Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Phantom Research Articles

Integrated particle image velocimetry and fluid–structure interaction analysis for patient-specific abdominal aortic aneurysm studies

BackgroundUnderstanding the hemodynamics of an abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is crucial for risk assessment and treatment planning. This study introduces a low-cost, patient-specific in vitro AAA model to investigate hemodynamics using particle image velocimetry (PIV) and flow-simulating circuit, validated through fluid–structure interaction (FSI) simulations.MethodsIn this study, 3D printing was employed to manufacture a flexible patient-specific AAA phantom using a lost-core casting technique. A pulsatile flow circuit was constructed using off-the-shelf components. A particle image velocimetry (PIV) setup was built using an affordable laser source and global shutter camera, and finally, the flow field inside the AAA was analyzed using open-source software. Fluid–structure interaction (FSI) simulations were performed to enhance our understanding of the flow field, and the results were validated by PIV analysis. Both steady-state and transient flow conditions were investigated.ResultsOur experimental setup replicated physiological conditions, analyzing arterial wall deformations and flow characteristics within the aneurysm. Under constant flow, peak wall deformations and flow velocities showed deviations within − 12% to + 27% and − 7% to + 5%, respectively, compared to FSI simulations. Pulsatile flow conditions further demonstrated a strong correlation (Pearson coefficient 0.85) in flow velocities and vectors throughout the cardiac cycle. Transient phenomena, particularly the formation and progression of vortex structures during systole, were consistently depicted between experimental and numerical models.ConclusionsBy bridging high-fidelity experimental observations with comprehensive computational analyses, this study underscores the potential of integrated methodologies in enhancing our understanding of AAA pathophysiology. The convergence of realistic AAA phantoms, precise PIV measurements at affordable cost point, and validated FSI models heralds a new paradigm in vascular research, with significant implications for personalized medicine and bioengineering innovations.

A patient-specific multi-modality abdominal aortic aneurysm imaging phantom

PurposeMultimodality imaging of the vascular system is a rapidly growing area of innovation and research, which is increasing with awareness of the dangers of ionizing radiation. Phantom models that are applicable across multiple imaging modalities facilitate testing and comparisons in pre-clinical studies of new devices. Additionally, phantom models are of benefit to surgical trainees for gaining experience with new techniques. We propose a temperature-stable, high-fidelity method for creating complex abdominal aortic aneurysm phantoms that are compatible with both radiation-based, and ultrasound-based imaging modalities, using low cost materials.MethodsVolumetric CT data of an abdominal aortic aneurysm were acquired. Regions of interest were segmented to form a model compatible with 3D printing. The novel phantom fabrication method comprised a hybrid approach of using 3D printing of water-soluble materials to create wall-less, patient-derived vascular structures embedded within tailored tissue-mimicking materials to create realistic surrounding tissues. A non-soluble 3-D printed spine was included to provide a radiological landmark.ResultsThe phantom was found to provide realistic appearances with intravascular ultrasound, computed tomography and transcutaneous ultrasound. Furthermore, the utility of this phantom as a training model was demonstrated during a simulated endovascular aneurysm repair procedure with image fusion.ConclusionWith the hybrid fabrication method demonstrated here, complex multimodality imaging patient-derived vascular phantoms can be successfully fabricated. These have potential roles in the benchtop development of emerging imaging technologies, refinement of novel minimally invasive surgical techniques and as clinical training tools.

Validation of an assessment tool for estimation of abdominal aortic aneurysm compression in diagnostic ultrasound

The study investigated ultrasound (US) transducer push, tantamount to applied transducer pressure, during abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) US scanning in a simulated non-clinical setup.During an assessment of maximal AAA diameter on a three-dimensional print-based AAA phantom, US transducer push varied as much as 2000% (range: 0.52–12.45 kPa) amongst 16 experienced sonographers. The mean transducer push was 5.54 ± 3.91 kPa (CV = 0.71).Deformation of a standardized gel-pad allowed for transducer push calculation based on US images; Young’s modulus of the gel-pad was estimated to 44,26 N/m2.The method is theoretically validated in a safe and non-clinical environment. Future investigations with the aim of clinical validation of the gel-pad principle on AAA patients are suggested, including the objectification of the magnitude of an eventual transducer push-related error during US AAA diameter measurement.

Utility of 3D printed abdominal aortic aneurysm phantoms: a systematic review.

3D printed (3DP) abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) phantoms are emerging in the literature as an adjunct for the visualization of complex anatomy, particularly for presurgical device selection and simulation. This is the first systematic review to provide a comprehensive overview of 3DP for endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) planning and intervention, evaluating the readiness of current levels of technology for mainstream implementation. A systematic literature search of PubMed and MEDLINE was performed as per PRISMA guidelines using the terms '3D Printing', 'AAA' OR 'EVAR' and related index terms, and further relevant articles were appraised via a snowballing approach. Our last search was conducted on 14 November 2020. Twenty-five articles were identified for critical analysis, with 14 cases or technical reports. Nineteen publications utilized 3DP AAA phantoms to aid presurgical decision making, device selection and design. Four publications explored the utility of 3DP phantoms as EVAR trainers, and one publication examined the technology as a tool for patient education. Flexible, transparent phantoms were deemed most useful; however, the cost and availability of higher end machines limited accessibility. 3DP phantoms have been used in EVAR to facilitate visualization of complex patient anatomy, appropriate device selection, in predicting navigational difficulties and the shape and position of endograft after deployment. These phantoms show promise in reducing known complications such as endoleak, stent graft occlusion and migration; however, larger scale prospective studies are required to validate its impacts on patient outcomes and cost savings to the healthcare system.

Design, Development, and Temporal Evaluation of a Magnetic Resonance Imaging-Compatible In Vitro Circulation Model Using a Compliant Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Phantom.

Biomechanical characterization of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) has become commonplace in rupture risk assessment studies. However, its translation to the clinic has been greatly limited due to the complexity associated with its tools and their implementation. The unattainability of patient-specific tissue properties leads to the use of generalized population-averaged material models in finite element analyses, which adds a degree of uncertainty to the wall mechanics quantification. In addition, computational fluid dynamics modeling of AAA typically lacks the patient-specific inflow and outflow boundary conditions that should be obtained by nonstandard of care clinical imaging. An alternative approach for analyzing AAA flow and sac volume changes is to conduct in vitro experiments in a controlled laboratory environment. In this study, we designed, built, and characterized quantitatively a benchtop flow loop using a deformable AAA silicone phantom representative of a patient-specific geometry. The impedance modules, which are essential components of the flow loop, were fine-tuned to ensure typical intraluminal pressure conditions within the AAA sac. The phantom was imaged with a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scanner to acquire time-resolved images of the moving wall and the velocity field inside the sac. Temporal AAA sac volume changes lead to a corresponding variation in compliance throughout the cardiac cycle. The primary outcome of this work was the design optimization of the impedance elements, the quantitative characterization of the resistive and capacitive attributes of a compliant AAA phantom, and the exemplary use of MRI for flow visualization and quantification of the deformed AAA geometry.

Pulsatile flow measurements and wall stress distribution in a patient specific abdominal aortic aneurysm phantom

AbstractIn this study, we develop a physiologic internal pressure and wall stress analysis procedure and apply it to a patient‐specific abdominal aortic aneurysm model. Time‐dependent pressure loading of the inner vessel wall was experimentally measured in a 3D printed aneurysm phantom. The results were used as boundary conditions for finite element calculations of von Mises stresses throughout the AAA model over the cardiac cycle. A nonlinear hyperelastic constitutive law with parameters based on biaxial stress‐deformation data from aneurysmal tissue samples was used to describe the mechanical behavior of the aneurysm wall. The internal pressure was found to be fairly spatially uniform (within 10%) over most of the cardiac cycle, but average internal pressure varied by more than a factor of two between systole and diastole. The aneurysm wall stress was highly spatially nonuniform. The highest value of von Mises stress was localized in a small area within the aneurysm bulge and remained in the same place throughout the cardiac cycle, suggesting that this area was the most likely point of rupture. Large variations in wall stress over the cardiac cycle suggest calculations that assume steady flow are a poor approximation for physiological stresses.

Experimental feasibility of spectral photon-counting computed tomography with two contrast agents for the detection of endoleaks following endovascular aortic repair

ObjectivesAfter endovascular aortic repair (EVAR), discrimination of endoleaks and intra-aneurysmatic calcifications within the aneurysm often requires multiphase computed tomography (CT). Spectral photon-counting CT (SPCCT) in combination with a two-contrast agent injection protocol may provide reliable detection of endoleaks with a single CT acquisition.MethodsTo evaluate the feasibility of SPCCT, the stent-lined compartment of an abdominal aortic aneurysm phantom was filled with a mixture of iodine and gadolinium mimicking enhanced blood. To represent endoleaks of different flow rates, the adjacent compartments contained either one of the contrast agents or calcium chloride to mimic intra-aneurysmatic calcifications. After data acquisition with a SPCCT prototype scanner with multi-energy bins, material decomposition was performed to generate iodine, gadolinium and calcium maps.ResultsIn a conventional CT slice, Hounsfield units (HU) of the compartments were similar ranging from 147 to 168 HU. Material-specific maps differentiate the distributions within the compartments filled with iodine, gadolinium or calcium.ConclusionSPCCT may replace multiphase CT to detect endoleaks without sacrificing diagnostic accuracy. It is a unique feature of our method to capture endoleak dynamics and allow reliable distinction from intra-aneurysmatic calcifications in a single scan, thereby enabling a significant reduction of radiation exposure.Key Points• SPCCT might enable advanced endoleak detection.• Material maps derived from SPCCT can differentiate iodine, gadolinium and calcium.• SPCCT may potentially reduce radiation burden for EVAR patients under post-interventional surveillance.

A methodology for developing anisotropic AAA phantoms via additive manufacturing

An Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm (AAA) is a permanent focal dilatation of the abdominal aorta at least 1.5 times its normal diameter. The criterion of maximum diameter is still used in clinical practice, although numerical studies have demonstrated the importance of biomechanical factors for rupture risk assessment. AAA phantoms could be used for experimental validation of the numerical studies and for pre-intervention testing of endovascular grafts. We have applied multi-material 3D printing technology to manufacture idealized AAA phantoms with anisotropic mechanical behavior. Different composites were fabricated and the phantom specimens were characterized by biaxial tensile tests while using a constitutive model to fit the experimental data. One composite was chosen to manufacture the phantom based on having the same mechanical properties as those reported in the literature for human AAA tissue; the strain energy and anisotropic index were compared to make this choice. The materials for the matrix and fibers of the selected composite are, respectively, the digital materials FLX9940 and FLX9960 developed by Stratasys. The fiber proportion for the composite is equal to 0.15. The differences between the composite behavior and the AAA tissue are small, with a small difference in the strain energy (0.4%) and a maximum difference of 12.4% in the peak Green strain ratio. This work represents a step forward in the application of 3D printing technology for the manufacturing of AAA phantoms with anisotropic mechanical behavior.

3D Printed Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Phantom for Image Guided Surgical Planning with a Patient Specific Fenestrated Endovascular Graft System.

With training on the patient-specific 3D printed AAA phantom, the clinical team optimized their procedural strategy. Anatomical landmarks and all devices were visible under x-ray during the simulation mimicking the clinical environment. The actual patient procedure went without complications. With advances in 3D printing, fabrication of patient specific AAA phantoms is possible. Simulation with 3D printed phantoms shows potential to inform clinical interventional procedures in addition to CTA diagnostic imaging.

Flow and wall shear stress characterization after endovascular aneurysm repair and endovascular aneurysm sealing in an infrarenal aneurysm model

BackgroundEndovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR) with a modular endograft has become the preferred treatment for abdominal aortic aneurysms. A novel concept is endovascular aneurysm sealing (EVAS), consisting of dual endoframes surrounded by polymer-filled endobags. This dual-lumen configuration is different from a bifurcation with a tapered trajectory of the flow lumen into the two limbs and may induce unfavorable flow conditions. These include low and oscillatory wall shear stress (WSS), linked to atherosclerosis, and high shear rates that may result in thrombosis. An in vitro study was performed to assess the impact of EVAR and EVAS on flow patterns and WSS. MethodsFour abdominal aortic aneurysm phantoms were constructed, including three stented models, to study the influence of the flow divider on flow (Endurant [Medtronic, Minneapolis, Minn], AFX [Endologix, Irvine, Calif], and Nellix [Endologix]). Experimental models were tested under physiologic resting conditions, and flow was visualized with laser particle imaging velocimetry, quantified by shear rate, WSS, and oscillatory shear index (OSI) in the suprarenal aorta, renal artery (RA), and common iliac artery. ResultsWSS and OSI were comparable for all models in the suprarenal aorta. The RA flow profile in the EVAR models was comparable to the control, but a region of lower WSS was observed on the caudal wall compared with the control. The EVAS model showed a stronger jet flow with a higher shear rate in some regions compared with the other models. Small regions of low WSS and high OSI were found near the distal end of all stents in the common iliac artery compared with the control. Maximum shear rates in each region of interest were well below the pathologic threshold for acute thrombosis. ConclusionsThe different stent designs do not influence suprarenal flow. Lower WSS is observed in the caudal wall of the RA after EVAR and a higher shear rate after EVAS. All stented models have a small region of low WSS and high OSI near the distal outflow of the stents.

3D-Printed Tissue-Mimicking Phantoms for Medical Imaging and Computational Validation Applications.

Abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is a permanent, irreversible dilation of the distal region of the aorta. Recent efforts have focused on improved AAA screening and biomechanics-based failure prediction. Idealized and patient-specific AAA phantoms are often employed to validate numerical models and imaging modalities. To produce such phantoms, the investment casting process is frequently used, reconstructing the 3D vessel geometry from computed tomography patient scans. In this study the alternative use of 3D printing to produce phantoms is investigated. The mechanical properties of flexible 3D-printed materials are benchmarked against proven elastomers. We demonstrate the utility of this process with particular application to the emerging imaging modality of ultrasound-based pulse wave imaging, a noninvasive diagnostic methodology being developed to obtain regional vascular wall stiffness properties, differentiating normal and pathologic tissue in vivo. Phantom wall displacements under pulsatile loading conditions were observed, showing good correlation to fluid-structure interaction simulations and regions of peak wall stress predicted by finite element analysis. 3D-printed phantoms show a strong potential to improve medical imaging and computational analysis, potentially helping bridge the gap between experimental and clinical diagnostic tools.

Effects of Intraluminal Thrombus on Patient-Specific Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Hemodynamics via Stereoscopic Particle Image Velocity and Computational Fluid Dynamics Modeling

The pathology of the human abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) and its relationship to the later complication of intraluminal thrombus (ILT) formation remains unclear. The hemodynamics in the diseased abdominal aorta are hypothesized to be a key contributor to the formation and growth of ILT. The objective of this investigation is to establish a reliable 3D flow visualization method with corresponding validation tests with high confidence in order to provide insight into the basic hemodynamic features for a better understanding of hemodynamics in AAA pathology and seek potential treatment for AAA diseases. A stereoscopic particle image velocity (PIV) experiment was conducted using transparent patient-specific experimental AAA models (with and without ILT) at three axial planes. Results show that before ILT formation, a 3D vortex was generated in the AAA phantom. This geometry-related vortex was not observed after the formation of ILT, indicating its possible role in the subsequent appearance of ILT in this patient. It may indicate that a longer residence time of recirculated blood flow in the aortic lumen due to this vortex caused sufficient shear-induced platelet activation to develop ILT and maintain uniform flow conditions. Additionally, two computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modeling codes (Fluent and an in-house cardiovascular CFD code) were compared with the two-dimensional, three-component velocity stereoscopic PIV data. Results showed that correlation coefficients of the out-of-plane velocity data between PIV and both CFD methods are greater than 0.85, demonstrating good quantitative agreement. The stereoscopic PIV study can be utilized as test case templates for ongoing efforts in cardiovascular CFD solver development. Likewise, it is envisaged that the patient-specific data may provide a benchmark for further studying hemodynamics of actual AAA, ILT, and their convolution effects under physiological conditions for clinical applications.

Endoleak Detection with CT Angiography in an Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Phantom: Effect of Tube Energy, Simulated Patient Size, and Physical Properties of Endoleaks

To analyze the detection of endoleaks with low-tube-voltage computed tomographic (CT) angiography. A cylindrical plastic phantom mimicking an aortic aneurysm, containing a stent graft and 36 simulated endoleaks of various diameters, densities, and distances from the graft, was placed into three different water containers corresponding to small, intermediate-sized, and large patients. CT was performed at 80, 100, and 120 kVp, and the volume CT dose index (CTDI(vol)) was noted. Three radiologists independently analyzed the CT images for endoleak localization with diagnostic confidence and for image quality. Analysis of variance was used to compare results and to find parameters that have an effect on endoleak detection. All 6-mm endoleaks were correctly identified at all tube energies except for five endoleaks at 80 kVp in the thick phantom. Observers detected more 4-mm leaks at higher tube voltage in the thick phantom (P < .001) and at 100 kVp compared with 80 kVp in the intermediate phantom (P = .006). Compared with CTDI(vol) at 120 kVp, CTDI(vol) was lower by nearly 50% at 80 kVp in the thin and intermediate phantoms and at 100 kVp in the thick phantom. Endoleak diameter, position, phantom dimension, and tube voltage all had a significant effect on the number of detected leaks (P < .0001). This phantom study suggests that reduced radiation exposure is achievable with CT angiography at 80 kVp in small and intermediate-sized patients and at 100 kVp in large patients, with no increased risk of missing significant endoleaks measuring 6 mm or larger.

Development and Application of an Experimental Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Model

A realistic phantom model of the abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is required for experimental studies of the behaviour and nature of AAA and to validate computational models of wall stress and rupture. This study was part of an MSc project which aimed to develop a suitable elastic AAA phantom. A latex AAA phantom was constructed and used in an in vitro flow model to study whether ultrasound measurements of the maximum diameter, distension and distensibility are predictors of AAA rupture. A multigate Doppler system was found to be capable of providing suitable distension measurements, but measurement of the maximum diameter was more reliable using B-mode imaging. Further work is required to help overcome the limitations of the phantom in accounting for a range of mechanical and geometrical properties, and the pathophysiological remodelling process of real AAAs.