What is it all about? An explorative study of patients’ experiences with medication free treatment

Abstract

BackgroundAs a response to the political decision by the Norwegian Ministry of Health and Care Services to establish some kind of “medication free treatment” for patients with severe mental illness throughout the country, a 6-bed ward unit dedicated to offer such treatment was in 2017 established in Tromsø, Norway by the North Norway Health Care Region. The aim of the present study was to explore the experiences of patients admitted to this ward unit.MethodSemi-structured interviews were conducted with 19 persons who had received treatment from the ward during the period January 2017 to October 2021. Analysis was done in line with Systematic Text Condensation and interviews were recorded, transcribed and analyzed using software NVivo.ResultsThe importance of engaging in a dialogue about the possibilities of living a life without medication was unanimously validated, along with a focus on empowerment, motivation, activity and flexibility. Not everyone reported fulfillment of their own wishes or the ward’s goal of tapering down, and reflected upon emotions such as ambivalence or fear. Three core concepts were identified to describe the participants’ experiences: 1) Tapering off, 2) Relations, and 3) Frames and content. A fourth concept overarches the process formed by these concepts; 4) Processes across categories.ConclusionThe study contributes to a deeper understanding of what "medication free" truly means, going beyond simply taking or not taking medications. It adds nuance to the debate surrounding medication free treatment. The ability to taper off medications is linked to intrapersonal factors, such as readiness and personal commitment, as well as the therapeutic environment, including the frames and values present on the ward. "Medication free" is more complex than it may initially appear, as many participants continue to use some form of psychotropic drugs. The sense of being part of something new and "exclusive" can be understood in light of what participants felt was lacking in previous treatment. It appears to be a need of rediscovering the significance of empowerment and empathic relationships in treatment of severe mental illness, in order to foster a sense of coherence and meaning.