Aerosol Exposure Assessment Research Articles

115 Laboratory Performances of the CIP 10 Personal Aerosol Sampler for the Collection of Submicron Particles

Abstract The CIP 10 is a personal aerosol sampler designed to sample conventional dust or specific occupational inorganic or organic substances such as crystalline silica, isocyanates or mycotoxins. It is widespread used, especially in France. Within the CIP10, the rotating cup contains a porous polyurethane foam devoted to the collection of airborne particles and rotates inside its housing at a speed close to 6700 rpm to induce a 7 or 10 L/min sampling airflow, depending on the particle-size selector. Despite several published works regarding its physical performances, no experimental data exist regarding the sampling efficiency for submicron particles. This study aimed to measure the collection efficiency of the CIP 10 for different types of foam (60 or 75 ppi, functionalized or not) and for the three selectors (inhalable, thoracic, respirable). Polydisperse particles with aerodynamic diameters between 20 nm and 10 µm were produced using various generators and different materials (DEHS, glass beads) in a specific test rig. For a given diameter, the collection efficiency was calculated by comparing the number concentrations measured alternatively upstream and downstream of the rotating cup, using APS (TSI 3321) or SMPS (Grimm DMA Vienna Type, CPC 5.403) spectrometers. While collection efficiency was 100% for particles > 3 µm, it progressively decreased to around 50 % and even below 10 % for aerodynamic diameters of 800 mm and 150 nm, respectively. Collection efficiency was unaffected by the type of foam or sampler flow rate used. Bias maps and consequences on workers aerosol exposure assessment will be discussed.

Aerosol exposure assessment during reclaimed water utilization in China and risk evaluation in case of Legionella

Aerosol exposure assessment during reclaimed water utilization in China and risk evaluation in case of Legionella

Combining real-time PCR and next-generation DNA sequencing to provide quantitative comparisons of fungal aerosol populations

We examined fungal communities associated with the PM10 mass of Rehovot, Israel outdoor air samples collected in the spring and fall seasons. Fungal communities were described by 454 pyrosequencing of the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) region of the fungal ribosomal RNA encoding gene. To allow for a more quantitative comparison of fungal exposure in humans, the relative abundance values of specific taxa were transformed to absolute concentrations through multiplying these values by the sample's total fungal spore concentration (derived from universal fungal qPCR). Next, the sequencing-based absolute concentrations for Alternaria alternata, Cladosporium cladosporioides, Epicoccum nigrum, and Penicillium/Aspergillus spp. were compared to taxon-specific qPCR concentrations for A. alternata, C. cladosporioides, E. nigrum, and Penicillium/Aspergillus spp. derived from the same spring and fall aerosol samples. Results of these comparisons showed that the absolute concentration values generated from pyrosequencing were strongly associated with the concentration values derived from taxon-specific qPCR (for all four species, p < 0.005, all R > 0.70). The correlation coefficients were greater for species present in higher concentrations. Our microbial aerosol population analyses demonstrated that fungal diversity (number of fungal operational taxonomic units) was higher in the spring compared to the fall (p = 0.02), and principal coordinate analysis showed distinct seasonal differences in taxa distribution (ANOSIM p = 0.004). Among genera containing allergenic and/or pathogenic species, the absolute concentrations of Alternaria, Aspergillus, Fusarium, and Cladosporium were greater in the fall, while Cryptococcus, Penicillium, and Ulocladium concentrations were greater in the spring. The transformation of pyrosequencing fungal population relative abundance data to absolute concentrations can improve next-generation DNA sequencing-based quantitative aerosol exposure assessment.

Occupational and environmental aerosol exposure assessment: a scientific journey from the past, through the present and into the future

This paper reviews how aerosol exposure assessment, for people in both working and living environments, has evolved over the years. It charts the main scientific developments that led to progressively improved ways of thinking and methods to assess exposure to airborne particulate matter in a manner more relevant to human health. It has been a long scientific journey as one generation of pioneering contributors has handed off to the next. In the process a consistent rationale has emerged, producing aerosol sampling criteria--and in turn exposure standards--which have been increasingly relevant to actual human exposures. The journey continues as a new generation of scientists steps up to deal with the new challenges that are emerging. An appreciation of the history of what went before is essential to charting the most effective path looking forward.

Establishing aerosol exposure predictive models based on noise measurements—using concrete drilling as an example

This study used a full scale mockup of a concrete drilling simulator to simulate drilling processes in an exposure chamber. Six drilling conditions were selected with rotating speeds and drill bit sizes varied from 265 to 587 rpm and 16 to 32 mm, respectively. For each drilling condition, the emitted noise power spectrums were measured and dust exposure concentrations of the fractions of the total (C(tot)), inhalable (C(inh)), thoracic (C(tho)), and respirable (C(res)) were estimated. We find that neither the resultant dust exposure levels nor the noise levels can be explained simply by the involved drilling mechanical energy. By dividing the emitted noise power spectrums into the high and low frequency noise (i.e., W(H) and W(L)), we find that 86.3%, 85.6%, 81.5%, and 77.6% variations of C(tot), C(inh), C(tho), and C(res) could be explained by the combination of W(H) and W(L), respectively. We also find that the emissions of coarse particles and W(L) were possibly contributed by two mechanisms of the impact wear and brittle fracture wear, whereas fine particles and W(H) could be contributed by the mechanism of abrasive wear. Although the predictive models obtained from this study could not be directly used in other dust emission sources, the developed methodology would be beneficial to industries in the future for aerosol exposure assessment, particularly when conducting conventional personal aerosol samplings is not possible in the field.

Emission Rates and Characterization of Aerosols Produced During the Spreading of Dewatered Class B Biosolids

This study measured aerosol emission rates produced during the spreading of dewatered class B biosolids onto agricultural land. Rates were determined in multiple independent experimental runs by characterizing both the source aerosol plume geometry and aerosol concentrations of PM10, total bacteria, heterotrophic plate count bacteria (HPC), two types of biosolids indicator bacteria, endotoxin, and airborne biosolids regulated metals. These components were also measured in the bulk biosolids to allow for correlating bulk biosolids concentrations with aerosol emission rates and to produce reconstructed aerosol concentrations. The average emission rates and associated standard deviation for biosolids PM10, total bacteria, HPC, total coliforms, sulfite-reducing Clostridia, endotoxin, and total biosolids regulated metals were 10.1 +/- 8.0 (mg/s), 1.98 +/- 1.41 x 10(9) (no./s), 9.0 +/- 11.2 x 10(7) (CFU/s), 4.9 +/- 2.2 x 10(3) (CFU/ s), 6.8 +/- 3.8 x 10(3) (CFU/s), 2.1 +/- 1.8 x 10(4) (EU/s), and 36.9 +/- 31.8 (microg/s) respectively. Based on the land application rates of spreaders used in this study, an estimated 7.6 +/- 6.3 mg of biosolids were aerosolized for every 1 kg (dry weight) applied to land. Scanning electron microscopy particle size distribution analysis of the aerosols revealed that greater than 99% of the emitted particles were less than 10 microm and particle size distributions had geometric mean diameters and standard deviations near 1.1 +/- 0.97 microm. The demonstrated correlations of bulk biosolids concentrations with aerosol emission rates, and the reconstruction of aerosol concentration based on PM10 and bulk biosolids concentration provide a more fundamental, bulk biosolids-based approach for extending biosolids aerosol exposure assessment to different land application scenarios and a broader range of toxins and pathogens.

Testing personal inhalable aerosol samplers: a suggested improved protocol based on new scientific knowledge

In 2002 the Comité Européen Normalisation (CEN) published its document Workplace atmospheres-assessment of performance of instruments for measurement of airborne particle concentrations (EN 13205) that describes a standard protocol by which to carry out the testing and validation of personal aerosol samplers of the type widely used for occupational aerosol exposure assessment. It emerged from more than a decade of discussion and a large body of research experience involving several laboratories. The protocol that is described, however, still poses significant technical and economic challenges, not least because it involves laborious-and hence costly-procedures in large, specialized wind tunnel facilities. More recent research has identified a number of areas by which the protocol may be improved and made more accessible to testing laboratories, including a set of validated aerosol sampler scaling laws, a better understanding of the reduced role of the bluff body of the wearer on sampler performance, and the availability of new options for rapid sampler testing methods. Taking these into account, a dummy new protocol is offered for discussion.

Aspiration Efficiency of IOM-Like Personal Aerosol Samplers from Experiments with a New Rapid Data Acquisition System

New automated instrumentation for the rapid acquisition of aerosol sampler aspiration efficiency data has been applied to an investigation of a range of personal aerosol samplers of the type developed during the 1980s at the Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) in Edinburgh, Scotland, U.K. The experimental research was carried out in a small wind tunnel, and the relation of the results for IOM-like samplers to full-scale life-size personal aerosol sampling scenarios—like those encountered in occupational aerosol exposure assessment—was investigated by reference to the scaling laws that have been developed based on familiar aerosol mechanics as they apply to the physics of aerosol sampling. In the small-scale experimental study, the IOM-like sampler was mounted centrally on a rectangular bluff body, simulating the wearing of the sampler on the body (e.g., as by a worker in an industrial setting). Scaling with respect to the corresponding, more-realistic full-scale system for a corresponding full-scale ...

Mass, surface area and number metrics in diesel occupational exposure assessment

While diesel aerosol exposure assessment has traditionally been based on the mass concentration metric, recent studies have suggested that particle number and surface area concentrations may be more health-relevant. In this study, we evaluated the exposures of three occupational groups-bus drivers, parking garage attendants, and bus mechanics-using the mass concentration of elemental carbon (EC) as well as surface area and number concentrations. These occupational groups are exposed to mixtures of diesel and gasoline exhaust on a regular basis in various ratios. The three groups had significantly different exposures to workshift TWA EC with the highest levels observed in the bus garage mechanics and the lowest levels in the parking ramp booth attendants. In terms of surface area, parking ramp attendants had significantly greater exposures than bus garage mechanics, who in turn had significantly greater exposures than bus drivers. In terms of number concentrations, the exposures of garage mechanics exceeded those of ramp booth attendants by a factor of 5-6. Depending on the exposure metric chosen, the three occupational groups had quite different exposure rankings. This illustrates the importance of the choice of exposure metric in epidemiological studies. If these three occupational groups were part of an epidemiological study, depending on the metric used, they may or may not be part of the same similarly exposed group (SEG). The exposure rankings (e.g., low, medium, or high) of the three groups also changes with the metric used. If the incorrect metric is used, significant misclassification errors may occur.

Evaluation of Two Inversion Techniques for Retrieving Health-Related Aerosol Fractions from Personal Cascade Impactor Measurements

Personal cascade impactors are widely used in occupational aerosol exposure assessment. Appropriate algorithms must be used to determine the total particle size distribution from masses collected on the stages of the cascade impactor. Such algorithms should be regarded as integral components of the measurement system. When evaluating algorithms for reconstruction of size distributions from cascade impactor data, the eventual use of the size distribution must be considered. So, from an industrial hygiene perspective, an appropriate basis for comparison of given measurement systems is the accurate retrieval of the inhalable, thoracic, and respirable aerosol fractions as described by the new, internationally accepted, particle size-selective sampling conventions (which are expected to form the basis of future aerosol standards). This article compares two inversion routines in terms of their abilities to retrieve these aerosol mass fractions relative to the masses that would have been obtained using an ideal sampler that perfectly followed the sampling convention. The routines were used to invert measurements made with the Institute of Occupational Medicine personal inhalable dust spectrometer, a miniature cascade impactor that aspirates the inhalable aerosol fraction, and the results are presented graphically as contours of equal mass bias. The simplest algorithm, based on the a priori assumption of lognormality, appears to provide the best results.

Occupational exposure to inhalable and total aerosol in the primary nickel production industry.

This paper describes a study that was carried out in the primary nickel production industry to investigate the levels of personal exposure to aerosols containing nickel and the impact on exposure assessment of introducing new personal sampling techniques with performance consistent with the latest particle size-selective criteria. Experiments were carried out at workplaces in mining, milling, smelting, and refining works to investigate the effect of changing from the current method of total aerosol (with the widely used 37 mm filter holder) to the new method of measuring inhalable aerosol (with the Institute of Occupational Medicine (IOM) inhalable aerosol sampler). The results show that inhalable aerosol exposure concentrations--for both overall aerosol and for total nickel--were consistently and significantly higher than the corresponding total aerosol concentrations. Weighted least squares linear regression yielded IOM/37 mm factors ranging from about 1.2 to 4.0. The exposure data for each company process were found to be log-normally distributed. The results suggest the possibility of generating a single pragmatic factor for each company process for converting current total aerosol exposures to new exposures based on the inhalability concept contained in the latest particle size-selective criteria for aerosol exposure assessment. Such data may be important in determining new occupational exposure limits for nickel.

Progress towards implementation of new aerosol industrial hygiene standards, with special reference to the aluminium industry

During recent years, progress has been made towards the establishment of particle size-selective criteria by which industrial aerosol exposure assessment - and, ultimately, standards — may be placed on a firmer health-related basis than previously. Three biologically-relevant fractions have been identified; inhalable (particles inhaled through the nose and/or mouth during breathing), thoracic (the subfraction of inhalable which penetrates into the lung below the larnyx), and respirable (the subfraction of inhalable which penetrates down to the alveolar region) and conventions for these have been agreed. Such conventions take the form of curves which should be regarded as ‘yardsticks’ for sampling instrumentation. In this paper, a summary is given of experiments in the workplaces of several industries in which a new personal sampler for the inhalable fraction is compared alongside the samplers which had been used previously. The results enable assessment of the impact of the implementation of the new standards. Such studies can aid in progress towards implementation of the new standards, including in the aluminium production industry.