How can we assess the validity of will notes written by martyr soldiers?
Answer from top 10 papers
Assessing the validity of will notes, particularly those of martyr soldiers, requires a multifaceted approach that considers content validity, authenticity, and the psychological state of the individual at the time of writing. Content validity ensures that the will encompasses the soldier's intentions and desires, reflecting their true wishes (Aandstad et al., 2014). Authenticity is crucial, as it pertains to the genuineness of the document and whether it represents an honest self-expression, which is particularly important in the context of a soldier's final testament (Bryan et al., 2019; Vodanovic, 2023).
Contradictions may arise when considering the authenticity of such personal documents, especially given the extreme stressors soldiers face (Shannon & Hambacher, 2015). The concept of "ground truth" as discussed in Reason (2017), which refers to the authentic experiences of soldiers, can be applied to the assessment of will notes. The will must be seen as a product of the soldier's lived experience and not merely a formal requirement. Additionally, the psychological state of the soldier, as indicated by the Suicide Cognitions Scale (SCS), can influence the validity of the will, as it may reflect a transient mental state rather than a considered and enduring intention (Faridi et al., 2021).
In summary, the validity of will notes of martyr soldiers can be assessed through a careful examination of content validity, ensuring that the will accurately reflects the soldier's intentions. Authenticity must be established to confirm that the will is a genuine expression of the soldier's self, and psychological assessments may be necessary to understand the state of mind at the time of writing. These factors together provide a comprehensive approach to validating the will notes of soldiers who have made the ultimate sacrifice (Aandstad et al., 2014; Bryan et al., 2019; Faridi et al., 2021; Reason, 2017; Shannon & Hambacher, 2015; Vodanovic, 2023).
Source Papers