When the school door closes, do teachers open a window? Using diary method to investigate teachers’ online teaching practices and momentary experiences in crisis

Abstract

School closures due to the COVID-19 pandemic have had a major impact on teaching activities. Adopting a mixed-methods design, this study aims to categorize daily instructional practices in the early stages of school closure using two-cycle content analysis, present the transition of the categories over days, and test the differences between categories using ANOVA. A total of 48 high school teachers with varying levels of teaching readiness (measured by online professional development experience and distance teaching TPCK) kept teaching logs where they recorded daily teaching practices and assessed teaching satisfaction and perceived student engagement. They also submitted diary entries to report episodic optimal experience. Four salient emergency online teaching patterns emerged, which were further interpreted based on the Community of Inquiry framework (Garrison et al., 1999) as four presence orientations: 1) low social low cognitive, 2) low social high cognitive, 3) high social low cognitive, and 4) high social high cognitive. Daily transition of these orientations revealed slight to medium changes. Teachers adopting different orientations were found to differ in terms of teaching readiness, teaching satisfaction, and perceived student engagement. No difference was shown in optimal experience. The results inform future professional development programs how to prepare high school teachers for the next emergency crisis.