What difficulties arise when implementing large-scale pedagogical reforms?

Answer from top 10 papers

The main challenges of pedagogical reforms on a large scale include the implementation of various agile frameworks in educational settings, which can present numerous difficulties (Valero, 2022). Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) struggle with updating curricula and pedagogical approaches due to rapid knowledge and technological advancements, with Open Educational Resources (OER) posing both a solution and a challenge (Dumbraveanu, 2018). Additionally, English language teaching (ELT) pedagogical reforms, while perceived positively, often do not translate into practice due to a mismatch between teachers' understanding and their actual practices, influenced by both internal and external factors (Rajaee et al., 2013).
Specific to science education, the integration of higher order thinking (HOT) into curricula faces challenges such as content prioritization over thinking goals and the development of educators' professional knowledge (Zohar, 2013). The slow shift from teacher-centered to student-centered learning in European higher education is another significant barrier, hindered by faculty and student resistance (Cunha et al., 2024). Instructional Design (ID) methodologies encounter institutional resistance and a lack of training for instructional designers (Alicia, 2024).
In the context of environmental education, the implementation of pollution prevention instruments in Indonesia is impeded by regulatory, enforcement, and capacity challenges (Conboy & Carroll, 2019). Engineering education reforms aimed at improving graduate employability face difficulties due to entrenched traditional practices and the need for new teaching techniques (Ismajli, 2018). Kosovo's curricular reforms in the Languages and Communication area are challenged by insufficient curriculum knowledge and inadequate teacher cooperation (Hoidn, 2016). Lastly, the implementation of outcome-based education (OBE) is criticized for its practical execution challenges, particularly in engineering education (Thanh & Le, 2021).
In summary, large-scale pedagogical reforms are fraught with challenges that span from the adoption of new frameworks and methodologies to resistance from educators and institutions. These challenges are compounded by the need to update educational content rapidly, ensure the quality of resources, and align teaching practices with reform values. Addressing these issues requires a multifaceted approach that includes legislative reforms, professional development, and a shift in educational culture to facilitate the successful implementation of pedagogical reforms (Alicia, 2024; Conboy & Carroll, 2019; Cunha et al., 2024; Dumbraveanu, 2018; Hoidn, 2016; Ismajli, 2018; Rajaee et al., 2013; Thanh & Le, 2021; Valero, 2022; Zohar, 2013).

Source Papers

Challenges, difficulties and barriers for engineering higher education

Higher education in general, and in engineering higher education in particular, is constantly under pressure to introduce reforms that improve the employability of graduates. Among the most common claims is the development of a more active and competency-based teaching oriented to the development of professional and personal skills. The university institution responds to these claims, sometimes in a timid way, but others by embarking on great transformation projects. A good example of this is the project to build the European Higher Education Area.However, the challenge of developing a more active and competency-based teaching faces numerous difficulties and barriers because many of the necessary changes are in sharp contrast with a status quo that has been consolidated over centuries. Difficulties and barriers include a lack of deep understanding (and even lack of acceptance) of some of the implications of the challenges we are facing, the learning of new techniques and tools that are not easy to use or unsuitable organizational structures.In this paper, we explore the nature of some of the challenges and review the difficulties and barriers most mentioned most often by those who dare to try. Anyone who wants to address the challenges or has a responsibility to facilitate changes should be aware of all these difficulties and barriers.

Read full abstract
Open Access
Challenges in wide scale implementation efforts to foster higher order thinking (HOT) in science education across a whole school system

This study explores the challenges involved in scaling up projects and in implementing policies across the whole school system in the area of teaching higher order thinking (HOT) in Israeli science classrooms. Eight semi-structured individual interviews were conducted with science education experts who hold leading positions pertaining to learning and instruction on the state level of the following school subjects: elementary and junior- high school science and technology; high-school physics; high school chemistry; and high school biology. Some of the challenges that the interviews revealed are common to many types of educational change processes. The interviews also revealed several challenges which are more specific to the educational endeavor of teaching HOT according to the infusion approach across large numbers of classrooms: challenges involved in weaving HOT into multiple, varied, specific science contents; challenges involved in planning a reasonable and coherent developmental sequence of thinking goals; the fact that content goals tend to have priority over thinking goals and thus to disperse of the latter in policy documents and in implementation processes; and finally, the considerable challenges (pedagogical and organizational) involved in developing educators’ sound and deep professional knowledge in the area of teaching HOT and metacognition on a large, nation-wide scale. The data shows that wide-scale implementation of thinking in Israeli science classrooms often develops as an evolutionary rather than as a revolutionary process. The implications for designing large scale implementation programs aimed at fostering students’ reasoning are discussed.

Read full abstract
Implementation of Environmental Pollution and Damage Prevention Instruments in Indonesia: Issues and Challenges

This paper delves into the implementation of environmental pollution and damage prevention instruments in Indonesia, highlighting the inherent issues and challenges. It scrutinizes the efficacy of existing measures in curbing environmental degradation and explores the obstacles hindering their successful execution. The findings underscore a myriad of challenges confronting the implementation process, ranging from regulatory gaps and enforcement deficiencies to institutional capacity constraints. Despite the presence of legislation aimed at safeguarding the environment, enforcement mechanisms often fall short due to inadequate resources, corruption, and lack of coordination among relevant stakeholders. Additionally, the complexity of environmental issues, coupled with rapid industrialization and urbanization, exacerbates the challenges faced in mitigating pollution and preserving natural resources. Addressing these challenges necessitates a multi-faceted approach that encompasses legislative reforms, capacity building initiatives, and enhanced collaboration between government agencies, civil society, and the private sector. Strengthening regulatory frameworks, improving monitoring and enforcement mechanisms, and promoting public awareness are crucial steps towards achieving sustainable environmental management in Indonesia. Moreover, integrating environmental considerations into broader policy agendas and fostering international cooperation are vital for addressing cross-border environmental challenges and ensuring long-term environmental sustainability. In conclusion, while Indonesia has made strides in formulating environmental policies, effective implementation remains a pressing issue. By identifying and addressing the challenges impeding the execution of pollution prevention instruments, Indonesia can bolster its environmental governance framework and pave the way for a greener and more sustainable future.

Read full abstract
Open Access
Challenges for Achieving Learning Outcomes of Languages and Communication Curriculum Area in Primary Education in Kosovo

The education system in Kosovo is in the phase of implementing the curricular reforms which aim at changing the teaching and learning approach. The new curriculum is a necessary innovation in pre-university education system and it has already started to be implemented in all schools in Kosovo, faces many difficulties, especially in achieving learning outcomes in some curricular areas. This research aims at analyzing the obstacles and challenges in achieving results in the Languages and Communication area and to recommend appropriate ways to facilitate its implementation. The representative group consists 75 teachers who work in five primary schools in Kosovo while the data is collected through a questionnaire for teachers. The research findings show that most teachers have sufficient knowledge and have positive attitude towards new curriculum. Challenges arising from this process are: insufficient knowledge of the new curriculum, inadequate cooperation among the teachers, lack of ICT and supporting materials in schools, difficulties in planning the learning results, and non-regular monitoring of teachers, textbook compliance with the principles and requirements of the new curriculum The development of competences and the improvement of results in this area can be achieved through changing educational policies as well as monitoring and accountability of teachers.

Read full abstract
Open Access
ELT pedagogical reforms: EFL high-school teachers’ perceptions and responses

Educational change, particularly English language teaching (ELT) pedagogical reforms, has received much attention from language researchers in the era of globalization and internationalization. Despite the recognition of problems in implementation, ELT pedagogical reforms have been widely introduced and adopted in schools all over the world, particularly in Vietnam. What English teachers’ overall perceptions, understanding, and practices are, and what influential factors on response to ELT pedagogical reforms are, the major foci in this study. The data were collected from 102 teachers of English as a Foreign Language (EFL) in different high-schools (grades 10, 11 and 12) in the Mekong Delta. The results from the questionnaire and interview revealed that the teachers highly perceived ELT pedagogical reforms. Moreover, the results also showed that the teachers well understood the values of ELT pedagogical reforms. However, the findings also showed that the teacher’s practices of ELT pedagogical reforms were above average and that their practices did not match with their understanding of the values of ELT pedagogical reforms. Besides that, from the findings, the EFL high-school teachers were relative strongly influenced, both the internal and external factors; the main influential factors are students’ learning outcomes after implementing ELT pedagogical reforms, teachers’ attitudes towards the adoption of these reforms, and teachers’ self-efficacy on their teaching. Moreover, the study contributed an interesting finding to the literature that teaching and learning culture is a factor that influenced teachers’ responses. Based on these findings, implications were made for enhancing teachers’ teaching practices in response to ELT pedagogical...

Read full abstract
Open Access