Abstract
This essay reads Marvell’s mower poems and ‘The Garden’ as case studies in the ethics of vulnerability that collectively work to illuminate a potential for joyful connection—with people, but also with the natural world—in the practice of critique, which otherwise has a melancholic potential for over-identifying with its object. Whereas vulnerability commonly denotes susceptibility to harm, this essay builds on the work of Erinn Gilson to show that vulnerability is ontological, a shared feature of human existence that makes both harm and connection possible. Vulnerability figures in the poems through the relationships they depict: between the mower and himself, Juliana, and the grass. As a counterbalance to the various strategies that they deploy to escape the vulnerability (and potentiality for harm) occasioned by these relationships, the poems also present the possibility of an ‘innocent’, non-violent relationship of mutual fruitfulness with the grass—a possibility that at least hypothetically extends to relationships with other people. These latter possibilities suggest a form of critique that escapes its melancholic temperament—the presumption that the world portends only harm—and allows even complicity to contain the potential for joyful, mutual, and fruitful connection with others.
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have