Water isotopic constraints on the enhancement of the mid-Holocene West African monsoon

Abstract

During the early to mid-Holocene, changes in orbital precession led to considerable increases in West African monsoon (WAM) rainfall compared to today and shifted its reach further north. However, climate proxies and paleoclimate model simulations disagree over fundamental aspects of the mid-Holocene (MH; 6 ka BP) enhancement of the WAM. Here, we use a water isotope-enabled Earth system model (iCESM1) to, for the first time, directly compare simulated northern African hydroclimatic change between the mid-Holocene and pre-industrial era (PI) with the hydroclimate signal inferred from leaf wax n-alkanes in order to study the WAM's past spatial change. iCESM1 simulates a northernmost WAM extent of ∼24°N, which broadly agrees with the extent inferred from pollen and dust records (23–28°N) but falls short of that from leaf wax n-alkanes (27–31°N). While the isotopic composition of rainfall (δDP) inferred from leaf wax n-alkanes is lower during the MH than the PI, simulated MH δDP is higher in northwestern Africa, especially in boreal fall. This discrepancy can be reconciled by interpreting the inferred signal of leaf wax n-alkanes as being reflective of the isotopic composition of soil water (δDS) and its subsequent influence by soil evaporation. We postulate that leaf wax n-alkanes may overestimate inferred mean annual precipitation rates in the MH by not incorporating the enrichment of precipitation shown by iCESM1. Our results have broad implications for reconstruction of past hydrologic change in northern Africa and lend further support to the northernmost WAM extents inferred from pollen and dust records.