Sort by
Republican violence in Northern Ireland: a comparative case study of County Tyrone

ABSTRACT Ireland has a long history of political violence emanating from Irish republicans’ desire to be free from British rule. The focus of this article is on the use of such political violence in one particular area, namely County Tyrone using a comparative analysis to interrogate republican violence during the Anglo-Irish War (1919–1921) and the period known as the Troubles (1969–1997). Drawing upon archival sources, interviews with ex-security force members and republicans with direct experience of the conflict in County Tyrone and the extant literature, the article examines whether successive generations of republicans drew upon or deviated from established templates of political violence. In doing so, it considers the practical and lethal effect of the exchange of memories, grievance, justifications, tactics and patterns of past episodes of violence. By comparing and analysing differences in the political violence employed by successive generations of republicans, similar strategies and tactics are identified. These include the use of guerrilla warfare, attacks on security forces, the local economy and infrastructure, the creation of security force-free zones and the fostering of sectarian and representative violence. The research has contemporary relevance to improve our understanding, challenge misinterpretations and myths of past events and legacies in County Tyrone.

Open Access
Relevant
Understanding and addressing the risk of disguised compliance in CVE programming

ABSTRACT Disguised compliance refers to individuals participating in programmes to counter violent extremism (CVE), deceiving, and manipulating intervention staff about the degree to which they are deradicalised and disengaged. It is a particular challenge that confronts CVE case managed programmes. Recent cases of individuals committing terrorist acts who have participated in CVE interventions have demonstrated the risks that disguised compliance presents. However disguised compliance is a common challenge confronting behavioural change programmes. This paper reports results from interviews with practitioners directly involved in the delivery of CVE interventions about their understandings of disguised compliance, its occurrence, identification, and management. The results indicate that the occurrence of disguised compliance is highly contextual and shaped by individual motivations and capacities, with it comprising a spectrum of behaviours. Interviewees emphasised that the detection of disguised compliance requires a mix of strategies and approaches, and that these should not undermine rapport and trust building with a client. The implications of the results for policy and practice are considered including the type of indicators that constitute authentic indicators of behavioural and cognitive change.

Open Access
Relevant