In this issue of AIDS, Sacktor and colleagues [1] describe a relatively simple bedside screening tool for HIV dementia. Despite the advent of HAART, dementia remains both common and debilitating in the HIV-infected population. HIV dementia will ultimately affect 10–15% of all HIV infected individuals and even higher rates pertain, perhaps approaching 60% [2], for any degree of cognitive impairment occurring by the time of death in the absence of antiretroviral drugs. Along with HIV-associated peripheral neuropathy, HIV dementia represents one of the most common of the neurological disorders resulting from this viral infection. In general, studies comparing the incidence of this disorder from the period of time before to that after the introduction of HAART indicated that its incidence had declined, at least as an AIDS defining event [3–5]. However, when the DANA (pre-HAART) and NEAD (post-HAART) cohorts were compared, the cumulative incidence of HIV dementia was virtually identical at 1 and 2 years [6]. These cumulative incidences were 25% in both studies at one year and 40% and 38%, respectively, at 2 years. Despite the decline in incidence, the prevalence of HIV dementia appeared to increase; however, these findings have been inconsistently demonstrated, perhaps because of differing populations. Some investigators have proposed that HAART has changed the pattern of neuropsychological abnormality observed in HIV infection and, possibly, that in HIV dementia [7]. In its advanced form, diagnosing HIV dementia is not difficult. The illness is characterized by features chiefly reflective of a frontal subcortical dementing process typically associated with a severe degree of immunodeficiency. A decline in mental alacrity (bradyphrenia) and slowness of movement (bradykinesia) are salient components of the disorder and the patient frequently complains of difficulty with memory. When, as is often the case, the disorder occurs in association with other illnesses attending advanced immunodeficiency, it may be overlooked. Less advanced dementia may be difficult to diagnose. In general, detailed neuropsychological batteries are employed to determine the degree and nature of the cognitive impairment and to identify contributing or obfuscating co-morbidities such as depression and anxiety. Unfortunately, these batteries require professionals skilled in their performance and are both time consuming and costly. They are not widely available and certainly not applicable for the AIDS populations in developing countries. In an effort to develop a bedside screening tool, Power and colleagues [8] devised a test that could be administered in minutes consisting of four components. The test focuses on tasks that are likely to be affected by a frontal subcortical disorder and includes components that assess verbal memory recall, writing speed for the alphabet in capital letters, speed and ability to copy a three dimensional figure, and suppression of ocular saccadic refixation on an image. Sacktor and colleagues [1] have essentially revised this set of tasks to a total of three which are more universally applicable than the original battery. In essence, they include tasks of recall, non-dominant finger tapping speed, and psychomotor speed determined by the correct repetitive replication of a sequence of hand movements. Currently, it is estimated that there are 42 million people worldwide infected with HIV (http://www.who.int/hiv/pub/epidemiology/epi2002/en/). Fewer than 10% of these individuals live in developed countries. Therefore, access to advanced diagnostic tools and the most highly effective antiretroviral regimens is limited in at least 38 million people. If 10% of this population (a conservative estimate), ultimately develops HIV dementia, this is a staggering burden of this disorder. Reliable bedside methods for determining whether a patient has features of HIV dementia and for following the impact of the disorder would be very important among these populations. In that respect, the International HIV Dementia Scale proposed by Sacktor and colleagues is an important first step. One must bear in mind that this scale appears to be, at best, only a screening tool. The absolute difference in mean scores between the demented and non-demented subjects was small, 1.3 points, on a scale of 12, albeit statistically significant. Not surprisingly, with a cut off score of 10, which provided a sensitivity of 80%, the test lacked specificity. These results parallel those observed with the original HIV dementia scale, but neither sensitivity or specificity seem to be as robust as that observed with the former [8,9]. The relatively low specificity indicates a risk of misclassifying patients without dementia. Additionally, the number of subjects in this study was relatively small and only one site in an underdeveloped country was compared to a US population. Therefore, additional studies will be needed before this test is widely adopted. Furthermore, issues such as re-test validity and practice effect need to be defined. As the authors correctly assert, the International HIV Dementia Scale is but a screening tool and has not been designed to be a substitute for detailed neuropsychological testing. That said, it is a valuable contribution to the field.
Read full abstract