Viability of an isocentric cobalt-60 teletherapy unit for stereotactic radiosurgery.

Abstract

The potential for radiosurgery with an isocentric teletherapy cobalt unit was evaluated in three areas: (1) the physical properties of radiosurgical beams, (2) the quality of radiosurgical dose distributions obtained with four to ten noncoplanar converging arcs, and (3) the accuracy with which the radiosurgical dose can be delivered. In each of these areas the cobalt unit provides a viable alternative to an isocentric linear accelerator (linac) as a radiation source for radiosurgery. A 10 MV x-ray beam from a linac used for radiosurgery served as a standard for comparison. The difference between the 80%-20% penumbras of stationary radiosurgical fields in the nominal diameter range from 10 to 40 mm of the cobalt-60 and 10 MV photon beams is remarkably small, with the cobalt-60 beam penumbras, on average, only about 0.7 mm larger than those of the linac beam. Differences between the cobalt-60 and 10 MV radiosurgical treatment plans in terms of dose homogeneity within the target volume, conformity of the prescribed isodose volume to the target volume, and dose falloffs outside the target volume are also minimal, and therefore of essentially no clinical significance. Moreover, measured isodose distributions for a radiosurgical procedure on our Theratron T-780 cobalt unit agreed with calculated distributions to within the +/- 1 mm spatial and +/- 5% numerical dose tolerances, which are generally specified for radiosurgery. The viability of isocentric cobalt units for radiosurgery will be of particular interest to centers in developing countries where cobalt units, because of their relatively low costs, provide the only megavoltage source of radiation for radiotherapy, and could easily and inexpensively be modified for radiosurgery. Of course, the quality assurance protocols and mechanical condition of a particular teletherapy cobalt unit must meet stringent requirements before the use of the unit for radiosurgery can be advocated.