochemical gradient of ions to fuel the “uphill” translocation of the substrate following the alternating-access model. The coupling of ions to conformational dynamics of the protein remains one of the least characterized aspects of the transporter function. We employ extended molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to examine the Na+-binding effects on the structure and dynamics of a LeuT-fold, Na+-coupled secondary transporter (Mhp1) in its major conformational states, i.e., the outward-facing (OF) and inward-facing (IF) states, as well as on the OF ↔ IF state transition. Microsecond-long, unbiased MD simulations illustrate that Na+ stabilizes an OF conformation favorable for substrate association, by binding to a highly conserved site at the interface between the two helical bundles and restraining their relative position and motion. Furthermore, a special-protocol biased simulation for state transition suggests that Na+ binding hinders the OF ↔ IF transition. These synergistic Na+-binding effects allosterically couple the ion and substrate binding sites and modify the kinetics of state transition, collectively increasing the lifetime of an OF conformation with high substrate affinity, thereby facilitating substrate recruitment from a low-concentration environment. Based on the similarity between our findings for Mhp1 and experimental reports on LeuT, we propose that this model may represent a general Na+-coupling mechanism among LeuT-fold transporters.

Kinetic Models of Secondary Active Transporters.

Kinetic models have been employed to understand the logic of substrate transport through transporters of the Solute Carrier (SLC) family. All SLC transporters operate according to the alternate access model, which posits that substrate transport occurs in a closed loop of partial reactions (i.e., a transport cycle). Kinetic models can help to find realistic estimates for conformational transitions between individual states of the transport cycle. When constrained by experimental results, kinetic models can faithfully describe the function of a candidate transporter at a pre-steady state. In addition, we show that kinetic models can accurately predict the intra- and extracellular substrate concentrations maintained by the transporter at a steady state, even under the premise of loose coupling between the electrochemical gradient of the driving ion and of the substrate. We define the criteria for the design of a credible kinetic model of the SLC transporter. Parsimony is the guiding principle of kinetic modeling. We argue, however, that the level of acceptable parsimony is limited by the need to account for the substrate gradient established by a secondary active transporter, and for random order binding of co-substrates and substrate. Random order binding has consistently been observed in transporters of the SLC group.