Wetland Restoration through Excavation: Sediment Removal Results in Dramatic Water Quality Improvement

Abstract

We evaluated whether sediment excavation improved water quality in a former (pre-European settlement) wetland complex that was a farm in the early 1900s and then later in the 1990s/early 2000s was allowed to naturally refill with water and became nutrient-rich ponds plagued by legacy phosphorus issues. Two ponds were recently restored via dewatering, excavation of the surface sediment, and hydrologic reconnection to an adjacent creek to re-establish a flow-through marsh. The removal of ~103,000 m3 of phosphorus-laden sediment and reconnection to the adjacent stream resulted in improved water quality, with a reduction in total phosphorus concentration from ~1000 μg/L to ~20 μg/L and a 40% reduction in specific conductivity in both former ponds. Soluble reactive phosphorus concentrations declined substantially in one pond, from ~720 μg/L to 3 μg/L, but not in another pond, which was partially dredged by the landowner prior to restoration. Additionally, phosphorus concentration in the downstream receiving water body also declined but to a much more modest degree. Sediment excavation was an effective restoration tool in this former agricultural system, but given the expense and potential impact on pre-existing biota, a full-system diagnosis, including cost, sediment characterization, and control of external nutrient loading, is recommended before its implementation elsewhere.