Tryptophan and its non-canonical variants play critical roles in pharmaceutical molecules and enzymes. Facile access to this privileged class of amino acids from readily available building blocks remains a long-standing challenge. Here, we report a regioselective synthesis of non-canonical tryptophans bearing C4-C7 substituents via Rh-catalyzed annulation between structurally diverse tert-butyloxycarbonyl (Boc)-protected anilines and alkynyl chlorides readily prepared from amino acid building blocks. This transformation harnesses Boc-directed C-H metalation and demetalation to afford a wide range of C2-unsubstituted indole products in a redox-neutral fashion. This umpolung approach compared to the classic Larock indole synthesis offers a novel mechanism for heteroarene annulation and will be useful for the synthesis of natural products and drug molecules containing non-canonical tryptophan residues in a highly regioselective manner.