Weevils and Watermilfoil: Did a North American Herbivore Cause the Decline of an Exotic Plant?

Abstract

The Eurasian watermilfoil (Myriophyllum spicatum) population in Brownington Pond, Vermont, declined between 1986 and 1989. Watermilfoil covered ≈10‐11 ha of the littoral zone in 1986. Less than 0.5 ha remained in 1989. An herbivorous weevil (Euhrychiopsis lecontei), which is native to North America, was found associated with this watermilfoil population and we hypothesized that this weevil played a role in the decline. We monitored watermilfoil and E. lecontei populations in Brownington Pond from 1990 through 1992 by (1) mapping the location and extent of beds in the pond, and (2) determining watermilfoil biomass along permanent transects. The abundance of weevil eggs, larvae, pupae, and adults were monitored by sampling individual watermilfoil stems. Watermilfoil cover increased to ≈ 2.5 ha by 1991 and then declined again to ≈1 ha by 1992. The reduction in watermilfoil biomass from 1991 to 1992 ranged from 4‐ to 30‐fold depending on location. Mean weevil abundance increased from 1990 (<1/stem) through early 1992 (3‐4/stem) and then began to decline. The number of weevil eggs/stem also peaked in early 1992 and then declined. These survey results are consistent with the hypothesis that the weevil played an important role in producing both observed declines. The effect of weevils on watermilfoil was evaluated in two experiments. In an aquarium experiment, we found that the viability of stem fragments damaged by weevils was reduced compared to stem fragments without weevil damage. Watermilfoil commonly spreads by producing fragments so the spread of watermilfoil beds by fragmentation may be reduced when weevil abundances are high. In a pond enclosure experiment, weevils suppressed the production of new watermilfoil biomass. The biomass of lateral stems and roots of watermilfoil plants damaged by weevils was significantly less than those of control plants. There was no significant difference in the biomass of the stems originally planted in the enclosures. Weevil damage did have a negative effect on the buoyancy of these original stems, however. These experimental results also support the hypothesis that this native weevil played an important role in the two watermilfoil declines observed at Brownington Pond.