2D Protein Crystals Research Articles

Designed 2D protein crystals as dynamic molecular gatekeepers for a solid-state device

The sensitivity and responsiveness of living cells to environmental changes are enabled by dynamic protein structures, inspiring efforts to construct artificial supramolecular protein assemblies. However, despite their sophisticated structures, designed protein assemblies have yet to be incorporated into macroscale devices for real-life applications. We report a 2D crystalline protein assembly of C98/E57/E66L-rhamnulose-1-phosphate aldolase (CEERhuA) that selectively blocks or passes molecular species when exposed to a chemical trigger. CEERhuA crystals are engineered via cobalt(II) coordination bonds to undergo a coherent conformational change from a closed state (pore dimensions <1 nm) to an ajar state (pore dimensions ~4 nm) when exposed to an HCN(g) trigger. When layered onto a mesoporous silicon (pSi) photonic crystal optical sensor configured to detect HCN(g), the 2D CEERhuA crystal layer effectively blocks interferents that would otherwise result in a false positive signal. The 2D CEERhuA crystal layer opens in selective response to low-ppm levels of HCN(g), allowing analyte penetration into the pSi sensor layer for detection. These findings illustrate that designed protein assemblies can function as dynamic components of solid-state devices in non-aqueous environments.

Assembly dynamics and structure of an aegerolysin, ostreolysin A6

Ostreolysin A6 (OlyA6) is an oyster mushroom-derived membrane-binding protein that, upon recruitment of its partner protein, pleurotolysin B, forms a cytolytic membrane pore complex. OlyA6 itself is not cytolytic but has been reported to exhibit pro-apoptotic activities in cell culture. Here we report the formation dynamics and the structure of OlyA6 assembly on a lipid membrane containing an OlyA6 high-affinity receptor, ceramide phosphoethanolamine, and cholesterol. High-speed atomic force microscopy revealed the reorganization of OlyA6 dimers from initial random surface coverage to 2D protein crystals composed of hexameric OlyA6 repeat units. Crystal growth took place predominantly in the longitudinal direction by the association of OlyA6 dimers, forming a hexameric unit cell. Molecular-level examination of the OlyA6 crystal elucidated the arrangement of dimers within the unit cell and the structure of the dimer that recruits pleurotolysin B for pore formation.

Unraveling Molecular Dynamics with High-Speed Video-Rate Atomic Force Microscopy

Abstract:This article describes the application of the fastest commercially available video-rate atomic force microscope (AFM) for studying the molecular dynamics of biological samples with a temporal resolution reaching 20 ms per frame. High-speed AFM was used for monitoring the kinetics of the temperature-induced ripple phase transition in supported lipid bilayers, DNA origami streptavidin-biotin binding, thermodynamic rehybridization of DNA, collagen type I fibrillogenesis, and the mobile annexin V trimer dynamics in 2D protein crystals. With no further need for sample processing, the applied method offers a breakthrough in molecular and sample dynamics measurements by enabling the real-time visualization of molecular processes and structural transitions at near-native conditions.

Sample Preparation and Data Collection for Electron Crystallographic Studies on Membrane Protein Structures and Lipid-Protein Interaction.

Electron crystallography is a unique tool to study membrane protein structures and lipid-protein interactions in their native-like environments. Two-dimensional (2D) protein crystallization enables the lipids immobilized by the proteins, and the generated high-resolution density map allows us to model the atomic coordinates of the surrounding lipids to study lipid-protein interaction. This protocol describes the sample preparation for electron crystallographic studies, including back-injection method and carbon sandwich method. The protocols of data collection for electron crystallography, including electron imaging and diffraction, of the 2D membrane crystal will be followed.

Enzyme-Directed Functionalization of Designed, Two-Dimensional Protein Lattices.

The design and construction of crystalline protein arrays to selectively assemble ordered nanoscale materials have potential applications in sensing, catalysis, and medicine. Whereas numerous designs have been implemented for the bottom-up construction of protein assemblies, the generation of artificial functional materials has been relatively unexplored. Enzyme-directed post-translational modifications are responsible for the functional diversity of the proteome and, thus, could be harnessed to selectively modify artificial protein assemblies. In this study, we describe the use of phosphopantetheinyl transferases (PPTases), a class of enzymes that covalently modify proteins using coenzyme A (CoA), to site-selectively tailor the surface of designed, two-dimensional (2D) protein crystals. We demonstrate that a short peptide (ybbR) or a molecular tag (CoA) can be covalently tethered to 2D arrays to enable enzymatic functionalization using Sfp PPTase. The site-specific modification of two different protein array platforms is facilitated by PPTases to afford both small molecule- and protein-functionalized surfaces with no loss of crystalline order. This work highlights the potential for chemoenzymatic modification of large protein surfaces toward the generation of sophisticated protein platforms reminiscent of the complex landscape of cell surfaces.

Multi-Step 2D Protein Crystallization via Structural Changes within an Ordered Lattice

Multi-Step 2D Protein Crystallization via Structural Changes within an Ordered Lattice

Bond selection during protein crystallization: Crystal shapes

The so‐called bond selection mechanism, BSM (C.N. Nanev, Progress in Crystal Growth and Characterization of Materials, 59, 133–169, 2013) allows explaining a set of traits in both protein crystal nucleation and growth processes. BSM explanatory and predictive power are enhanced now, when intra‐crystalline repulsive interactions are assumed to act in parallel with the attractive forces, the former arising due to protein surface patch‐to‐patch incompatibility. Shapes of 1D and 2D protein crystals are considered from such a perspective. Using BSM the strong directional kinetic anisotropy in the edge growth rates of 2D protein crystals is tackled. The shapes of near‐critically sized apoferritin crystals and of experimentally grown 3D apoferritin crystals are considered.

Flow-induced 2D protein crystallization: characterization of the coupled interfacial and bulk flows.

Two-dimensional crystallization of the protein streptavidin, crystallizing below a biotinylated lipid film spread on a quiescent air-water interface is a well studied phenomenon. More recently, 2D crystallization induced by a shearing interfacial flow has been observed at film surface pressures significantly lower than those required in a quiescent system. Here, we quantify the interfacial and bulk flow associated with 2D protein crystallization through numerical modeling of the flow along with a Newtonian surface model. Experiments were conducted over a wide range of conditions resulting in a state diagram delineating the flow strength required to induce crystals for various surface pressures. Through measurements of the velocity profile at the air-water interface, we found that even in the cases where crystals are formed, the macroscopic flow at the interface is well described by the Newtonian model. However, the results show that even in the absence of any protein in the system, the viscous response of the biotinylated lipid film is complicated and strongly dependent on the strength of the flow. This observation suggests that the insoluble lipid film plays a key role in flow-induced 2D protein crystallization.

Research at the NSF STC for Biology with X-ray lasers

"The NSF BioXFEL Science and Technology Center (STC) is a new consortium of six research campuses devoted to the application of x-ray free-electron lasers (XFELs) to structural biology. Over the last four years a variety of approaches have been made to the observation of protein structure and dynamics for various classes of proteins. The Linac Coherent Light source at SLAC, the first hard-Xray EXFEL, provides intense coherent hard X-ray pulses at 120 Hz which vaporize protein when focussed to a sub-micron beam. Atomic-resolution Bragg diffraction patterns are nevertheless obtained using 50 fs pulses prior to the onset of significant damage, in this ""diffract-then-destroy"" mode, which outruns radiation damage. This use of short pulses instead of freezing samples to reduce radiation damage therefore opens the way to the study of protein dynamics at room temperature in a native environment. I'll review the work of several groups using a range of approaches to different types of sample, including the following: 1. Differences between the frozen sychrotron structure of GPCR proteins and the RT XFEL structure [1]. 2. Pump-probe dynamic structures in Photosynthesis [2]. 3. XFEL study of 2D protein crystals [3]. 4. Prospects for improved resolution in XFEL imaging from single particles such as viruses, where patterns can be obtained from a single virus. 5. New ideas - the Lipid Cubic Phase injector (which allows protein nanocrystals to be studied also at sychrotrons) [4], prospects for fast Laue diffraction using coherent attosecond X-ray lasers, ab-initio phasing [5], the use of angular correlation functions for analysis of fast solution scattering, and two-color opportunites for serial femtosecond crystallography (SFX). See [6] for a recent review of the field. 1. W.Liu et al Science 342, 1521 (2013) 2. A.Aquila et al Optics Express 20, 2706 (2012) 3. M.Frank et al IUCrJ (2014) In press. 4. U.Weierstall et al Nature Comms. (2014) In press. 5. J. Spence et al Optics Express 19, 2866 (2011). 6. J. Spence et al Rep. Prog. Phys. 75, 102601 (2012)."

Two-dimensional (2D) crystallization of engineered proteins: A review

Protein¢ two-dimensional (2D) crystallization denotes the supreme degree of its ordering, thus 2D protein crystals can be applied in diverse fields ranging from structural biology to materials science with unique performances. To date, 2D crystallization of proteins, especially engineered proteins, is emerging as a powerful tool for bottom-up approaches to the nanofabrication of functional structures. However, till now there is still lack of general method of forming 2D crystals of proteins due to limited understanding of the 2D crystallization process, and the self-assembly of 2D protein crystals often suffers from point defects and grain boundaries resulting from homogeneous nucleation and uncontrollable crystal growth. In this review, we will introduce some aspects of 2D protein crystallization, including key approaches to growing 2D protein crystals and their potential applications in various fields. Key words: Protein, two-dimensional (2D) crystallization, self-assembly, applications.

Biotemplated Synthesis of Metallic Nanoclusters Organized in Tunable Two-Dimensional Superlattices

Biotemplating has emerged as a very promising approach to produce inorganic materials organized into well-defined architectures. In this paper, we combined both biochemistry and physical approaches to control the size and two-dimensional (2D) organization of metallic nanoparticles (NPs). We used self-assembled Tomato Bushy Stunt Virus and streptavidin 2D crystals as biotemplates for the growth of silver NPs by thermal evaporation. On the one hand, the tunable arrangement of the virus superlattices offers an unprecedented opportunity to control the NPs organization. On the other hand, 2D protein crystals allow the formation of perfectly periodic NP arrays, with a sub-10 nm lattice parameter and a very narrow NPs size distribution. These two UHV-compatible biotemplates allow the formation of organized NPs assemblies over long distance, which are stable over time.

Automatic recovery of missing amplitudes and phases in tilt-limited electron crystallography of two-dimensional crystals

Electron crystallography of 2D protein crystals provides a powerful tool for the determination of membrane protein structure. In this method, data is acquired in the Fourier domain as randomly sampled, uncoupled, amplitudes and phases. Due to physical constraints on specimen tilting, those Fourier data show a vast un-sampled "missing cone" of information, producing resolution loss in the direction perpendicular to the membrane plane. Based on the flexible language of projection onto sets, we provide a full solution for these problems with a projective constraint optimization algorithm that, for sufficiently oversampled data, produces complete recovery of unmeasured data in the missing cone. We apply this method to an experimental data set of Bacteriorhodopsin and show that, in addition to producing superior results compared to traditional reconstruction methods, full, reproducible, recovery of the missing cone from noisy data is possible. Finally, we present an automatic implementation of the refinement routine as open source, freely distributed, software that will be included in our 2dx software package.

SONICC: A Novel Nonlinear Optical Detection Technique for 2D Celluar Crystallography

2D crystallization is one of the most powerful methods to study the structure and function of membrane proteins in their native lipid bilayer environment, yet obtaining high resolution diffraction protein crystals is the most difficult and time consuming step. Traditional techniques for protein crystal detection mostly depend on optical microscopy and the birefringence property of crystals. This situation becomes even more difficult for 2D crystallization because a negative stain check on electron microscope is required which makes it nearly impossible for high-throughput screening. Recently, UV spectroscopy has also been applied to distinguish protein crystals from salt ones. However, all these methods has detection limit which depends on the crystal size and crystallization condition. The Second Order Nonlinear Imaging of Chiral Crystals (SONICC) therefore is developed to overcome this difficulty. SONICC could selectively detect large or small non-centrosymmetric 2D and 3D protein crystals (<1um) with high signal noise ratio. Using this method, we successfully detected purple membrane (ie 2-D crystal of bacteriohrodopsin). We could even detect the crystal patch in a single living H. Salinarium R1 cell. By removing retinals from purple membrane, the signal dramatically decreased (∼5 fold) due to the distortion of the crystalline order and the absence of pigment. Considering the difficulty of growing 2D membrane crystals, SONICC not only solved the current detection limitation, but also provided a new opportunity for direct detection membrane crystals in situ formed naturally or artificially by overexpression.

High-Affinity Tags Fused to S-Layer Proteins Probed by Atomic Force Microscopy

Two-dimensional, crystalline bacterial cell surface layers, termed S-layers, are one of the most commonly observed cell surface structures of prokaryotic organisms. In the present study, genetically modified S-layer protein SbpA of Bacillus sphaericus CCM 2177 carrying the short affinity peptide Strep-tag I or Strep-tag II at the C terminus was used to generate a 2D crystalline monomolecular protein lattice on a silicon surface. Because of the genetic modification, the 2D crystals were addressable via Strep-tag through streptavidin molecules. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to investigate the topography of the single-molecules array and the functionality of the fused Strep-tags. In high-resolution imaging under near-physiological conditions, structural details such as protein alignment and spacing were resolved. By applying molecular recognition force microscopy, the Strep-tag moieties were proven to be fully functional and accessible. For this purpose, streptavidin molecules were tethered to AFM tips via approximately 8-nm-long flexible polyethylene glycol (PEG) linkers. These functionalized tips showed specific interactions with 2D protein crystals containing either the Strep-tag I or Strep-tag II, with similar energetic and kinetic behavior in both cases.

Towards automated screening of two-dimensional crystals

Screening trials to determine the presence of two-dimensional (2D) protein crystals suitable for three-dimensional structure determination using electron crystallography is a very labor-intensive process. Methods compatible with fully automated screening have been developed for the process of crystal production by dialysis and for producing negatively stained grids of the resulting trials. Further automation via robotic handling of the EM grids, and semi-automated transmission electron microscopic imaging and evaluation of the trial grids is also possible. We, and others, have developed working prototypes for several of these tools and tested and evaluated them in a simple screen of 24 crystallization conditions. While further development of these tools is certainly required for a turn-key system, the goal of fully automated screening appears to be within reach.

Protein Crystallization at the Air/Water Interface Induced by Shearing Bulk Flow

We have observed 2D protein crystallization under conditions where in the absence of flow, crystallization fails to occur. Even under conditions where crystallization does occur in quiescent systems, we have found that flow can accelerate the crystallization process. By interrogating the flow responsible for this enhanced crystallization, we have correlated the enhancement with large shear in the plane of the interface. Some possible mechanisms for why interfacial shear can enhance the crystallization process are proposed.

Two-dimensional structure in a generic model of triangular proteins and protein trimers

Motivated by the diversity and complexity of two-dimensional (2D) crystals formed by triangular proteins and protein trimers, we have investigated the structures and phase behavior of hard-disk trimers. In order to mimic specific binding interactions, each trimer possesses an "attractive" disk which can interact with similar disks on other trimers via an attractive square-well potential. At low density and low temperature, the fluid phase mainly consists of tetramers, pentamers, or hexamers. Hexamers provide the structural motif for a high-density, low-temperature periodic solid phase, but we also identify a metastable periodic structure based on a tetramer motif. At high density there is a transition between orientationally ordered and disordered solid phases. The connections between simulated structures and those of 2D protein crystals--as seen in electron microscopy--are briefly discussed.

Projection structure of the human copper transporter CTR1 at 6-Å resolution reveals a compact trimer with a novel channel-like architecture

Human CTR1 is a high-affinity copper transporter that also mediates the uptake of the anticancer drug cisplatin by largely unknown transport mechanisms. Here we report the 6-A projection structure obtained for human CTR1 by using electron crystallography of 2D protein crystals in a native phospholipid bilayer. The projection of CTR1 reveals a symmetrical trimer that is <40 A wide. Notably, the center threefold axis of each trimer forms a region of very low electron density likely to be involved in copper translocation. The formation of a putative pore for metal ions at the interface of three identical subunits deviates from the structural design of typical primary and secondary active transporters and reveals that copper uptake transporters have a novel architecture that is structurally more closely related to channel proteins.

Sample preparation procedures for biological atomic force microscopy

Since the late 1980s, atomic force microscopy (AFM) has been increasingly used in biological sciences and it is now established as a versatile tool to address the structure, properties and functions of biological specimens. AFM is unique in that it provides three-dimensional images of biological structures, including biomolecules, lipid films, 2D protein crystals and cells, under physiological conditions and with unprecedented resolution. A crucial prerequisite for successful, reliable biological AFM is that the samples need to be well attached to a solid substrate using appropriate, nondestructive methods. In this review, we discuss common techniques for immobilizing biological specimens for AFM studies.

Recrystallization of Bacterial S‐Layers on Flat Polyelectrolyte Surfaces and Hollow Polyelectrolyte Capsules

Polyelectrolyte multilayer (PE) deposition and S-layer technology have been combined to make novel robust biomimetic surfaces and membranes. Isolated subunits of the bacterial cell surface layer from Bacillus sphaericus CCM2177 SbpA was self-assembled on PE multilayer supports, with the composition of the multilayer playing a crucial role in determining the structure of the resulting supported protein layers. Flat substrates were studied using atomic force microscopy and neutron reflectometry; protein on suitable PE combinations showed a crystalline structure with lattice constants equal to those found in vivo on bacterial surfaces. The mechanical stability of the S-layer is higher when recrystallized on PEs than directly on silicon supports. The recrystallization process was subsequently used to coat colloidal particles, permitting the determination of zeta potentials before and after coating. Hollow capsules could also be coated in the same way, as proven by various techniques. Our results suggest that electrostatic interactions via divalent cations are important for the assembly process. The results also demonstrate that the versatility of the PE multilayer membranes can be successfully combined with the well-defined surface chemistry and structure of 2D protein crystals.