INTRODUCTION: Abnormal liver enzyme tests are a common finding in the clinical setting but the differential is broad and requires critical thinking. Often, the etiology is unclear in medically complex patients as the cause may be multifactorial. Sarcoidosis is a systemic autoimmune condition and many clinicians are familiar with its pulmonary involvement but about 30% of affected patients have extrapulmonary manifestations. Clinically significant gastrointestinal disease occurs in less than 1% of sarcoidosis patients but the liver can be involved in up to 65% of affected individuals. Accurate assessment and diagnosis can be difficult and requires one to always be open to a broad differential. CASE DESCRIPTION/METHODS: Our case involved a 47-year-old female with history of hashimoto’s disease, multiple sclerosis on tecfidera, and pulmonary sarcoidosis in remission. Incidental elevation of AST, ALT, and alkaline phosphatase were noted on labs when she was admitted after a car accident. Initial liver biopsy was nondiagnostic and lab work revealed normal ferratin, negative ASMA, AMA, A1AT, hepatitis C antibody and acute hepatitis panel but ANA was positive. Due to report of right upper quadrant abdominal pain at that time, she underwent MRI of the abdomen/pelvis and the common bile duct was noted to be 7 mm. She had an ERCP at that time with a sphincterotomy and though the pain resolved, her labs persisted. Tecfidera was another confounder as it also causes transaminitis. However, a medication interruption showed no improvement. Since a clear diagnosis was not found, her team trialed her on steroids for presumed autoimmune hepatitis and her labs improved. When her taper ended, she was readmitted for transaminitis and repeat liver biopsy at that time showed portal and periportal granuloma with associated lymphohistiocytic lobular necroinflammatory activity, which was more consistent with hepatic sarcoidosis. She was started on budesonide with imuran and her labs normalized. DISCUSSION: Though the patient had a remote history of sarcoidosis, she also had a number of other possible causes for her transaminitis and prior to the second biopsy, the working diagnosis of autoimmune hepatitis was supported by a positive ANA and improvement following steroids. This case highlights the importance of keeping a broad, evolving differential while merging clinical assessment with critical interpretation of laboratory data.