Abstract
The article discusses factors, determining loyalty of the European Parliament members, which is marginalized in most of researches on the European Parliament. The initial assumption holds that as given the rates of loyalty to the national states are high it is groundless to assess it as a neutral variable. Loyalty of the European Parliament members to national states can significantly contribute to the studies of European Parliament’s internal relations and power contribution.The first section of this article presents and analyses main insights of the influence of national parties and political groups on the voting behavior of the European Parliament members, justifying objective reasons which caused marginalization of importance of the European Parliament members’ loyalty to national states. It should be noted that the European Parliament members, like most of other politicians, have fixed set of objectives forming their choices. Goals of re-election, positions and policy (leading to power gains/losses) are leading. In the hands of national parties and political groups these goals become instruments of pressure and enforcement, determining behavior of the European Parliament members. National parties controlling the access of candidates to the electoral lists and defining their position on those lists gain extreme importance in the competition for loyalty. Since political groups of the European Parliament have dominant political force for the second objective of the parliament members each of them have an interest in maintaining balance between loyalty to the national party and particular political group. Loyalty to national states loses its importance as it has minimal influence on the success of achieving objectives of the parliament members.The second section is devoted to the research of links between voting of European Parliament members and their national states, more specifically – to the analysis of European Parliament members’ loyalty to their national states. Lithuania is chosen as a case study. The fact that loyalty to the national states during 2004–2009 and 2009–2014 terms of the European Parliament is over 85 % indicates that this variable should not be seen as accidental or insignificant. It is argued that loyalty to the national state mainly reflects voting unity of national delegation. The rest of this section analyzes factors which can explain why, despite the fact that national delegation is very diverse in the context of left-right ideological divide, rates of loyalty to the national states, demonstrated by the national delegations, remain very high.The article concludes stating that loyalty of European Parliament members to their national states is a valuable source of data for the analysis of the party behavior in the European Parliament as well as outside it and should not be overlooked.
Highlights
Lindberg B., „Are political parties controlling legislative decision-making in the European Parliament? The case of services directive“, Journal of European Public Policy 15:8, 2008, p. 1186
The article concludes stating that loyalty of European Parliament members to their national states is a valuable source of data for the analysis of the party behavior in the European Parliament as well as outside it and should not be overlooked
Summary
Straipsnyje analizuojami veiksniai, lemiantys Europos Parlamento tyrimuose marginalizuotą Europos Parlamento narių lojalumo nacionalinėms valstybėms rodiklį. Straipsnyje bandoma ne užginčyti faktą, kad Europos Parlamento narių balsavimą geriausiai paaiškina ideologinė, o ne nacionalinė dimensija, bet atskleisti, jog lojalumas nacionalinei valstybei irgi gali būti vertinamas ne kaip tautinis, o kaip ideologinis rodiklis. Šiame straipsnyje siekiama ne užginčyti faktą, kad EP narių balsavimą geriausiai paaiškina ideologinė, o ne nacionalinė dimensija, bet atskleisti, kad lojalumas nacionalinei valstybei irgi gali būti vertinamas ne kaip tautinis, o kaip ideologinis rodiklis, taip praturtinant dabartinius tyrimus nauju rodikliu. Key gatekeepers) laikytinos nacionalinės partijos[5], tad tai gali būti įvardijama kaip viena priežasčių, kodėl narių lojalumas nacionalinėms partijoms išlieka labai didelis ne vien dėl perrinkimo užsitikrinimo. Ne mažiau svarbus yra ir kitas mokslininkų pastebėjimas, kad EP narių balsavimo elgseną tiek EP frakcijų viduje, tiek tarp jų daugiausia lemia būtent nacionalinių partijų kairės–dešinės politinės preferencijos, o ne frakcijos galimybės spausti ir kontroliuoti[12]. Policy 15:8, 2008, p. 1256. 13 Rasmussen A., „Party soldiers in a non-partisan community? Party linkage in the European Parliament“, Journal of European Public Policy 15:8, 2008, p. 1168
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.