Which Dimensions of Social Responsibility Concern Financial Investors?

Abstract

Social and environmental ratings provided by social rating agencies are multidimensional. Using the six sub-ratings provided by the Vigeo rating agency, we perform a principal component analysis and we highlight three main socially responsible (SR) dimensions related to (1) the direct non-financial stakeholders (employee, customers and suppliers), (2) the indirect stakeholders (environment and society) and (3) the financial stakeholders (stockholders and debt holders).We explore the link between stock returns and these three SR dimensions. Our main result is that being non-socially responsible in one or several of the three dimensions is compensated by significant risk premia in the market. The average premia over the period 2003-2010 are larger for the components “direct non-financial stakeholders” and “financial stakeholders” than for the component “indirect stakeholders”. For this last component, the premium obviously exists only since the end of 2008. Environment and community involvement have only recently become a more important risk factor in investors’ minds. About the former risk premia (“direct non-financial stakeholders” and “financial stakeholders”), investors appear to penalize firms with the worst behavior in respect to their direct non-financial stakeholders and reward firms with good corporate governance practices.