What Types of Articles Does JBJS Reviews Prefer to Publish?

Abstract

Everyone appreciates a good review article. When comprehensive, well researched, well organized, and well written, a review article can be an essential part of every reader’s portfolio of knowledge. However, while the narrative or systematic format of most review articles may meet these qualifications, there are often missed opportunities for readers to derive the maximum benefit from these methods of communication. This is why JBJS Reviews provides 2 types of articles that take information in the literature to the next level of value: the Critical Analysis Review and the Team Approach article. Critical Analysis Review articles communicate clinical care recommendations that are derived from a complete evaluation of appropriate literature and are made explicit in a standard format known as a Recommendations for Care Table1. The added value of this information, which can pertain to treatment, diagnosis, or prognosis, is supported by the JBJS Levels of Evidence. As a result, the reader learns not only what information is current but also how reliable the information is and thus how dependable it may be for guiding clinical care. Team Approach articles focus on the multidisciplinary nature of musculoskeletal care by creating a clinical scenario and reviewing the potential input and involvement of key medical professionals in a co-management format2. A treatment recommendation from each specialist is presented in a logical sequence that reflects both the continuity of care and the collaborative approach. Although the Editor and the Board of Associate Editors are charged with making recommendations for invited articles, manuscripts submitted to JBJS Reviews need not always be invited. In fact, the majority of articles published to date have not been invited, which we view as a desirable trend. However, while the most outstanding narrative and Systematic Review articles will continue to be accepted, Critical Analysis Review and Team Approach articles will be preferred.