Windowed Fourier transform and cross-correlation algorithms for molecular tagging velocimetry

Abstract

Simulated and experimental molecular tagging velocimetry (MTV) images have been analyzed with a technique commonly used to process grid images on surfaces, the windowed Fourier transform with local spectrum analysis (WFT-LSA). A systematic synthetic image study of the modulation transfer function (MTF) and error tendencies of the WFT-LSA was performed and compared with a PIV-style cross-correlation algorithm to see if advanced strategies such as iterative image deformation can improve analysis of gridded images with high noise levels. Testing of single-pass algorithms showed that in typical MTV images, the WFT-LSA yields significantly lower bias errors than cross-correlation (CC) at displacements greater than 1 pixel but slightly higher random error at all displacements and image conditions. Analysis of the MTF shows that CC provided better resolution of spatial fluctuations than the WFT-LSA in many combinations of grid size and interrogation window. Tests of image deformation algorithms showed that the gap in performance between CC and WFT-LSA is maintained even as both methods improve. Additionally, WFT-LSA and CC methods are applied to real MTV experiments in high-speed gas jet flows. A preliminary analysis of phosphorescence lifetime provided by acetone vapor excited at 266 nm is used for assessing the required gas speeds for making MTV application feasible. The application of WFT-LSA to real MTV images demonstrates the ability of the algorithm to handle further real-world effects that could not be considered in the synthetic image analysis, like reduced signal-to-noise ratio and non-uniform intensity of the tagging grid across the image introduced by the actual laser beam energy distribution. With experimental images, CC is more accurate with shear flows but less robust to high noise levels than WFT-LSA, as predicted by the synthetic image analysis.