What difficulties arise when implementing large-scale pedagogical reforms?
Answer from top 10 papers
The main challenges of pedagogical reforms on a large scale include the implementation of various agile frameworks in educational settings, which can present numerous difficulties (Valero, 2022). Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) struggle with updating curricula and pedagogical approaches due to rapid knowledge and technological advancements, with Open Educational Resources (OER) posing both a solution and a challenge (Dumbraveanu, 2018). Additionally, English language teaching (ELT) pedagogical reforms, while perceived positively, often do not translate into practice due to a mismatch between teachers' understanding and their actual practices, influenced by both internal and external factors (Rajaee et al., 2013).
Specific to science education, the integration of higher order thinking (HOT) into curricula faces challenges such as content prioritization over thinking goals and the development of educators' professional knowledge (Zohar, 2013). The slow shift from teacher-centered to student-centered learning in European higher education is another significant barrier, hindered by faculty and student resistance (Cunha et al., 2024). Instructional Design (ID) methodologies encounter institutional resistance and a lack of training for instructional designers (Alicia, 2024).
In the context of environmental education, the implementation of pollution prevention instruments in Indonesia is impeded by regulatory, enforcement, and capacity challenges (Conboy & Carroll, 2019). Engineering education reforms aimed at improving graduate employability face difficulties due to entrenched traditional practices and the need for new teaching techniques (Ismajli, 2018). Kosovo's curricular reforms in the Languages and Communication area are challenged by insufficient curriculum knowledge and inadequate teacher cooperation (Hoidn, 2016). Lastly, the implementation of outcome-based education (OBE) is criticized for its practical execution challenges, particularly in engineering education (Thanh & Le, 2021).
In summary, large-scale pedagogical reforms are fraught with challenges that span from the adoption of new frameworks and methodologies to resistance from educators and institutions. These challenges are compounded by the need to update educational content rapidly, ensure the quality of resources, and align teaching practices with reform values. Addressing these issues requires a multifaceted approach that includes legislative reforms, professional development, and a shift in educational culture to facilitate the successful implementation of pedagogical reforms (Alicia, 2024; Conboy & Carroll, 2019; Cunha et al., 2024; Dumbraveanu, 2018; Hoidn, 2016; Ismajli, 2018; Rajaee et al., 2013; Thanh & Le, 2021; Valero, 2022; Zohar, 2013).
Source Papers