Vibratory Impact of 3 Different Ambulance Suspension Systems on the Simulated Neonate and Health Care Provider During Normal Driving Conditions

Abstract

ObjectivePatients and health care providers experience varying degrees of vibration during interfacility ground transport. The impact of vibration on term and preterm neonates may result in physiologic instability and increased risk of intracranial hemorrhage, whereas the impact on health care providers has been shown to include an increase in perceived and physiologic stress levels and may contribute to chronic back and neck pain. This study aimed to evaluate 3 common ambulance suspension systems and the corresponding vibratory impact produced during typical interfacility driving conditions on adult caregiver and neonatal patient mannequins. MethodsType 3 ambulances with air, liquid, and traditional suspensions were evaluated using various driving tests to simulate typical road conditions. Vibrations were measured using triaxial accelerometers placed on the chassis, upon the head of a seated caregiver mannequin in the ambulance bench seat, and the head of a neonatal mannequin supine and secured in an isolette. Data analysis included the average vibration frequency, root mean square values, and maximum vibration amplitudes. ResultsThe results showed that the supine neonatal mannequin experienced the highest vibration frequency and amplitude in the vertical (x) direction, whereas the adult caregiver mannequin experienced higher vibration frequencies in both parallel (y) and lateral (z) directions and the highest vibration amplitude in the y direction. The liquid suspension system consistently demonstrated the lowest vibration levels in all driving conditions and directions, whereas traditional suspension had the highest values. ConclusionThis study provides important insights into the vibrations incurred by simulated neonatal patients and health care providers during ambulance transport. The directional vibration frequency and amplitude differ between a neonatal mannequin and an adult mannequin when placed in typical positions with typical restraints during varied ambulance driving conditions. In all directional movements and driving conditions, a liquid suspension system decreases vibration frequency and amplitude more than air or traditional systems. The live patient and caregiver impact of these results should be further investigated.