Wittgenstein's New Way of Talking to Himself

Abstract

AbstractA lack of consensus persists as to whom exactly the dialogues of Wittgenstein'sPhilosophical Investigationsare between: Wittgenstein and an interlocutor? Or perhaps a variety of interlocutors, none of whom can be identified with Wittgenstein himself? I argue here that this lack of consensus is possibly due to an ambiguity in the ordinary concept of “talking to oneself,” and that a new concept of “talking to oneself” appropriate to Wittgenstein's dialogues is needed to properly understand them. Wittgenstein is talking to himself—but he is doing so in the way we talk to other people.