WTP6.4 Influence of Annual Record of Competence Progression panel profile on Differential Attainment

Abstract

Abstract Introduction Differential Attainment (DA) refers to divergent achievements when related to protected traits. Annual Review of Competency Progression (ARCP) panels play a key role which compositions should reflect, yet no guidance exists on panel profile related to protected traits. This study aimed to evaluate the influence of panel profile on DA. Methods Anonymised ARCPs numbering 1090 in a UK Statutory Education Body (SEB) were examined and primary effect measure was ARCP Outcome (ARCPO) with satisfactory ARCPO classified as 1, 2 or 6, and unsatisfactory as 3 or 4. Results Satisfactory ARCPOs numbered 1005 and unsatisfactory 85. Median panel number was 7 (range 1-15, p<0.001). Median female percentage consultant representation was 18.2% (0% (Urology, Plastic & Paediatric Surgery) to 40% (Core Surgery) and median ethnicity (BME) consultant representation 14.3% (0% (Vascular & Neurosurgery) to 80% (Cardiothoracic Surgery). Multivariable analysis revealed: Trainee seniority (OR 0.800, p<0.001), SAC Liaison Member gender (OR 0.720, p=0.013) and Panel gender balance (N ARCP panel females, OR 10.695, p=0.003) to be independently associated with adverse ARCPO. Discussion Important two to five-fold variance in ARCP panels were found related to gender and ethnicity profile respectively with apparent significant impact on DA.