Weakly abelian lattice-ordered groups

Abstract

Every nilpotent lattice-ordered group is weakly Abelian; i.e., satisfies the identity $x^{-1}(y\vee 1)x\vee (y\vee 1)^2=(y\vee 1)^2$. In 1984, V. M. Kopytov asked if every weakly Abelian lattice-ordered group belongs to the variety generated by all nilpotent lattice-ordered groups [The Black Swamp Problem Book, Question 40]. In the past 15 years, all attempts have centred on finding counterexamples. We show that two constructions of weakly Abelian lattice-ordered groups fail to be counterexamples. They include all preiously considered potential counterexamples and also many weakly Abelian ordered free groups on finitely many generators. If every weakly Abelian ordered free group on finitely many generators belongs to the variety generated by all nilpotent lattice-ordered groups, then every weakly Abelian lattice-ordered group belongs to this variety. This paper therefore redresses the balance and suggests that Kopytov’s problem is even more intriguing.