Kikuyugrass (Pennisetum clandestinum Hochst. ex Chiov.) is an active silicon (Si) accumulator, and Si can reduce the organic‐matter digestibility of forage grasses. Calcium carbonate (crushed coral) applications to a low Si Maile silt loam soil (Acrudoxic Hydrudands) had no effect on the in vitro digestible organic matter (IVDOM) concentration of 3‐week‐old (4.5‐leaf‐per‐tiller stage of development) ‘Whittet’ kikuyugrass regrowth, whereas calcium silicate (wollastonite) applied at the calcium equivalent of the calcium carbonate rates produced a curvilinear (crescent‐shaped quadratic) IVDOM response. Whittet IVDOM decreased when grass Si concentration exceeded about 22 g kg−1 or when 0.5 M acetic acid–extractable soil Si exceeded about 230 mg kg−1. Common and ‘Hosaka’ kikuyugrass regrowth on the Maile soil had less Si and greater IVDOM concentrations than those observed for high‐Si Kohala (Humic Dystrustepts) and Waialua (Pachic Haplustolls) silty clay soils. Whittet had greater crude protein and IVDOM concentrations and lesser fiber concentrations than common.