Wear Mechanisms, Composition and Thickness of Antiwear Tribofilms Formed from Multi-Component Lubricants.

Abstract

The antiwear properties of tribofilms formed on steel surfaces lubricated with various multi-component lubricants were investigated at an elevated temperature and under load-speed conditions conducive to sliding in the boundary lubrication regime. The lubricants contained base oil, reduced-level (secondary) zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate (ZDDP), and nitrogenous dispersant. The wear resistance of the tribofilms produced from different oil blends was evaluated in the context of the rate of change in the sliding track volume (wear rate for material loss) and the load-bearing capacity, chemical composition, and thickness of the tribofilms. Surface profilometry and scanning electron microscopy were used to quantify the wear performance and detect the prevailing wear mechanisms, whereas X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy elucidated the chemical composition and thickness of the tribofilms. The oil blends without ZDDP did not produce tribofilms with adequate antiwear properties, whereas the oil blends containing ZDDP and dispersant generated tribofilms with antiwear characteristics comparable to those of tribofilms produced from blends with a higher ZDDP content. Although dispersants can suspend oil contaminants and preserve the cleanness of the sliding surfaces, it was found that they can also reduce the antiwear efficacy of ZDDP. This was attributed to an additive-dispersant antagonistic behavior for surface adsorption sites affecting tribofilm chemistry and mechanical properties. Among the blends containing a mixture of ZDDP and dispersant, the best antiwear properties were demonstrated by the tribofilm produced from the blend consisting of base oil, 0.05 wt% ZDDP, and a bis-succinimide dispersant treated with ethylene carbonate. The findings of this investigation demonstrate the potential of multi-component lubricants with reduced-content ZDDP and nitrogen-based dispersant to form effective antiwear tribofilms.