Water and nutrient retention in coarse-textured soil profiles from the Athabasca oil sand region

Abstract

Post-mining land reclamation of Athabasca Oil Sands (AB, Canada) involves the reconstruction of soil profiles able to support a mosaic of boreal forest communities. However, the use of coarse-textured reclamation materials to recreate forest ecosystems represents a challenge in terms of soil water and nutrient availability. This work aimed to quantify nutrient leaching in reclaimed coarse-textured soils constructed with two coversoils (peat mineral mix and forest floor mineral mix) underlain by mineral materials, including a blended B/C subsoil reclamation material, lean oil sand overburden substrate, and tailing sand. Water retention and conductivity curves were estimated for each material, and their retention capacity for inorganic N and P was measured in sorption isotherm experiments. The redistribution of water, inorganic N and P five days after an intense rain event was evaluated in six different reclaimed soil profiles using a laboratory-controlled leaching experiment in 1.2-m deep columns. The redistribution of fertilizer nutrients was also measured following the addition of 15N-labelled ammonium and phosphate over the top 10 cm of the columns. In addition, a 25-day incubation experiment with the two coversoils enabled us to estimate the timing of N immobilization and nitrification processes. Our results show that, depending on the combination of materials used for land reclamation, the soil profiles may provide equal or higher amounts of inorganic N and P in the rooting zone compared to natural, coarse-textured soils of the region. Following the simulated intense rainfall, the peat-mineral mix was able to retain 44% of its initial inorganic N within the top 20 cm of the reclaimed soil profiles, while 84% of the inorganic N present in the forest floor mineral mix was leached down. Compared to the movement of water, the leaching of N down the soil profiles was slower and partly restricted by the presence of lean oil sand, and to a lesser degree tailing sand. Most of the introduced fertilizer-N remained in the first 20 cm of the soil profiles under the form of nitrate, although the incubation experiment suggested that nitrification only occurred after the simulated rainfall event. Based on our experimental data and on additional simulations of water and nutrient transport, we conclude that nutrient leaching in reclaimed soils can be significant if specific materials such as forest floor mineral material and coarse-textured subsoil are combined and when an intense rainfall occurs at a period coinciding with a high concentration of nitrate-N in the topsoil.