Why is brood reduction in Florida scrub-jays higher in suburban than in wildland habitats?

Abstract

In a population of Florida scrub-jays, Aphelocoma coerulescens (Bosc, 1795), in a suburban scrub habitat, partial brood loss is much more common (averaging about 30% of nestlings from successful nests) than in a natural habitat (averaging about 5%). We hypothesized that this partial brood loss was attributable to starvation of last-hatched nestlings (i.e., brood reduction), and that large differences in partial brood loss were caused by differences in arthropod food abundance between the two sites. To test these hypotheses, we closely monitored nests in suburban scrub in 1999 and performed arthropod surveys and focal-nest observations in both habitats in 1998 and 1999. In suburban scrub, later hatched nestlings were three times more likely to die before fledging than earlier hatched nestlings, suggesting that brood reduction occurred. In both years, arthropod abundance in the suburban scrub was less than half that of the natural scrub. However, patterns of food delivery by parents were not significantly different between sites, suggesting that lower food abundance does not in itself explain higher partial brood loss in suburban habitat. Differences in the number of helpers, a greater degree of hatching asynchrony or the delivery of lower quality food throughout the nestling period may increase the probability that later hatched nestlings starve in suburban scrub.