When a Palearctic bacterium meets a Nearctic insect vector: Genetic and ecological insights into the emergence of the grapevine Flavescence dorée epidemics in Europe.

Sylvie Malembic-Maher,Dima Khalil,Elisa Angelini,Delphine Desqué,Xavier Foissac,Michael Maixner,Barbara Jarausch,Marie-Pierre Dubrana-Ourabah,Jean-Luc Danet,Alberto Materazzi,Michele Della Bartola,Oliver Krstić,Jelena Jović,Bernard Bergey,Pascal Salar,Luisa Filippin,Friederike Lang,Ivo Toševski,Laure Béven ,I Ember ,Slobodan Krnjajić ,M Kölber ,Steven Duret ,Nathalie Arricau‐Bouvery ,Zoltán Ács

doi:10.1371/journal.ppat.1007967

Abstract

Flavescence dorée (FD) is a European quarantine grapevine disease transmitted by the Deltocephalinae leafhopper Scaphoideus titanus. Whereas this vector had been introduced from North America, the possible European origin of FD phytoplasma needed to be challenged and correlated with ecological and genetic drivers of FD emergence. For that purpose, a survey of genetic diversity of these phytoplasmas in grapevines, S. titanus, black alders, alder leafhoppers and clematis were conducted in five European countries. Out of 132 map genotypes, only 11 were associated to FD outbreaks, three were detected in clematis, whereas 127 were detected in alder trees, alder leafhoppers or in grapevines out of FD outbreaks. Most of the alder trees were found infected, including 8% with FD genotypes M6, M38 and M50, also present in alders neighboring FD-free vineyards and vineyard-free areas. The Macropsinae Oncopsis alni could transmit genotypes unable to achieve transmission by S. titanus, while the Deltocephalinae Allygus spp. and Orientus ishidae transmitted M38 and M50 that proved to be compatible with S. titanus. Variability of vmpA and vmpB adhesin-like genes clearly discriminated 3 genetic clusters. Cluster Vmp-I grouped genotypes only transmitted by O. alni, while clusters Vmp-II and -III grouped genotypes transmitted by Deltocephalinae leafhoppers. Interestingly, adhesin repeated domains evolved independently in cluster Vmp-I, whereas in clusters Vmp-II and–III showed recent duplications. Latex beads coated with various ratio of VmpA of clusters II and I, showed that cluster II VmpA promoted enhanced adhesion to the Deltocephalinae Euscelidius variegatus epithelial cells and were better retained in both E. variegatus and S. titanus midguts. Our data demonstrate that most FD phytoplasmas are endemic to European alders. Their emergence as grapevine epidemic pathogens appeared restricted to some genetic variants pre-existing in alders, whose compatibility to S. titanus correlates with different vmp gene sequences and VmpA binding properties.

Highlights

Grapevine Flavescence doree (FD) is a phytoplasma quarantine disease that emerged in the 1950s first in southwestern France and in the vineyards of ten European countries [1, 2]
Flavescence doree epidemics had been associated to the introduction of the North American leafhopper vector Scaphoideus titanus
We hereby show that the associated phytoplasma originated from European alders and that epidemics in grapevine are restricted to some phytoplasma genetic variants pre-existing in this wild asymptomatic plant host

Summary

Introduction

Grapevine Flavescence doree (FD) is a phytoplasma quarantine disease that emerged in the 1950s first in southwestern France and in the vineyards of ten European countries [1, 2]. The 16SrV-C alder phytoplasmas, which did not always provoke symptoms in their plant host, were shown to be transmitted from alder to alder by Oncopsis alni, a monophagous leafhopper of subfamily Macropsinae, which can transmit them to the vine [17,18,19]. These cases of grapevine yellows, called Palatinate grapevine yellows (PGY), were not transmissible by the S. titanus leafhopper [20]. The climbing shrub Clematis vitalba was found harboring 16SrV-C FDP, that could be transmitted to grapevine by the naturally

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion