In a recently published article (9), Wachino et al. reported that a single amino acid substitution (I292S) responsible for the expansion of the hydrolyzing activity against several extended-spectrum cephalosporins (ceftazidime or cefepime) is near the H-10 helix region of CMY-19. However, other reports (2, 7, 8) have concluded that the region responsible for the extended substrate spectrum in class C β-lactamases is in (not near) the H-10 helix. Wachino and colleagues designated the amino acid sequence from 279 to 287 as the H-10 helix (Fig. (Fig.1),1), which may be based on the crystal structure of AmpC K-12 (PDB code 2BLS), although they did not state the fact. However, one previous report described residues 279 to 294 as the H-10 helix, according to the crystal structure of GC1 (3). Our recent report (5) showed that the sequence from 289 to 294 was the H-10 (α10) helix (Fig. (Fig.1),1), based on superposed crystal structures among CMY-10 (5), P99, and GC1 β-lactamases. There are different positions of the H-10 helix that is related to the extended substrate spectrum in class C β-lactamases. Therefore, we propose that the exact region responsible for the extended substrate spectrum is the R2 loop (residues 289 to 307) (Fig. (Fig.1)1) described in our recent report (5). There are three important reasons why the exact region is the R2 loop in the R2 active site, referring to the region that accommodates the R2 side chain at C3 of the β-lactam nucleus in extended-spectrum cephalosporins. FIG. 1. A sequence alignment of amino acid residues near the H-9 (α9) and H-10 helix (α10) of class C β-lactamases with extended substrate spectrum. Alignment among CMY-10, P99, and GC1 β-lactamases whose structures are available ... First, the R2 loop includes all regions responsible for the extended substrate spectrum in all reported class C extended-spectrum β-lactamases except HKY28 (4): (i) six-amino-acid deletion (residues 289 to 294) of CHE (2); (ii) the single amino acid substitution (L296H) of AmpC KL (7); (iii) four-amino-acid deletion (residues 293 to 296) of HD (8); (iv) three-amino-acid deletion (residues 303 to 305) of CMY-10 (5); (v) the single amino acid substitution (I292S) of CMY-19 (9); and (vi) the L293P substitution of Ear2 (1). Second, mutations in the R2 loop can change the architecture of the active site in class C extended-spectrum β-lactamases, thereby affecting their hydrolyzing activity. Owing to the deletion in CMY-10, for example, the R2 loop in the R2 active site displays noticeable structural alterations: the shortened path of the connection R2 loop between α10 and β11 (Fig. (Fig.1)1) induces a ∼2.5-A shift of α9 and α10 relative to the adjacent helix α11 in CMY-10, compared with both P99 and GC1 β-lactamases, opening the gap between α9-α10 and α11 (5). Therefore, the bulky R2 side chain of extended-spectrum cephalosporins could fit snugly into the significantly widened R2 active site in this way (6). Third, CMY-19 showed 97% sequence identity to CMY-10. But the sequence identity between CMY-19 and AmpC K-12 was 40%. Therefore, it is reasonable for the region responsible for the extended substrate spectrum in CMY-19 to be designated based on the crystal structure of CMY-10 (not AmpC K-12).
Read full abstract