What is “technology integration” and how is it measured in K-12 education? A systematic review of survey instruments from 2010 to 2021

Abstract

This systematic review provides an overview and analysis of the survey instruments measuring technology integration (TI) in educational settings from 2010 to 2021. Given the importance of addressing aspects related to the quality of TI (e.g., the use of technology to support pedagogical goals), we paid particular attention to them. Search results from the PsycINFO, ERIC, Web of Science, and Scopus databases yielded 695 records. Thirty-five different survey instruments used in 36 studies met our eligibility criteria and were then analyzed by applying content analysis. Our results indicate that the diversity of operationalizations is very high and that several instruments have no explicit conceptual or theoretical underpinnings. Most of the instruments measure aspects related to classroom practices and measure TI from the teachers' point of view. The most frequently measured pedagogical aspects of TI in instructional practices include the use of technology to (1) enhance students’ cognitive engagement, (2) promote collaboration between students, and (3) allow students to conduct research online. The study concludes with some perspectives for future research, an attempt to formulate a definition of TI, and some more general recommendations to ensure terminological unambiguity in TI research.