Was the decline of saltmarsh tabanid populations after the 2010 oil spill associated with change in the larval food web?

Abstract

AbstractHorse flies of the species Tabanus nigrovittatus and Tabanus acutus are native to coastal marshlands. Their larvae are apex invertebrate predators, and their development is dependent on the food web in the marsh sediment. Surveillance of T. nigrovittatus after the 2010 Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill in the Gulf of Mexico showed population crashes of adult flies in southeast Louisiana marshes near oil landfall, but not in southwest Louisiana where oil did not reach. Sediment collection in 2011 from Louisiana marshes showed a near‐complete absence of larvae in the southeast yet high numbers in the southwest. We hypothesized that oil contamination destroyed critical components of the larval food web and/or residual toxicity led to larval death. We used 18S rRNA gene metagenomics to identify components of the food web in larval guts and sediment from southeast and southwest Louisiana marshes. Sediment oil contamination, biochemistry, and toxicity could not explain the lack of larvae in the southeast, because oiling at our high‐tide mark sites was low at the time of the study and toxicity was independent of sediment biochemistry. Hexapods were the main food web components in tabanid larval guts. Abundance of stink bug, vinegar fly, and mosquito species in the sediment was positively associated with the presence of larvae. However, these taxa were enriched in southeastern (near oil) versus southwestern (unoiled reference) sediment, and thus, lack of major food web components due to oiling could not explain lack of larva in the east. We conclude that the immediate crash in adult populations in oiled regions was the main cause for the absence of larvae the following year. While most saltmarsh arthropod groups had rebounded within a year after the oil spill, recovery of saltmarsh horse flies was ongoing for 5 years.