Brønsted basicity of solid particles is commonly evaluated by the pH of their aqueous suspensions, which is a simple and widely used analytical method. Herein, the pH of aqueous suspensions of activated carbons were measured to evaluate their Brønsted basicity. The results show that the pH of activated carbon suspensions varies greatly with residence time in a fast ascending and slowly descending pathway. Moreover, a significant electrolyte effect is found even in an ideal solution electrolyte of <0.01 M. Suspensions of basic porous carbon in 1 M NaCl or 0.5 M Na2SO4 solutions produce tenfold more OH− than those in ultrapure water, indicating much stronger Brønsted basicity. The great variation of pH with time and the significant electrolyte effect on pH can be attributed to the assembly of electric double-layers (EDLs) at the interface with the solid surface. Results on the isomerization of glucose into fructose demonstrate that basic activated carbons in electrolyte solutions have the potential to serve as a solid base. This work reveals a high degree of uncertainty in the pH of aqueous suspensions of carbons and provides new insight into the importance of EDLs at interfaces with solid surfaces with regard to Brønsted basicity of solids.