Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the zwitterionic surfactant octyl phosphocholine (OPC) in water have been performed with two force fields, both using the TraPPE united-atom alkane parameters for tailgroup-tailgroup interactions but with tailgroup-water interactions adjusted to reproduce hydration free energies for two different water models (SPC and TIP4P-2005). Micelle size distributions from a number of trajectories were analyzed using the PEACH (Partition-Enabled Analysis of Cluster Histograms) method to yield free energies of aggregation for premicelles and micelles over the full range from 2 to over 40 molecules. The dependence of free energy on aggregation number was consistent with the functional form derived from the “quasi-droplet” model of micellization. Free energies of aggregation were used to calculate concentration-dependent micelle size distributions, from which critical micelle concentrations (cmc's) could be inferred. The cmc values derived from PEACH free energies for the SPC and TIP4P-2005 models were 40% and 27% higher respectively than the experimentally reported value of 114 mM. In systems with enough monomers to form multiple micelles, the micelles tended to stick together, complicating the analysis. Micelle size distributions were used to weight small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) form factors derived from micelle structures, generating a composite form factor reflecting the polydispersity of aggregate sizes with contributions in the range from 20 to 45 monomers. The composite scattering profile was quite similar to that of the mass-weighted average micelle size, suggesting that SAXS profiles for small micelles can be adequately fit using a single typical micelle even in the presence of significant polydispersity.
Read full abstract