Which Surgical Technique for Liver Resection is Favourable in Patients with Colorectal Liver Metastases?

Abstract

Abstract Background The liver is the most common metastatic site after curative treatment for colorectal cancer (CRC). Around 50% of all patients with CRC will develop colorectal liver metastases (CRLM). Liver resection (LR) represents a curative treatment option. Benefits of anatomic (ALR) versus non-anatomic liver resection (NALR) show a lack of consistent evidence. While ALR seems to be associated with a higher postoperative complication rate, NALR could lead to more recurrences. Aims We investigated complication and survival rates of patients with CRLM after both resection types. Methods This is a multicentre cohort study using retrospectively and prospectively collected data. All patients undergoing LR for CRLM between 2009 and 2020 from 3 specialised centres in Switzerland and Germany were included. Complication and survival rates after ALR versus NALR were analysed using uni- and multivariate Cox regression models. Results 624 patients were included. Median follow-up time was 25.49 months. In 292/624 patients (47%) ALR was performed, while 53% underwent NALR. Complications according to the Clavien-Dindo classification have been observed significantly more often in the ALR group (p=0.001). Especially severe complications grade III and IV have been more present after ALR (36/292 vs. 26/332 and 13/292 vs. 11/332, respectively). Both, length of ICU and postoperative hospital stay have been significantly longer in the ALR group (p<0.001 each). The uni- and multivariate models have shown no significant differences in overall survival (OS) and recurrence free survival rates (RFS) between both groups (for OS adjusted HR of 0.84 (95% CI 0.59 - 1.21; p=0.35) and for RFS adjusted HR 0.92 (95% CI 0.69 - 1.22, p=0.56)). Conclusion This multicentre prospective study investigating ALR versus NALR for CRLM has shown no significant differences in OS and RFS. However, postoperative complications have been reported significantly more often after ALR. NALR seems to be the better choice for patients with CRLM undergoing LR.