Allele-specific Loss Of Heterozygosity Research Articles

Correlation of allele-specific HLA loss of heterozygosity in patients with cancer with driver mutations.

e14658 Background: While immunotherapies have revolutionized cancer treatment, the limited predictability of response and resistance mechanisms present challenges to the development of novel therapeutics for solid tumors. Many of these use a sensitive and specific T cell receptor (TCR)-HLA:peptide interaction as a mechanism of action and can be impacted by HLA loss of heterozygosity (LOH). Allele-agnostic HLA LOH analyses assessing loss of any MHC class I allele are relevant for HLA-agnostic approaches such as immune checkpoint inhibitors; however, context-specific studies remain limited. For example, adoptive TCR T cell therapies and bi-specific TCR T cell engagers target neoantigen peptides derived from oncogenic driver mutations, such as those of KRAS and TP53, presented by a specific HLA allele. Thus, allele-agnostic analyses may overestimate the frequency and relevance of HLA LOH for allele-specific modalities. Methods: A real-world comprehensive genomic profiling dataset consisting of 78,418 cases (1), germline heterozygous for one or more HLA class I locus, was analyzed for HLA LOH in the context of frequent driver mutations (KRAS G12C, G12D, G12V and TP53 R175H), the corresponding HLA alleles (A*02:01, A*03:01, and A*11:01), and within tumor subtypes. Results: Allele-agnostic HLA LOH was observed in 16.6% of all samples and varied between indications. Notably, allele-specific loss of HLAs A*02:01, A*03:01, and A*11:01 across all samples was much lower than allele-agnostic loss (6.3%, 6.6%, and 6.3% cases, respectively). Although, a trend for increased allele-specific HLA LOH was observed when analyzed by driver mutation, the frequency remained low. Specifically, across all cases, A*02:01, A*03:01, and A*11:01 allele-specific LOH ranged between 5.9% - 9.7% in relation to KRAS G12C, G12D, and G12V compared to 5.9% - 6.2% for wild-type (WT). Moreover, it did not achieve statistical significance for any HLA-KRAS mutation pairs in colorectal (CRC), non-small cell lung (NSCLC), and pancreatic (PDAC) cancers, except for A*11:01 and KRAS G12C in NSCLC, which was lower in mutated cases (5.3% for G12C vs 10.1% for WT KRAS, p=0.045). Both allele-agnostic and A*02:01-specific HLA LOH in TP53 WT samples were lower than average. The TP53 R175H mutation was associated with limited increase in HLA-A*02:01 LOH (from 4.4% for WT to 8.1% for TP53 R175H) and varied between indications, e.g. no significant increase was observed in R175H-positive breast cancer and NSCLC cases contrary to CRC and PDAC. Conclusions: Based on this real-world dataset, over 90% of cases retain the TCR-targeted allele and, therefore, preserve the molecular complex necessary for HLA/driver mutation-based therapies. Notably, the database is enriched for advanced cancer patients. Further studies should test correlations with treatments and whether tumors in earlier lines of treatment have an even lower rate of HLA LOH. 1. Montesion et al., PMID: 33127846.

Robust prediction of response to immunotherapy in a mixed cohort of previously treated and immunotherapy-naive melanoma patients.

e21548 Background: While immune checkpoint blockade (ICB) has become a pillar of cancer treatment, biomarkers that consistently predict patient response remain elusive due to the complex mechanisms driving immune response to tumors. We hypothesized that a multi-dimensional approach modeling both tumor and immune-related molecular mechanisms would better predict ICB response than simpler mutation-focused biomarkers. Methods: Pre-treatment samples from 51 unresectable, stage III/IV melanoma patients who underwent anti-PD-1 therapy were characterized to assess factors influencing response. RECIST criteria were used to evaluate tumor response to therapy, with a median follow-up of 24 months. For each patient, a single paired FFPE tumor and normal blood sample was collected and profiled using Personalis’ ImmunoID NeXT Platform; an augmented exome/transcriptome platform and analysis pipeline which produces comprehensive tumor mutation information, gene expression profiling, neoantigen characterization, HLA typing and LOH, TCR repertoire profiling, and tumor microenvironment profiling. These data were then integrated to form a composite neoantigen presentation score (NEOPS) for each patient. Results: We demonstrate increasing predictive power with deeper modeling of neoantigens and immune-related resistance mechanisms to ICB. Neoantigen burden score (NBS) was derived from SHERPA, our exome and transcriptome integrative neoantigen prediction model. We found that NBS more significantly stratified responders and non-responders (P = 0.016) than TMB alone (P = 0.049). A broader score, NEOPS, incorporated DASH, to capture HLA allele-specific loss of heterozygosity and additional antigen presenting machinery resistance mechanisms. NEOPS consequently demonstrated a stronger association with response (p = 0.002). We used area under the curve (AUC) to benchmark NEOPS performance against established mutational and transcriptomic predictive models, demonstrating the model was more predictive of response in both the treatment naive setting, as well as in a mixed cohort of treatment-naive and experienced patients. These findings were confirmed in an independent cohort of patients (n = 110), suggesting that NEOPS is a robust, novel biomarker of ICB response in melanoma. Conclusions: Given the complex nature of resistance to immunotherapy, as well as potential toxicities associated with treatment, there is a need for biomarkers that can more accurately predict response. Here we demonstrate that NEOPS can significantly improve stratification of patient response. We also demonstrate that data intensive biomarkers like NEOPS can be clinically practical, with comprehensive tumor profiling in our clinical cohort achieved using very limited tumor tissue.

Abstract 3769: Detection of allele specific loss of heterozygosity in 70,000 patients with ctDNA

Abstract Background: Loss of Heterozygosity (LoH) is a common feature of tumor biology. LoH frequently arises from defects in Homologous Recombination Repair (HRR) and results in uni-parental deletions that manifest as (LoH). In the absence of a driving force, the likelihood of allelic loss is equal, so in a population, the rate of retention and loss of a given allele is equal, but allele specific loss (or retention) is known to occur. Methods: Using a novel analysis method incorporating observed allele frequency and copy number variation, we investigated the Guardant Health database of variants detected from 70,000+ samples from whole blood samples from patients with advanced solid tumors that were tested using a 73-gene cell-free DNA next-generation sequencing panel (Guardant360, Guardant Health, Redwood City, CA) to identify allele specific loss. Results: Analysis of the Guardant Health database revealed that LoH frequently manifests as allele imbalance with the observed mutation allele frequency (MAF) of the retained allele exceeding an observed allele frequency of 50% and the lost allele having observed mutation allele frequencies below 50% in an individual sample. This imbalance occurs because allele frequency is a relative measurement and loss of one allele causes the relative abundance of the remaining allele to increase in a proportional amount. Population analysis reveals that the majority of of alleles are lost without preference, but certain alleles may be more prone to retention or loss. Conclusions: The detection of allele specific loss from ctDNA provides insight into the underlying tumor biology and the selective pressures shaping tumor evolution over the course of treatment. Note: This abstract was not presented at the meeting. Citation Format: Jing Zhao, Stephen R. Fairclough, Darya Chudova, Richard Lanman, AmirAli Talasaz, Aaron Hardin. Detection of allele specific loss of heterozygosity in 70,000 patients with ctDNA [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 3769.

Abstract A22: Homologous recombination deficiency negatively predicts for immune infiltration and antitumor immune activity in breast tumors with BRCA1/2 alterations

Abstract Tumors with germline or somatic BRCA1 or BRCA2 alterations are sensitive to DNA-damaging agents but often develop therapeutic resistance. Breast cancers associated with BRCA1/2 alterations have a relatively high mutational load, defined as the number of nonsynonymous single nucleotide mutations, relative to BRCA1/2 wild-type tumors, leading to suggestions that patients with BRCA1/2 mutations are possible candidates for immune checkpoint blockade. However, immune infiltration can range widely in tumors with BRCA1/2 alterations, and molecular determinants that account for this variability remain unclear. Our goal was to delineate the molecular features associated with immunogenicity in breast cancers associated with germline or somatic BRCA1/2 alterations through genetic/genomic and histopathologic analyses in 115 tumors from the TCGA (n=89) and Penn (n=26). In the TCGA dataset, we found that the level of homologous recombination deficiency (HRD), as measured by the copy number-based HRD score (high vs. low, dichotomized by median), correlated positively with neoantigen load in BRCA1/2 tumors (p=0.02), but unexpectedly inversely with immunogenicity as measured by cytolytic index (p=0.04) (geometric mean of PRF1 and GZMA expression) and immune ESTIMATE (p=0.002), an RNA-seq-based measure of immune cell infiltration. In prior studies, we had found that a surprisingly high percentage of BRCA1 and BRCA2 germline mutation-associated breast cancers lacked allele-specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH), 10% and 46%, respectively. We thus evaluated whether allele-specific LOH of germline BRCA2 mutations and somatic BRCA1/2 mutation clonality were drivers of the negative association between HRD level and cytolytic index/immune ESTIMATE. We found that allele-specific LOH was associated with higher HRD score (p=0.015) but lower enrichment of the Type II IFN signaling immune metagene (p=0.01), lower cytolytic index (p=0.04), and lower immune ESTIMATE score (p=0.01); tumors with clonal somatic BRCA1/2 mutations had significantly higher HRD score (p=2.4E-07) and mutational burden (p=0.05) but lower cytolytic index (p=0.003) and immune ESTIMATE scores (p=5E-05) than tumors with subclonal somatic BRCA1/2 mutations. Stratifying by both hormone receptor expression and median HRD score, we found that triple-negative breast cancers with low HRD were the most immunogenic and hormone receptor-positive tumors with high HRD the least (p=0.001). We confirmed these TCGA findings by histopathology in tumors associated with germline mutations in BRCA1/2 from Penn. We found that CD45+ leukocyte (p=0.03) and CD8+ cytotoxic T-cell infiltration (p=0.03) as well as expression of the immune effector PRF1 (p=0.048) were significantly lower with high HRD. Further, tumors with allele-specific LOH of the germline BRCA1/2 mutation had significantly lower PRF1 staining (p=0.004), lower membrane levels of the immune checkpoint protein PDL1 (p=0.05), and lower CD8+ (p=0.001), FoxP3+ (p=0.03), and CD20+ (p=0.04) immune cells, suggesting an immunosuppressive role for allele-specific LOH leading to high HRD. These data are consistent with a prior pan-TCGA analysis demonstrating that increased tumor chromosome/arm level copy number alterations suppress immunogenicity. We have found, for the first time, that genomic instability in BRCA1/2 tumors is associated with lower antitumor immune activity, and that the immunogenicity of BRCA1/2 mutation-associated breast cancers is directly related to their HRD level (driven by allele-specific LOH and clonality) and receptor status, both clinically evaluable biomarkers. These findings have immediate implications for the stratification of patients with BRCA1/2 mutation-associated breast cancer for checkpoint blockade therapy. Citation Format: Adam A. Kraya, Kara N. Maxwell, Bradley Wubbenhorst, Brandon M. Wenz, John Pluta, Andrew J. Rech, Nicole Lunceford, Amanda Barrett, Nandita Mitra, Jennifer J.D. Morrissette, Anupma Nayak, Michael Feldman, Susan M. Domchek, Robert H. Vonderheide, Katherine L. Nathanson. Homologous recombination deficiency negatively predicts for immune infiltration and antitumor immune activity in breast tumors with BRCA1/2 alterations [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference: Advances in Breast Cancer Research; 2017 Oct 7-10; Hollywood, CA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Mol Cancer Res 2018;16(8_Suppl):Abstract nr A22.

Common alleles in candidate susceptibility genes associated with risk and development of epithelial ovarian cancer.

Common germline genetic variation in the population is associated with susceptibility to epithelial ovarian cancer. Microcell-mediated chromosome transfer and expression microarray analysis identified nine genes associated with functional suppression of tumorogenicity in ovarian cancer cell lines; AIFM2, AKTIP, AXIN2, CASP5, FILIP1L, RBBP8, RGC32, RUVBL1 and STAG3. Sixty-three tagging single nucleotide polymorphisms (tSNPs) in these genes were genotyped in 1,799 invasive ovarian cancer cases and 3,045 controls to look for associations with disease risk. Two SNPs in RUVBL1, rs13063604 and rs7650365, were associated with increased risk of serous ovarian cancer [HetOR = 1.42 (1.15-1.74) and the HomOR = 1.63 (1.10-1.42), p-trend = 0.0002] and [HetOR = 0.97 (0.80-1.17), HomOR = 0.74 (0.58-0.93), p-trend = 0.009], respectively. We genotyped rs13063604 and rs7650365 in an additional 4,590 cases and 6,031 controls from ten sites from the United States, Europe and Australia; however, neither SNP was significant in Stage 2. We also evaluated the potential role of tSNPs in these nine genes in ovarian cancer development by testing for allele-specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in 286 primary ovarian tumours. We found frequent LOH for tSNPs in AXIN2, AKTIP and RGC32 (64, 46 and 34%, respectively) and one SNP, rs1637001, in STAG3 showed significant allele-specific LOH with loss of the common allele in 94% of informative tumours (p = 0.015). Array comparative genomic hybridisation indicated that this nonrandom allelic imbalance was due to amplification of the rare allele. In conclusion, we show evidence for the involvement of a common allele of STAG3 in the development of epithelial ovarian cancer.

Biological significance of allele specific loss of the p53 gene in breast carcinomas.

Abstract Abstract #4064 Background: The p53 tumour suppressor gene has a central role in the defence against cancer, including breast cancer, and contains a polymorphic variant (Arg/Pro) at codon 72 that has been shown to have different biological properties regarding apoptosis and cell cycle arrest. Earlier studies have shown allele specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at this particular site and we aimed to investigate its biological relevance in codon 72 heterozygous breast cancer patients (i.e. survival and age of disease onset).
 Method: 199 postmenopausal cases were analyzed for LOH using MegaBACE1000 and statistics was performed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences. As reference for loss/retention of heterozygosity at the Arg or Pro allele DNA from 30 heterozygous blood donors included in a population based DNA bank was used.
 Results: LOH was found in totally 124 (62.3%) patients and the Pro allele (n = 103) was significantly more often deleted compared to the Arg allele (n = 21) (p = 0.001). Patients with LOH of the Arg allele were diagnosed at an earlier age (mean age 62.5 years) than those with loss of the Pro allele (mean age 69.2 years) (p = 0.011). LOH of the Arg allele was also associated with worse survival (p = 0.05). Tumour size or number of positive lymph nodes was not associated with LOH.
 Conclusion: We found a non-random loss of the codon 72 Pro allele, implying the existence of a selective pressure during carcinogenesis that confers a growth advantage to cells lacking the Pro allele. We also found that earlier age of onset was associated with loss of the Arg allele. These results were achieved from primary tumors without any influence of adjuvant treatment, possibly showing a picture of the natural history of carcinogenesis. The worsen prognosis associated with loss of the Arg allele is somewhat more complex to interpret since recurrence free survival could be influenced by genotype, mutational status and adjuvant treatment. Citation Information: Cancer Res 2009;69(2 Suppl):Abstract nr 4064.

Biological significance of allele specific loss of the p53 gene in breast carcinomas

The p53 tumor suppressor gene has a central role in the defense against cancer, including breast cancer, and contains a polymorphic variant (Arg/Pro) at codon 72 that has been shown to have different biological properties regarding apoptosis and cell cycle arrest. Earlier studies have shown allele specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at this particular site and we aimed to investigate its biological relevance in codon 72 heterozygous breast cancer patients (i.e., survival and age of disease onset). 199 postmenopausal cases were analyzed for LOH using MegaBACE(1000) and statistics was performed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences. LOH was found in totally 124 (62.3%) patients and the Pro allele (n = 103) was significantly more often deleted compared to the Arg allele (n = 21) (P = 0.001). Patients with LOH of the Arg allele were diagnosed at an earlier age (mean age 62.5 years) than those with loss of the Pro allele (mean age 69.2 years) (P = 0.011). LOH of the Arg allele was also associated with worse survival (P = 0.05). LOH in comparison to ROH correlated significantly with increased S-phase fraction. Tumor size, stage or number of positive lymph nodes was not related to LOH. Our results and earlier findings suggest a selective loss of the Pro allele during carcinogenesis that might confer a growth advantage for cancer cells. On the other hand, it appears to be more harmful for patients to loose the Arg allele since we found that loss of this allele was associated with earlier onset and worse prognosis.

Allele-specific loss of heterozygosity in multiple colorectal adenomas: toward an integrated molecular cytogenetic map II

Colorectal cancer (CRC) remains a significant public health challenge despite our increased understanding of the genetic defects underlying the pathogenesis of this common disease. It has been thought that multiple mechanisms lead to the malignant phenotype, with familial predisposition syndromes accounting for only a small proportion of all CRC cases. To identify additional loci likely involved in CRC and to test the hypothesis of allele-specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) for the localization of CRC susceptibility genes, we initially conducted a genome-wide allelotyping analysis of 48 adenomas from a patient with familial adenomatous polyposis coli (FAP) and 63 adenomas from 7 patients with sporadic CRC using 79 fluorescently tagged oligonucleotide primers amplifying microsatellite loci covering the human genome. Frequent allelic losses were identified at D17S802 (41%), D7S518 (40%), D18S53 (38%), D10S249 (32%), D2S391 (29%), D16S419 (27%), D15S1005 and D15S120 (24%), D9S274 and D11S1318 (23%), D14S65 (20%), D14S274 and D17S953 (19%), D19S424 (18%), D5S346 and D1S397 (15%), and D6S468 (13%) in multiple FAP adenomas. Common LOH was also detected at D4S1584 (42%), D11S968 (31%), D17S953 (28%), D5S394, D9S286 and D10S249 (24%), D8S511 (23%), D13S158 (21%), D7S669 (20%), D18S58 (19%), D2S162 and D16S432 (16%), D2S206 (15%), D7S496 and D17S946 (14%), D6S292 (13%), D4S1586 and D8S283 (11%), and D1S2766 (10%) in multiple CRC adenomas. In addition, allele-specific LOH at D5S346, D15S1005, and D15S120 was observed in multiple FAP adenomas ( P < 0.01) and at D2S206 and D16S423 in multiple CRC ( P < 0.05). To compare our data to previous reports, we determined the band-specific frequency of chromosomal imbalances in CRC karyotypes reported in the Mitelman database, and from the CGH results of cases accessible through the PROGENETIX website. Furthermore, published genome-wide allelotyping analysis of CRC and other allele-specific LOH studies were compiled and collated with our LOH data. The combined results not only provide a comprehensive view of genetic losses in CRC, indicating the comparability of these different techniques, but they also reveal different novel loci in multiple adenomas from FAP and sporadic CRC patients, suggesting that they represent a distinct subtype of CRC in terms of allelic losses. Allele-specific LOH is an alternative approach for cancer gene mapping.

Novel Pheochromocytoma Susceptibility Loci Identified by Integrative Genomics

Pheochromocytomas are catecholamine-secreting tumors that result from mutations of at least six different genes as components of distinct autosomal dominant disorders. However, there remain familial occurrences of pheochromocytoma without a known genetic defect. We describe here a familial pheochromocytoma syndrome consistent with digenic inheritance identified through a combination of global genomics strategies. Multipoint parametric linkage analysis revealed identical LOD scores of 2.97 for chromosome 2cen and 16p13 loci. A two-locus parametric linkage analysis produced maximum LOD score of 5.16 under a double recessive multiplicative model, suggesting that both loci are required to develop the disease. Allele-specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) was detected only at the chromosome 2 locus in all tumors from this family, consistent with a tumor suppressor gene. Four additional pheochromocytomas with a similar genetic pattern were identified through transcription profiling and helped refine the chromosome 2 locus. High-density LOH mapping with single nucleotide polymorphism-based array identified a total of 18 of 62 pheochromocytomas with LOH within the chromosome 2 region, which further narrowed down the locus to <2 cM. This finding provides evidence for two novel susceptibility loci for pheochromocytoma and adds a recessive digenic trait to the increasingly broad genetic heterogeneity of these tumors. Similarly, complex traits may also be involved in other familial cancer syndromes.

Mass Spectrometry-Based Loss of Heterozygosity Analysis of Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism Loci in Paraffin Embedded Tumors Using the MassEXTEND Assay: Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism Loss of Heterozygosity Analysis of the Protein Tyrosine Phosphatase Receptor Type J in Familial Colorectal Cancer

As the number of identified single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) increases, high-throughput methods are required to characterize the informative loci in large patient series. We investigated the feasibility of MassEXTEND LOH analysis using Sequenom's MassArray RT software, a mass spectrometry method, as an alternative to determine loss of heterozygosity (LOH). For this purpose, we studied the c.827A>C SNP (1176A>C p.Gln276Pro) in protein tyrosine phosphatase receptor type-J (PTPRJ), which is frequently deleted in human cancers. In sporadic colorectal cancer (CRC), c.827A>C showed allele-specific LOH of the c.827A allele, which is important because LOH of PTPRJ may be an early event during sporadic CRC. To elucidate the impact of this low-penetrance gene on familial CRC, we studied c.827A>C in 222 familial CRC cases and 156 controls. In 6.2% of the A/C genotyped CRC samples, LOH of c.827A was observed with MassEXTEND LOH analysis and confirmed by conventional sequencing. Furthermore, a case with LOH of c.827A showed no LOH in 22 synchronously detected adenomas, including one with malignant transformation. The importance of the PTPRJ- c.827A>C SNP appears to be limited in familial CRC. We conclude that MassEXTEND LOH analysis (using Sequenom's MassARRAY RT software) is a sensitive, high-throughput, and cost-effective method to screen SNP loci for LOH in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue.

Allelic imbalance in colorectal cancer at the CRAC1 locus in early-onset colorectal cancer

A susceptibility gene to colorectal adenomas and carcinoma ( CRAC1) on chromosome region 15q14∼q22 has been proposed on the basis of linkage in a single family. Allele-specific loss of heterozygosity (LOH) in tumors of affected family members suggests that the causative gene functions as a tumor-suppressor gene. The genes that are mutated in inherited cancer syndromes are often involved in the pathogenesis of sporadic cancer. To determine whether CRAC1 plays a role in colorectal carcinogenesis in general, we have studied 277 cases of early-onset colorectal cancers for allele loss at 15q14∼q22 using four microsatellite markers (D15S970, D15S117, D15S971, and D15S1028) that define the region of maximal linkage. The frequency of LOH detected was between 14% and 22%, but there was no significant association between LOH at each adjacent marker. Most cancers caused by loss of expression of a tumor suppressor involve large-scale deletion of one allele. On this basis, our findings suggest that CRAC1 is unlikely to be implicated in the development of colorectal cancer in general or, if involved, it is through small somatic mutations or other loss of function mechanisms rather than allele loss.

Allelotype of Uterine Leiomyomas

Uterine leiomyomas are the most common benign tumor that arise from smooth muscle cells of the myometrium. Little is known about the etiology and pathogenesis of this tumor. To investigate the molecular pathogenesis of these tumors, we have conducted an allelotype of 102 leiomyomas from 12 patients, using 67 fluorescently-tagged oligonucleotide primers amplifying microsatellite loci covering all autosomes. No areas of the genome showed frequent loss of heterozygosity (LOH); however, the highest rate of LOH (9%) was observed on 7q, consistent with previous cytogenetic observations. Uterine leiomyomas are sometimes multiple. In general, multiplicity of other types of neoplasm is associated with genetic predisposition to the disease. Because multiple tumors were available from each of the 12 patients studied, we looked for evidence of allele-specific LOH, which might indicate the presence of an underlying predisposition gene. However, no evidence for allele-specific LOH was detected, indicating that if cases of multiple uterine leiomyoma are due to an underlying predisposition gene, it is unlikely to be a recessive oncogene.