Achiral Stationary Phases Research Articles

Sustainable solutions for direct TLC enantioseparation with in-home thought-out, prepared/modified chiral stationary phases.

TLC is used globally, yet less attention has been paid to TLC (in enantioseparation) despite its advantages. The present paper describes/reviews successfully practiced direct approaches of 'chiral additive in achiral stationary phase' (as an application of in-home thought out, prepared, tested, and modified chiral stationary phase), 'pre-mixing of chiral reagent with the enantiomeric mixture' (an approach using both achiral phases during chromatographic separation) and 'chiral additive in mobile phase', and chiral ligand exchange for enantioseparation of DL-amino acids, their derivatives, and some active pharmaceutical ingredients. It provided efficient enantioseparation, quantitative determination, and isolation of native forms via in-situ formation of non-covalent diastereomeric pair. The mechanism of enantioseparation in these approaches has been discussed along with the isolation and establishment of the structure of diastereomers. This may help chemists gain useful insights into fields outside their specialization and the experts get brief accounts of recent key developments, providing solutions for sustainable development of less expensive methods for control of enantiomeric purity and isolation of native enantiomers.

Introducing macrocyclic glycopeptide columns as unique achiral stationary phases: Insights from hydrophobic subtraction model and in-silico modeling

BackgroundThe need for stationary phases with unique selectivity in reversed-phase liquid chromatography has been of utmost importance to chromatographers for advancing the analysis of complex samples. Macrocyclic glycopeptide based stationary phases have been widely used for chiral separations with different chromatographic modes such as normal phase, reversed phase, and supercritical fluid chromatography. Given the multimodal retention mechanisms namely π-π complex interaction, hydrogen bonding, dipole-dipole interaction, and strong Coulombic interactions by which analytes are separated using the macrocyclic glycopeptides, these stationary phases are expected to provide novel selectivity when used under the reversed phase for achiral separations. ResultsHerein, for the first time we have conducted a systematic study using the improved hydrophobic subtraction model (HSM) which incoporates dipole-dipole interactions to demonstrate the novel selectivity offered by four different macrocyclic glycopeptide based stationary phases, namely NicoShell, TeicoShell, TagShell, and VancoShell. A comparison of the HSM parameters for these columns has been made with 551 commercially available reversed phase stationary phases and the differences in the values point to the importance of adding these columns to the already existing arsenal. These stationary phases offer separations over a wide range of pH and show variability in selectivity depending on the pH of the mobile phase which make them versatile for method development in the reversed phase mode. Additionally, we have provided an actual example of a separation from an Amgen discovery project using the VancoShell column aided by computer-assisted modelling. SignificanceThis is the first report characterizing macrocyclic glycopeptides for achiral RPLC applications. The selectivity of these stationary phases were found to be unique when compared to other commercially available stationary phases thereby acting as their own class of columns. The unusual selectivity of the columns enabled separation of complex pharmaceutical samples.

The Effect of the Stationary Phase on Resolution in the HPLC-Based Separation of Racemic Mixtures Using Vancomycin as a Chiral Selector: A Case Study with Profen Nonsteroidal Anti-Inflammatory Drugs

Chiral resolution is a technique of choice, making it possible to obtain asymmetric and enantiomerically pure compounds from a racemic mixture. This study investigated the behavior of vancomycin when used as a chiral additive in high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) to separate enantiomers of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), including ketoprofen, ibuprofen, flurbiprofen, and naproxen enantiomeric impurities. We compared two achiral stationary phases (C18 and NH2) to assess the impact of mobile phase composition and stationary phase on the vancomycin retention time in the racemic resolution of drug enantiomers. Our results demonstrated the successful enantioseparation of all drugs using vancomycin in the mobile phase (phosphate buffer 0.05 M/2-propanol, 50/50) with an NH2 column. This enhanced separation on the NH2 column resulted from the chromatography system’s efficiency and vancomycin dimers’ stereoselective interaction on the NH2 surface. This study underscores the importance of stationary phase selection in the chiral resolution of NSAIDs with vancomycin as a chiral additive. It offers valuable insights for future research and development of NSAID chiral separation methods, highlighting potential vancomycin applications in this context.

Enantioseparation of chiral phytocannabinoids in medicinal cannabis

The evaluation of the chiral composition of phytocannabinoids in the cannabis plant is particularly important as the pharmacological effects of the (+) and (-) enantiomers of these compounds are completely different. Chromatographic attempts to assess the presence of the minor (+) enantiomers of the main phytocannabinoids, cannabidiolic acid (CBDA) and trans-Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinolic acid (trans-Δ9-THCA), were carried out on heated plant extracts for the determination of the corresponding decarboxylated species, cannabidiol (CBD) and trans-Δ9-tetrahydrocannabinol (trans-Δ9-THC), respectively. This process produces an altered phytocannabinoid composition with several new and unknown decomposition products. The present work reports for the first time the stereoselective synthesis of the pure (+) enantiomers of the main phytocannabinoids, trans-CBDA, trans-Δ9-THCA, trans-CBD and trans-Δ9-THC, and the development and optimization of an achiral-chiral liquid chromatography method coupled to UV and high-resolution mass spectrometry detection in reversed phase conditions (RP-HPLC-UV-HRMS) for the isolation of the single compounds and evaluation of their actual enantiomeric composition in plant. The isolation of the peaks with the achiral stationary phase ensured the absence of interferences that could potentially co-elute with the analytes of interest in the chiral analysis. The method applied to the Italian medicinal cannabis variety FM2 revealed no trace of the (+) enantiomers for all phytocannabinoids under investigation before and after decarboxylation, thus suggesting that the extraction procedure does not lead to an inversion of configuration.

Coupling of chiral and achiral stationary phases in supercritical fluid chromatography: Evaluating and improving retention prediction

Isomers and stereoisomers are always challenging to separate. Column coupling may provide improved chromatographic selectivity, necessary for the separation of the compounds with similar chemical and structural properties. The relatively low viscosity of supercritical fluids, used as mobile phases allows for the coupling of several columns in series in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), without exceeding the pressure limits of the system. The aim of this study is to propose reliable prediction of the retention behaviour of analytes on a coupled column system, based on a limited number of initial analyses. The chiral compounds atenolol, ephedrine, propranolol, mianserin, labetalol and nadolol, besides the diastereomers quinine and quinidine, and the structural isomers of aminophenol and aminocresol were used as model analytes. The retention behaviour of the analytes was determined on the individual chiral columns Lux Cellulose-1, Lux Cellulose-2, Lux Cellulose-3, Lux Cellulose-4, Lux Amylose-2 and the achiral columns Luna NH2, Luna Silica, Synergi RP and FluoroSep RP. The mobile phase was composed of CO2 mixed with 20% (v/v) MeOH, which contained 0.1% (v/v) trifluoroacetic acid and 0.1% (v/v) isopropylamine. The retention factors of the analytes on coupled stationary phases were predicted, and subsequently compared to the experimentally obtained ones. Relative deviations of predicted and experimental retention factors were in range from 0.00% to 51.91%. Flow rate and back pressure of the screening conditions were adjusted to improve prediction precision on four column combinations, with varying success rates. The average relative deviations of retention factors were reduced to 2.84% - 6.59% by adjusting flow rate, and to 2.30% - 8.57% by adjusting back pressure. The most successful approach, flow rate adjustment, was then applied to select a column combination providing improved resolution of the structurally similar components of silymarin extract.

Analytical Quality by Design-Compliant Retention Modeling for Comparing Multivariate Eluent Design Spaces – Studying Column Interchangeabilities in Separating Ezetimibe and its Related Impurities on Achiral Stationary Phases

Analytical Quality by Design-Compliant Retention Modeling for Comparing Multivariate Eluent Design Spaces – Studying Column Interchangeabilities in Separating Ezetimibe and its Related Impurities on Achiral Stationary Phases

Inherently chiral dialkyloxy-calix[4]arene acetic acids as enantiodiscriminating additives for high-performance liquid chromatography separation of d,l-amino acids.

Inherently chiral dialkyloxy-calix[4]arene acetic acids with asymmetric placement of substituents on the lower rim of the macrocycle were first studied as enantiodiscriminating additives to the mobile phase MeCN/H2 O/HCOOH (75/25/0.02 by volume) in the high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) separation of d,l-alanine and d,l-valine on the achiral stationary phase ZORBAX Original CN. The dependence of enantio-binding properties on the position of alkyl groups is demonstrated. The highest resolution (1.65) and enantioselectivity (1.80) were obtained for the 1,2-dipropyloxy-calix[4]arene acetic acid.

Simultaneous Quantitative Determination of Synthetic Cathinone Enantiomers in Urine by GC-NCI-MS/MS using Menthylchloroformate as Chiral Derivatization Reagent

Development and validation of a new analytical method for enantioseparation and quantitation of synthetic cathinones is reported using a chiral derivatization agent (CDA) and GC-MS triple quadrupole mass spectrometry with negative chemical ionization (NCI) mode. Indirect separation of ten synthetic cathinone compounds has been achieved using a commercially available optically pure CDA called (1R)-(-)-menthylchloroformate (MCF). MCF was capable of converting synthetic cathinone enantiomers into diastereoisomers, which were later separated with good resolution on an ultra-inert 60 m achiral stationary phase column. An internal standard (IS), 3-methylmethcathinone (3-MMC) was used for quantitation of synthetic cathinone diastereoisomers. Method validation in terms of calibration curve linearity, sensitivity in terms of limits of detections (LODs), limits of quantitation (LOQs), interday and intra-day reproducibility, and recoveries has been obtained for the ten synthetic cathinone compounds that were analyzed simultaneously as a mixture after being spiked in urine. It was found that LOD’s and LOQ’s for the ten synthetic cathinones mixture in urine were in the ranges of 0.004-3.678 ppm and 0.012-11.14 ppm respectively. The results of four synthetic cathinones (Buphedrone, 3-MethylBP,3,4-DMEC, and Butylone) derivatized with MCF were compared with the same compounds derivatized with N-trifluoroacetyl-L-prolyl chloride (L-TPC). It was found that the later was more sensitive in terms of LOD and LOQ than the former method.

A General Phenomenon of Spontaneous Amplification of Optical Purity under Achiral Chromatographic Conditions

This work explores the behavior of chiral compound mixtures enriched in one of the enantiomers whilst a typical chromatography on the achiral stationary phase is employed. The influence of several factors, such as the eluent composition, ratio of the compound to the stationary phase, and the initial enatiomeric purity of the compound used on the distribution of the enantiomers in the collected chromatographic fraction, was studied. The obtained results indicate that the phenomenon of Self Disproportionation of Enantiomer (SDE) occurred in all cases, and some of the collected fractions got higher optical purities than the initial one. Thus, achiral column chromatography could be applied in some cases as the simplest approach for chiral purification. Based on the experimental results and DFT calculations, an alternative concept explaining the SDE phenomenon was proposed. Due to its generality and simplicity, SDE may also be responsible for the formation of the first chiral non-racemic compounds on the early Earth.

Purification of drug degradation products supported by analytical and preparative supercritical fluid chromatography

A stressed degradation (oxidation) was employed to produce metabolites from an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) with large molecular weight (about 900 g/mol). An analytical chromatographic method was desired to compare the products generated by different degradation methods while a multi-gram-scale preparative chromatographic method was necessary to purify the produced metabolites. Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) was selected for both tasks as no other chromatographic method had achieved the resolution of the API and metabolites (two isomeric mono-oxide species and one di-oxide). First, an analytical-scale method was developed with ultra-high performance supercritical fluid chromatography (UHPSFC). Achiral stationary phases containing sub-2 μm fully porous particles or sub-3 μm superficially porous particles, and chiral phases containing 3 and 5 μm fully porous particles were selected for a first screening with gradient elution (carbon dioxide – methanol containing additives). The stationary phase providing the most promising results was ACQUITY Torus 2-PIC (100 x 3 mm, 1.7 μm, Waters). A central composite design (CCD) was conducted to optimize the gradient program and oven temperature. Final gradient conditions were as follows: 50–70% methanol in 3.8 min with oven temperature set at 36 °C, back-pressure set at 11 MPa and flow-rate at 0.8 mL/min. The optimized method was employed to analyze samples obtained with different degradation conditions. Then the method was adapted and transferred to preparative-scale SFC on a 5 μm-particles Torus 2-PIC stationary phase (150 x 30 mm). The method was modified to comprise an isocratic step followed by a gradient, favoring peak shape of the last eluting compound and minimal volume of collected fractions. Batch injections in gradient mode were carried out to purify six grams of crude product.

Sequential Tether‐Directed Synthesis of Pentakis‐Adducts of C60 with a Mixed [3:2] Octahedral Addition Pattern

The design of a novel concept for the synthesis of [3:2] pentakis‐adducts of fullerene C60 is presented. A sequential tether‐directed, remote functionalization approach is introduced for the construction of the pentakis‐adducts. This fullerene derivative embellished with two different addends in two different directions can be considered as a valuable tecton for further functionalization. The stepwise cyclopropanation of C60 with a macrocyclic tris‐malonate and a bis(β‐keto ester) yielded the corresponding pentakis‐adduct with an incomplete octahedral addition pattern. This reaction sequence gave access to two pairs of enantiomers that were easily separated by column chromatography on an achiral stationary phase and subsequently characterized.

Poly(butylene terephthalate) based novel achiral stationary phase investigated under supercritical fluid chromatography conditions

Poly(butylene terephthalate) based novel stationary phase (SP), composed of planar aromatic phenyl group together with ester group monomer units, was designed for supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) use. As expected from its structure, this phase shows planarity recognition of isomeric aromatics and closely similar compounds. Interestingly, for most analytes, the retention behavior of this SP is significantly distinct from that of the 2-ethylpyridine based SPs which is among the most well-known SFC dedicated phases. Although the poly(butylene terephthalate) is coated on silica gel, the performance of the column did not change by using extended range modifiers such as THF, dichloromethane or ethyl acetate and column robustness was confirmed by cycle durability testing.

Interest of achiral-achiral tandem columns for impurity profiling of synthetic drugs with supercritical fluid chromatography

To achieve the most complete impurity profiling of synthetic drugs with a single chromatographic technique, high resolution is required, which may be gained with a combination of high efficiency and versatile selectivity, allowing to separate most similar analytes. Compared to a single-column chromatographic method, coupling complementary stationary phases promises both an increase in efficiency and an increase in selectivity possibilities. With supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC), the use of long columns is facilitated by the low viscosity of the mobile phase. In this paper, we investigate the interest of coupling two achiral stationary phases (Acquity UPC2 HSS C18 SB and Nucleoshell HILIC) that were previously observed to have excellent complementarity in SFC to carry out impurity profiling on 25 individual drug substances containing varied numbers and amounts of impurities. The single-column gradient methods are compared to tandem-column gradient methods with the two possible ordering of columns (C18 phase in first or second position) based on selectivity, peak capacity, sensitivity, UV-estimated purity of the active pharmaceutical ingredient and number of impurities detected with UV-estimated concentration >0.04%. It appears that it could be more beneficial to have two columns coupled in a single analysis than two consecutive methods with the single columns. The overall analysis time are nearly the same, but with more informative chromatograms in about 35% cases.

Individual (f,tA)‐ and (f,tC)‐Fullerene‐Based Nickel(II) Glycinates: Protected Chiral Amino Acids Directly Linked to a Chiral π‐Electron System

AbstractStereoselective electrosynthesis of the first individual (f,tA)‐ and (f,tC)‐1,4‐fullerene derivatives with a non‐inherently chiral functionalization pattern is described, as well as the first example of an optically pure protected primary amino acid directly linked to the fullerene through only the chiral α‐amino‐acid carbon atom. An application of an auxiliary chiral nickel‐Schiff base moiety as derivatizing agent allowed separation of (f,tA)‐ and (f,tC)‐1,4‐fullerene derivatives using an achiral stationary phase, a separation which has never been done before.

Individual (f,t A)- and (f,t C)-Fullerene-Based Nickel(II) Glycinates: Protected Chiral Amino Acids Directly Linked to a Chiral π-Electron System.

Stereoselective electrosynthesis of the first individual (f,t A)- and (f,t C)-1,4-fullerene derivatives with a non-inherently chiral functionalization pattern is described, as well as the first example of an optically pure protected primary amino acid directly linked to the fullerene through only the chiral α-amino-acid carbon atom. An application of an auxiliary chiral nickel-Schiff base moiety as derivatizing agent allowed separation of (f,t A)- and (f,t C)-1,4-fullerene derivatives using an achiral stationary phase, a separation which has never been done before.

A comprehensive examination of the self-disproportionation of enantiomers (SDE) of chiral amides via achiral, laboratory-routine, gravity-driven column chromatography

The behavior of a series of chiral amides during column chromatography using an achiral stationary phase revealed that a self-disproportionation of enantiomers (SDE) was always observed regardless of amide structure or chromatographic conditions.

Comparative assessment of achiral stationary phases for high throughput analysis in supercritical fluid chromatography

Supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) using open bed fraction collection is becoming more widely used for purification of diverse collections of compounds for drug discovery. This application requires predictable chromatography on scale up from analytical to preparative conditions. We have discovered that the selectivities of many columns used for SFC change over time when ammonium acetate additive is present in the mobile phase as a result of changes in silanophilic interactions. This makes scale up predictions difficult. To address this challenge we have developed a nontraditional comprehensive column ranking. Our system is based on the long-term retention repeatability of basic drugs in ammonium acetate containing mobile phase. The decreases in retention over time were used as a measure of changing silanophilicity of the stationary phases and became the basis for a column ranking system. This system, along with results for 24 commonly used silica-based columns, is presented in this paper.

Self-disproportionation of enantiomers via achiral chromatography: a warning and an extra dimension in optical purifications

This tutorial review describes the self-disproportionation of enantiomers (SDE) of chiral, non-racemic compounds, subjected to chromatography on an achiral stationary phase using an achiral eluent, which leads to the substantial enantiomeric enrichment and the corresponding depletion in different fractions, as compared to the enantiomeric composition of the starting material. The physicochemical background of SDE is a dynamic formation of homo- or heterochiral dimeric or oligomeric aggregates of different chromatographic behavior. This phenomenon is of a very general nature as the SDE has been reported for different classes of organic compounds bearing various functional groups and possessing diverse elements of chirality (central, axial and helical chirality). The literature data discussed in this review clearly suggest that SDE via achiral chromatography might be expected for any given chiral enantiomerically enriched compound. This presents two very important issues for organic chemists. First, chromatographic purification of reaction products can lead to erroneous determination of the stereochemical outcome of catalytic asymmetric reactions and second, achiral chromatography can be used as a new, nonconventional method for optical purifications. The latter has tremendous practical potential as the currently available techniques are limited to crystallization or chiral chromatography. However, a further systematic study of SDE is needed to develop understanding of this phenomenon and to design practical chromatographic separation techniques for optical purification of non-racemic mixtures by achiral-phase chromatography.

Enantiomeric fraction as an indicator of pharmaceutical biotransformation during wastewater treatment and in the environment – a review

Enantioselective analysis of some pharmaceuticals during wastewater treatment has the potential to reveal significant insights regarding the effectiveness of biotransformation processes. Furthermore, enantioselective analysis of chiral pharmaceuticals in the aquatic environment may provide a useful historical record revealing the dominant source of (treated or untreated) wastewater contamination. This review of the recent scientific literature has identified only a handful of studies that have directly investigated these promising applications. However, a range of enantioselective analytical techniques are likely to be adaptable from those which have been developed within the pharmaceutical industry. These include direct enantioseparations of enantiomers on chiral stationary phases as well as indirect separations by achiral stationary phases after chiral derivatization to form pairs of physically distinguishable diastereomers. Further investigations of the patterns of enantiomeric fractionation of pharmaceuticals in wastewater and environmental samples will provide an increasingly solid understanding of the relationship between biotransformation processes and the often overlooked parameter of enantiomeric fraction.

Separation of triphenyl atropisomers of a pharmaceutical compound on a novel mixed mode stationary phase: A case study involving dynamic chromatography, dynamic NMR and molecular modeling

Analysis of atropisomers is of considerable interest in the pharmaceutical industry. For complex chiral molecules with several chiral centers hindered axial rotation can lead to formation of interconverting diastereomers that should be separable on achiral stationary phases. However, achieving the actual separation may be difficult as the on-column separation speed must match or be faster then the rate of isomer interconversion. Often, this requirement can be satisfied by using low-temperature conditions and by improving selectivity via use of chiral stationary phases. In the current study, we present an alternative approach utilizing an Obelisc R column, a novel mixed mode stationary phase that provided acceptable separation of triphenyl atropisomers inside a conventional HPLC temperature range. The separation was investigated under various chromatographic conditions. The interconversion chromatograms exhibited classic peak–plateau-peak behavior indicating the simultaneous atropisomer separation and interconversion. The elution profiles were integrated in order to deconvolute the peak areas of the “pure” (non-exchanged) and interconverted species; these data were used to obtain kinetic information. Analysis of retention data rendered thermodynamic information on the mechanism of retention and selectivity. Chromatographic kinetic data were complemented with variable-temperature NMR and molecular modeling studies, which provided additional support and insights into the energetics of the interconversion process.