Natural compounds that either increase or decrease polymerization of actin into filaments have become indispensable tools for cell biology. However, to date, it was not possible to use them as therapeutics due to their overall cytotoxicity and their unfavorable pharmacokinetics. Furthermore, their synthesis is in general quite complicated. In an attempt to find simplified analogues of miuraenamide, an actin nucleating compound, we identified derivatives with a paradoxical inversion of the mode of action: instead of increased nucleation, they caused an inhibition. Using an extensive computational approach, we propose a binding mode and a mode of action for one of these derivatives. Based on our findings, it becomes feasible to tune actin-binding compounds to one or the other direction and to generate new synthetic actin binders with increased functional selectivity.