Reviewed by: Where Slavery Died Hard: The Forgotten History of Ulster County and the Shawangunk Mountain Region Oscar Williams (bio) Where Slavery Died Hard: The Forgotten History of Ulster County and the Shawangunk Mountain Region By Cragsmoor Historical Society, 2018. 54 minutes running time. Wendy Harris and Arnold Pickman, writer/directors; Walter Alvarez, producer; Maureen Radl, associate producer In recent years, historians, archeologists, and other scholars have begun to examine the extent of American slavery in the North. Once believed to be exclusively a Southern institution, new scholarship has revealed that it was prevalent in the Northeast from the early seventeenth through early nineteenth centuries. In New York, the Hudson Valley served as the epicenter, as estates and manors from New York City to Albany relied heavily on enslaved African labor to raise livestock, till fields, serve as domestics, clear land, run mills, construct buildings, and tend to the needs and demands of the slaveholding family. Among the scholarship is a fifty-four-minute documentary produced by the Cragsmoor Historical Society. Titled Where Slavery Died Hard: The Forgotten History of Ulster County and the Shawangunk Mountain Region, the film is based on a scholarly article published in 2016 by archeologists Wendy E. Harris and Arnold Pickman. Using primary documents such as letters, wills, maps, manuscripts, contemporary accounts, census records, and newspapers, the film reveals the nature of slavery in Ulster County and how the enslaved were treated. The documentary's goal is to provide a detailed view of slavery by examining the lives of the enslaved. This is achieved by following author A. J. Williams's assertion in his 1994 book, Long Hammering: Essays on the Forging of an African American Presence in the Hudson River Valley, that the enslaved were highly skilled individuals who played a pivotal role in adding to the history and culture of the region. Abundant detail is provided throughout the documentary that reveals a life of difficulty for the enslaved. The most vivid account is the recollections of legendary abolitionist Sojourner Truth, who was enslaved in Ulster County in the 1790s. Sold as a child several times, she bore five children during her enslavement, one of whom was separated from her via sale and sent to Alabama, commenting [End Page 446] that the institution robbed her of children.1 Wills also revealed the vulnerability of slave families, as demonstrated by the Jansen family in 1798 and 1802, when several family members received enslaved individuals as an inheritance, including children.2 The documentary reveals that enslaved Africans strove to have a life for themselves when given the opportunity. One example is the story of two enslaved individuals who belonged to the DeWitt family. Caesar and Jane DeWitt, when freed in the 1820s, lived nearby their former slave home on a three-acre patch of land they purchased from the DeWitt family and continued to work for them. When the patriarch, John DeWitt, passed in 1845, the family were given ten acres of land and $9,000 due to Jane's devotion to care for his son, who passed at the age of nineteen.3 As with other slave societies, the threat of violence was always present in Ulster County. In 1741, the same year of the New York Slave Conspiracy, a New York City newspaper reported that an enslaved boy, fifteen or sixteen years of age, set fire to hay barracks, resulting in the destruction of the farm and the harvest. As punishment, he was executed. Another newspaper account from 1775 highlights a group of enslaved males who, to attain their freedom, planned to set fire to homes and kill people when they fled. The plan was discovered, and the men were killed.4 Labor of the enslaved is highlighted in the film as a crucial component of Ulster County, particularly in the case of a Dutch Reformed Church of Warwarsing, where an enslaved man by the name of Jet contributed three shillings to the construction of the church. It is believed that he was able to do so because of earnings as a skilled worker. It is also asserted that despite lack of evidence, enslaved Africans were employed at grist mills and used their skills...
Read full abstract